The intensity of perturbations rises with the cost of incorrect signals, b. The direct character has an independent cost, c. (A–C) The optimal value of the buffering character, τ*, when both the buffering character and the direct character evolve freely. (D–F) The optimal value of the direct character. The solid line shows δ*, when both the direct and buffering character evolve freely. The dashed line shows , the evolutionary response of the direct character when the buffering character is constrained to
, as explained in the text. (G–I) The ratio of fitness, w, when both characters evolve freely to {δ*,τ*} relative to when τ is fixed and δ evolves freely to the point
. The ratio shows the net benefit of robustness in terms of enhanced fitness from buffering against perturbations.