Correction
26 Mar 2018: Póvoa TF, Oliveira ERA, Basílio-de-Oliveira CA, Nuovo GJ, Chagas VLA, et al. (2018) Correction: Peripheral Organs of Dengue Fatal Cases Present Strong Pro-Inflammatory Response with Participation of IFN-Gamma-, TNF-Alpha- and RANTES-Producing Cells. PLOS ONE 13(3): e0195140. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0195140 View correction
Figures
Abstract
Dengue disease is an acute viral illness caused by dengue virus (DENV) that can progress to hemorrhagic stages leading to about 20000 deaths every year worldwide. Despite many clinical investigations regarding dengue, the immunopathogenic process by which infected patients evolve to the severe forms is not fully understood. Apart from differences in virulence and the antibody cross reactivity that can potentially augment virus replication, imbalanced cellular immunity is also seen as a major concern in the establishment of severe dengue. In this context, the investigation of cellular immunity and its products in dengue fatal cases may provide valuable data to help revealing dengue immunopathogenesis. Here, based in four dengue fatal cases infected by the serotype 3 in Brazil, different peripheral organs (livers, lungs and kidneys) were studied to evaluate the presence of cell infiltrates and the patterns of local cytokine response. The overall scenario of the studied cases revealed a considerable systemic involvement of infection with mononuclear cells targeted to all of the evaluated organs, as measured by immunohistochemistry (IHC). Quantification of cytokine-expressing cells in peripheral tissues was also performed to characterize the ongoing inflammatory process by the severe stage of the disease. Increased levels of IFN-γ- and TNF-α-expressing cells in liver, lung and kidney samples of post-mortem subjects evidenced a strong pro-inflammatory induction in these tissues. The presence of increased RANTES-producing cell numbers in all analyzed organs suggested a possible link between the clinical status and altered vascular permeability. Co-staining of DENV RNA and IFN-γ or TNF-α using in situ hibridization and IHC confirmed the virus-specific trigger of the pro-inflammatory response. Taken together, this work provided additional evidences that corroborated with the traditional theories regarding the “cytokine storm” and the occurrence of uneven cellular immunity in response to DENV as major reasons for progress to severe disease.
Citation: Póvoa TF, Oliveira ERA, Basílio-de-Oliveira CA, Nuovo GJ, Chagas VLA, Salomão NG, et al. (2016) Peripheral Organs of Dengue Fatal Cases Present Strong Pro-Inflammatory Response with Participation of IFN-Gamma-, TNF-Alpha- and RANTES-Producing Cells. PLoS ONE 11(12): e0168973. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0168973
Editor: Dong-Yan Jin, University of Hong Kong, HONG KONG
Received: June 24, 2016; Accepted: December 10, 2016; Published: December 22, 2016
Copyright: © 2016 Póvoa et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: This work was funded by the Fundação Carlos Chagas Filho de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado do Rio de Janeiro (FAPERJ, Grant: E-26/110.511/2014) www.faperj.br to MVP. The funder had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Dengue is considered the most important mosquito-borne viral disease due to its clinical relevance and rapid spread, nowadays putting at risk about half of the world’s population [1]. The etiologic agent, dengue virus (DENV), is distributed as four distinct serotypes (DENV1 to DENV4) and infections can result in a mild flu-like acute illness known as dengue fever (DF) [2]. From an epidemiological view, it is estimated that 390 million dengue infections occur each year, of which nearly 25% are symptomatic [3]. While most patients naturally recover from the non-severe clinical DF course, a small proportion evolves to severe disease, mostly characterized by plasma leakage and hemorrhagic manifestations (namely dengue shock syndrome—DSS and dengue hemorrhagic fever—DHF) [2, 4]. Despite the relevant mortality rates derived from dengue complications (arround 20000 deaths each year) [5], the elucidation of the pathogenic process by which infected patients evolve to the severe forms is still an ongoing challenge. Apart from the relationship between social determinants of health and dengue fatal cases, biological factors such as distinct virulence levels among virus strains and host immunity have been considered as key elements to drive patients to severe stages [6, 7]. Disease complications triggered by DENV enhanced infections assisted by previously-formed opsonizing antibodies, were related to altered T cell activation and cytokine production in secondary infections [8–10]. Yet, concerning a host primary response environment, other unknown factors could also play a role in triggering severe dengue. Classical DF symptoms, such as fever and headaches, usually match with high viremia levels, but interestingly the severe forms of dengue (DSS/DHF), when manifested, occur after virus clearance. This observation has raised concerns about the association of severe dengue with immonopathological mechanisms [11, 12].
In this context, the investigation of post-mortem severe dengue cases may represent a valuable tool for a better understanding of the immune scenario during a terminal stage. Additionally, a search for evidences regarding cell migration and cytokine production in peripheral tissues may also provide new insights about possible underpinning immune mechanisms linked to the development of severe forms. In a previous report of our laboratory, peripheral organs such as livers, lungs and kidneys of four dengue cases that died from DENV-3 were histopathologically and ultrastructurally screened [13]. Aside from virus detection in unusual sites such as hepatocytes and type II pneumocytes, all studied organs presented lesions that corresponded to severe dengue cases. In this work, the same post-mortem samples were object of study for investigation of the cellular immune response and its products. Immunohistochemical analysis revealed a systemic involvement of infection with mononuclear cells targeted to all of the analyzed tissues. Assessment of local cytokine response showed increased levels of IFN-γ- and TNF-α-expressing cells in livers, lungs and kidneys that evidenced a consistent pro-inflammatory induction in these tissues. Co-expression of DENV RNA and IFN-γ or TNF-α by Kupffer cells confirmed the specific DENV induction over the cytokine production, as found by in situ hibridization and IHC. Furthermore, an indicative of altered vascular permeability found in all analyzed organs was also suggested due to the presence of increased levels of local RANTES-producing cells.
Ultimately, this work brought additional evidences that the effect of the uneven cellular immunity in response to DENV can contribute to disease severity. Given the limited numbers of reports concerning investigation of post-mortem samples from dengue severe cases, this work importantly contributes to narrowing the gaps of dengue immunopathogenesis.
Materials and Methods
Ethical procedures
All procedures performed during this work were approved by the Ethics Committee of the Oswaldo Cruz Foundation/FIOCRUZ, with the number CAEE: 47525115.3.0000.5248 for studies with dengue fatal cases and controls. The use of tissue samples informed consent was verbally provided by family members to the responsible physician Dr. Carlos Alberto Basíllio de Oliveira by the time of the necropsy. This consent procedure was approved by the ethics committee.
Human fatal cases
The human tissues analyzed in this study (livers, lungs and kidneys) were obtained from four dengue fatal cases that occurred during a Brazilian outbreak of DENV-3 in 2002 in Rio de Janeiro. All patients died with a clinical diagnosis of severe dengue with infections confirmed by positive serum IgM antibodies. The four negative controls, from both sexes and ranging from 40 to 60 year old, were non-dengue and did not present any other infectious disease. More information about these cases can be found in a previous report of our laboratory [13]. Briefly:
Case 1.
A 63-year-old male patient that developed a sudden onset of headache, myalgia, anorexia and abdominal pain. A few days later the patient presented diarrhea, thrombocytopenia (platelet 79.000/mm3) and hemoconcentration (hematocrit 59%). The case eventually evolved to shock with severe pulmonary congestion followed by death with a clinical diagnosis of dengue hemorrhagic fever.
Case 2.
A 21-year-old female patient who experienced fever, myalgia and headache with progression to metrorrhagia, nausea, vomiting and diarrhea. The patient also presented severe leukopenia and thrombocytopenia (platelet 10.000/mm3). During hospitalization, the case progressed to respiratory failure, followed by evolution of multiple organ failure and refractory shock.
Histopathological analysis
Tissue samples from the human necropsies were fixed in formalin (10%), blocked in paraffin resin, cut in 4 μm, deparaffinized in xylene and rehydrated with alcohol, as described previously [14]. Sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H.E.) for histological examination and visualized under a Nikon ECLIPSE E600 microscope.
Immunohistochemical procedure
For immunohistochemical studies, the paraffin-embedded tissues were cut (sections of 4 μm), deparaffinized in xylene and rehydrated with alcohol. Antigen retrieval was performed by heating the tissue in the presence of citrate buffer [15]. Tissues were blocked for endogenous peroxidase with 3% hydrogen peroxidase in methanol and rinsed in Tris-HCl (pH 7.4). To reduce non-specific binding, sections were incubated for 30 min at room temperature. Samples were then incubated over-night at 4°C with anti-human antibodies that recognize CD4 (Spring Bioscence, CA, USA), CD8 (DAKOCytomation, CA, USA), CD20 (Biocare Medical, CA, USA), CD68 (Biocare Medical, CA, USA), IFNγ (Abbiotec, CA, USA), TNFα (Abbiotec, CA, USA), IL-10 (Abbiotec, CA, USA), RANTES/CCL5 (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, CA, USA) or TGF-β (Abbiotec, CA, USA). The next day, sections were incubated with rabbit anti-mouse IgG, a secondary antibody horseradish peroxidase (HRP) conjugate (Spring Bioscience, CA, USA), for 30 min at room temperature. For negative control of the immunohistochemical reactions, samples were incubated only with the secondary HRP-conjugated antibody. Reactions were revealed with diaminobenzidine (Dako, CA, USA) as a chromogen and the sections were counterstained in Meyer’s hematoxylin (Dako). Finally, samples were examined under a Nikon ECLIPSE E600 microscope.
Quantification of positive cells by immunohistochemistry
Slides were evaluated using a Nikon ECLIPSE E600 microscope with a coupled Cool SNAP-Procf Color camera. For each specific antibody, 50 images (fields) were randomly acquired at 400x magnification using the software Image Pro version 4.5. After collecting the frames, positive cells were quantified in each of the 50 fields in every organ and the median of positive cell number was determined. All analyzes were accomplished in a blind test without prior knowledge of the studied groups. After quantification, frames exhibited in figures were selected as to be more informative according to specific areas in the analyzed tissues. S1 Table contains the raw data.
In Situ Hybridization
The assessment of DENV in liver sections was performed by in situ hybridization using a digoxigenin-tagged probe (5’-TGACCATCATGGACCTCCA-3’) which anneals within the negative strand of the DENV RNA genome, as previously described [13]. Briefly, paraffin-embedded sections of tissues were deparaffinized and digested with pepsin (1.3 mg/ ml) for 4 min at room temperature. Tissues were incubated with the probe cocktail at 60°C for 5 min and then kept overnight at 37°C for denaturation and hybridization, respectively. Next, samples were washed with 0.2 x SSC and 2% bovine serum albumin at 55°C for 5 min. The probe-target complexes were revealed by the activity of alkaline phosphatase conjugated to anti-digoxigenin.
Co-staining of DENV RNA and pro-inflammatory cytokines
Co-staining of virus and IFNγ or TNFα were performed, as previously described [13], using in situ hybridization and immunohistochemistry. The dengue case 2 was considered for this analysis. Briefly, the DENV probe was first tagged with 59 digoxigenin and locked nucleic acid (LNA) modified (Exiqon). Resulting complexes were visualized using an antidigoxigenin-alkaline phosphates conjugate and nitro-blue tetrazolium and 5-bromo-4-chloro-39-indolyphosphate as the chromogen. Detection of IFNγ or TNFα was then performed by immunohistochemistry (anti-IFNγ antibody—ABCAM ab133566-rabbit and anti-TNFα—ABCAM ab6671-rabbit) using Leica Bond Max automated platform (Leica Biosystems) and DAB as the chromogen. No counterstain was done. Data were analyzed by the computer based Nuance system (Caliper Life Sciences, Hopkinton, MA, USA) which separates the different chromogenic signals, converts them to fluorescent-based signals and combine them to determine co-expression.
Results
The liver as a target of immune-mediated mechanisms in dengue fatal cases
The liver is considered as an important target for DENV infection and is the most common organ to be involved in the disease. Hepatic alterations are key characteristics found in DENV cases. As observed in biopsies and autopsies of previously reported fatal cases [16], hepatocytes and Kupffer cells are described as important targets during DENV infection [17, 18]. For this reason, liver samples of the four DENV-3 fatal cases were first considered for our evaluations.
Histopathological studies of all samples showed diffuse mononuclear cell infiltrates, mainly around the portal space (Fig 1 panel a). Detection of CD68+ cells revealed the presence of hyperplasic Kupffer cells and/or circulating macrophages (Fig 1 panel b), although quantification analysis did not show statistical difference when comparing dengue to control samples (Fig 1 panel c). Yet, we detected numerous CD4+ (Fig 1 panel d), and CD8+ (Fig 1 panel f) T cells placed mainly in sinusoidal capillaries. Quantification of these cell populations showed a significant increase in the number of T lymphocytes present in liver samples of dengue cases when compared to controls (about 5 and 3 fold, respectively—Fig 1 panels e and g).
Sections were stained with (a) H.E. or (b, d, f) incubated with specific antibodies in immunohistochemical assays. (a) Liver of a representative dengue case showing diffuse mononuclear infiltrates around the portal space; (b) detection of hyperplasic Kupffer cells (CD68+) observed mainly in sinusoidal capillaries of the dengue cases; (c) quantification of CD68+ cells in dengue cases and controls (non-dengue cases); (d) detection of CD4+ cells manly in portal space of the dengue cases; (e) quantification of CD4+ cells in controls and dengue cases; (f) CD8+ cells detected mainly in portal space; (g) quantification of CD8+ cells. MI—mononuclear cell infiltrates. Asterisks indicate differences that are statistically significant between dengue cases and control groups, (*p < 0.05). Staining controls are shown in S1 Fig.
In order to qualify the ongoing inflammatory process in the hepatic tissue, we also investigated the cytokine production by the mononuclear cell types found in the liver. In this case, cells expressing TNF-α, IFN-γ, IL-10, TGF-β and RANTES were considered for quantification. We observed a great number of cells producing these cytokines in the midzonal area and, to a lesser extent, in other hepatic areas. Production of TNF-α was detected by Kupffer cells and monocytes, mainly in the sinusoidal capillaries (Fig 2 panel a), while detection of IFN-γ was found mostly in lymphocytes, Kupffer cells and monocytes (Fig 2 panels b and c). In sinusoidal capillaries, we also detected groups of cells with an anti-inflammatory profile, such as IL-10-expressing monocytes and lymphocytes (Fig 2 panel d) and TGF-β-expressing macrophages and Kupffer cells (Fig 2 panel h). The chemokine RANTES/CCL5 was detected mainly in endothelium and Kupffer cells (Fig 2 panels i and j). Quantification of cells producing the inflammatory cytokines TNF-α, IFN-γ and RANTES/CCL5 revealed a significant increase (4-, 4.5- and 3-fold, respectively) in dengue group compared to control (Fig 2 panels e, f and l), while the number of cells expressing the anti-inflammatory cytokines IL-10 and TGF-β did not change significantly in either group (Fig 2 panels g and k).
(a) Detection of TNF-α in macrophages and Kupffer cells in sinusoidal capillaries; (b and c) detection of INF-α in Kupffer cells and lymphocytes; (d) production of anti-inflammatory cytokines (IL-10 in monocytes and lymphocytes circulating in sinusoidal capillaries and TGFβ detected in macrophages inside the portal space; (h) TGF-β-expressing macrophages and Kupffer cells in sinusoidal capillaries; (i and j) detection of RANTES in endothelium and Kupffer cells; (e, f, g, k and l) quantification of the number of cells expressing these cytokines in the hepatic tissue. Monocytes (Mo); Macrophages (Mϕ); Kupffer cells (KC); lymphocyte (Ly) and sinusoidal endothelium cells (E). Asterisks indicate differences that are statistically significant between groups (*p < 0.05). Staining controls are shown in S1 Fig.
Histopathological analysis and cytokine profile present in the lungs of dengue fatal cases
Previous studies in our laboratory revealed that lung tissues from fatal dengue cases showed severe damages as represented by diffuse areas of hemorrhage and edema [13]. Here, we aimed to investigate a possible contribution of an exacerbated pro-inflammatory response that could be related to this local tissue impairment.
After analysis of lung sections of dengue cases we observed a diffuse mononuclear infiltrate in alveolar septa and edema areas (Fig 3 panel a), thus, indicating that this tissue could also be targeted by immune mechanisms triggered by infection. The immunohistochemical assay revealed the presence of macrophages (CD68+ cells) (Fig 3 panel b) in alveolar septa, CD4+ (Fig 3 panel d) and CD8+ T cells (Fig 3 panel f) mainly in the blood vessels. The quantification analysis revealed a 4-fold increase of lymphocytes in the dengue group when compared to non-dengue samples (Fig 3 panels e and g), whereas the number of CD68+ was not statistically different from the controls (Fig 3 panel c).
Lung tissue sections stained with (a) H.E. or (b, d and f) incubated with specific antibodies in immunohistochemistry assays. (a) Mononuclear infiltrates located in interstitial septa; (b) macrophages (CD68+ cells) observed in alveolar capillaries; (d and f) CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes respectively, found in interstitial infiltrates septa; (c, e and g) quantification of cell subpopulations in the lung tissue. Macrophage (CD68); Mononuclear infiltrate (MI); edema (E); alveolar macrophage (AM); (CD4+) lymphocytes; (CD8+) lymphocytes. Asterisks indicate differences that are statistically significant between analyzed groups (*p < 0.05). Staining controls are shown in S2 Fig.
We next aimed to identify the local cytokine profile in the lungs to characterize the ongoing inflammatory process in fatal cases of severe dengue. The evaluation of cytokine-expressing cells in the tissues of the dengue group exhibited pro- and anti-inflammatory profiles occurring simultaneously, what revealed an atypical elicited immunity. TNF-α, which is an important cytokine related to dengue pathogenesis, was detected mainly in alveolar macrophages. (Fig 4 panel a). Increased numbers of TNF-α- (Fig 4 panel d), IFN-γ- (Fig 4 panels b and e), IL-10- (Fig 4 panels c and f) and TGF-β- (Fig 4 panels g and i) expressing cells such as macrophages and lymphocytes were characterized in the tissues of dengue cases, when compared to controls. Vascular permeability impairment was also addressed in dengue cases by the presence of several RANTES-expressing endothelial cells and alveolar macrophages in the perivascular space (Fig 4 panel h). The quantification of these subpopulations was found to be increased in dengue cases when compared to controls (Fig 4 panel j).
Immunohistochemical analysis of lung sections collected from dengue fatal cases exhibited (a) TNF-α and (b) INF-γ production in alveolar macrophages; (c) IL-10 detected in monocytes/macrophages and lymphocytes in alveolar septa; (g) TGF-β produced by numerous macrophages and lymphocytes in the septa; (h) RANTES detected in endothelium cells and several macrophages in pulmonary tissue; (d-f, i and j) quantification of cytokine-expressing cells in the lung sections. Monocyte (Mo); Alveolar macrophage (AM); Endothelium (E); Lymphocytes (Ly). Asterisks indicate differences that are statistically significant between dengue cases and controls (*p < 0.05). Staining controls are shown in S2 Fig.
Kidneys in severe dengue are targeted by pro-inflammatory cells
Kidney involvement with dengue virus infection is being recognized, since the prevalence of proteinuria and hematuria has been reported as high as 70-80% [19]. Mechanisms that may drive kidney complications in dengue are not clear but possibly result from indirect pathways via host immunity. Due to these knowledge gaps, renal sections extracted from post-mortem dengue cases were also considered for investigation.
Tissue analysis of severe cases revealed a diffuse mononuclear infiltrate, more pronounced in cortical and medullar regions (Fig 5 panels a and b, respectively). CD68+ cells were detected mainly in mesangial cells (monocyte or smooth muscle origin, responsible for filtration, structural support, and phagocytosis), located in the glomerulus (Fig 5 panel c). The quantification of CD68+ cells revealed an 8-fold increment of this population in dengue cases when compared to non-dengue patients (Fig 5 panel d). The number of CD4+ T cell lymphocytes, located primarily within the renal glomerulus, was also found to be increased in dengue group renal sections, when compared to controls (Fig 5 panels e and f). CD8+ T cells were detected mainly in the medullar zone (Fig 5 panel g) and their quantification showed no statistical difference between dengue and control groups (Fig 5 panel h).
(a and b) A representative kidney section stained with H.E. showing diffuse mononuclear cell infiltrate; (c) detection of (CD68+) in mesangial cells in glomeruli; (e and g) circulating CD4+ lymphocytes detected inside renal glomeruli and CD8+ cells observed in the interstitial space, respectively; (d, f and h) quantification of cell subpopulations in the kidney tissue. Mesangial cells (CD68); (CD4+) lymphocytes; (CD8+) lymphocytes. RG—renal gromerulus. Asterisks indicate differences that are statistically significant between groups (*p < 0.05). Staining controls are shown in S3 Fig.
The evaluation of cytokine profile in renal samples revealed TNF-α being produced mainly by monocytes/macrophages present in the medullar region (Fig 6 panel a). IFN-γ-producing cells, such as macrophages, were found in blood vessels located also in the medullar region (Fig 6 panel b). The anti-inflammatory cytokines IL-10 and TGF-γ were observed mostly in lymphocytes within the renal glomerulus (Fig 6 panel c) and macrophages (Fig 6 panel g), while RANTES production was detected mainly in macrophages only (Fig 6 panel h). Quantification of cells producing these cytokines revealed a general increase in dengue cases when compared to controls. The number of cells producing of TNF-α and IFN-γ in dengue cases was 3- and 5-fold higher, respectively, after comparison with non-dengue cases (Fig 6 panels d and e). Concerning the number of cells expressing TGF-β (Fig 6 panel i), IL-10 (Fig 6 panel f) and RANTES (Fig 6 panel j), in dengue cases we noted increments of about 2.5-, 3- and 13-fold, respectively.
(a) TNF-α detected in monocytes located in blood vessels; (b) Production of INF-γ observed in circulating macrophages and lymphocytes located in the interstitial space; (c) IL-10 found in endothelial cells of glomerulus; (g) TGF-β production by lymphocytes present mainly inside renal glomeruli; (h) RANTES detected in macrophages and lymphocytes in the interstitial renal space; (d-f, i and j) quantification of the number of cells expressing the above cytokines. Macrophages (Mϕ); Lymphocytes (Ly). Asterisks indicate differences that are statistically significant between analyzed groups (*p < 0.05). Staining controls are shown in S3 Fig.
DENV-specific induction of pro-inflammatory response
In order to confirm the participation of DENV-infected cells in inducing the local pro-inflammatory response, DENV RNA and cytokine production were co-tested in host samples. For this evaluation, the liver was elected due to its importance as a target organ in dengue pathogenesis.
As expected, the light microscopy of a dengue fatal case exhibited mononuclear cell infiltrates with the presence of Kupffer cells (KC) in the sinusoid capillaries (Fig 7 panels a and b), while non-dengue control presented regular hepatic structures with resident KCs (Fig 7 panels i and j). As detected by in situ hybridization and IHC, the dengue case showed many areas of co-expression in the hepatic tissue considering DENV RNA and IFN-γ or TNF-α (Fig 7 panels g and h). In this case, Kupffer cells were the main targets of co-staining. The control case presented no staining for either DENV or the studied cytokines.
Liver samples of dengue fatal case 2 were processed for in situ hybridization and IHC procedures. DENV was detected by a probe that aneals to a conserved sequence within the viral RNA negative strand. IFN-γ and TNF-α were assessed by immunohistochemistry assay. Probe-target complexes were revealed by alkaline phosphatase activity and cytokines were identified by standard DAB reactions. The chromogenic signals were converted to fluorescent-based signals using a computer based Nuance system. Representative images are shown: (a, b) Light microscopy of sinusiodal areas of dengue case stained for DENV RNA and IFN-γ or TNF-α, respectively. (c, d) Expression of DENV RNA (blue) in samples stained with IFN-γ or TNF-α, respectively. (e, f) Expression of IFN-γ or TNF-α (red) in in samples stained with DENV RNA, respectively. (g, h) Merged signals of DENV RNA and IFN-γ or TNF-α where co-expression is exhibited in yellow, respectively. (i, j) Light microscopy of sinusiodal areas of a non-dengue case stained for DENV RNA and IFN-γ or TNF-α, respectively. (k, l) Comtrol samples showing DENV and IFN-γ or TNF-α fluorescent signals, respectively. KC—Kupffer cells.
These data confirmed, under a qualitative basis, the specific DENV-induction over pro-inflammatory cytokine response and also addressed the virus spread versus IFN-γ or TNF-α expression in the liver sample of a dengue fatal case.
Discussion
The elucidation of mechanisms that underlie the development of severe dengue is still seen as a major challenge in the field [20]. The progress of dengue research concerning such aspects has been hampered by a set of factors that include the peculiar nature of DENV infection together with the absence of an immunocompetent animal approach capable of mimicking severe dengue symptoms [21]. Under this scenario, the investigation of post-mortem samples extracted from severe dengue human cases would bring valuable information to better understand the pathogenic base of the disease. Immune mechanisms are thought to drive the mild flu-like illness (DF) to the severe hemorrhagic stages of dengue, since such manifestations occur after virus clearance from the circulation [22]. In this work, four fatal human cases that experienced the severe hemorrhagic symptoms of dengue had three of their peripheral sites (liver, lung and kidney) investigated. Organs were elected according to previous known relevance or knowledge gaps related to dengue [16–19, 23]. Research was focused on the cellular immunity, in which mononuclear cell migration and cytokine production were considered to the evaluation of host response by the fatal cases of severe dengue. In a previous report from our laboratory, we found that the same post-mortem samples presented tissue damages that were consistent with severe dengue clinical cases [13]. The inspection of these tissues under an immunological approach was our major concern in this work, since evidences of an exacerbated host immunity would somehow be linked to organ impairments. From a first panoramic view, all evaluated sites from fatal cases (liver, lungs and kidneys) were targeted by mononuclear cell migration, such as macrophages and T cells. Apart from this, the analyzed peripheral organs exhibited higher levels of pro-inflammatory cells, as found by their production of TNF-α, IFN-γ and RANTES. Those observations strongly supported the proposed theories claiming that exaggerated [24, 25] or misdirected [8, 26–28] T-cell responses would eventually lead the host to severe clinical stages.
Numerous reports describe the release of different cytokines and soluble receptors during dengue infection [25, 29, 30], which has also been associated to the unfavorable disease outcome [31]. In this work, increased levels of RANTES-producing endothelial cells may have contributed to the occurrence of cell infiltrates, since this chemokine signals for cell movement from the bloodstream into tissues [32, 33]. Therefore, that would infer a close connection between RANTES and the altered vascular permeability events related to severe dengue. In this case, higher RANTES production and secretion would favor plasma leakage and lymphocyte cell infiltration into the liver, lungs and kidneys, hence, potentially mediating the inflammatory response found in these peripheral organs. Among all chemokines, RANTES is particularly associated with viral infections [34]. RANTES, also known as CCL5, is an early expressed chemokine induced by pattern recognition receptors, but can also be induced by TNF-α and IFN-γ at late stages of infection [35], that is the case of a terminal dengue situation. The discussion about chemokine signaling and its effects over infectious diseases can sometimes be controversial in the literature. Together with other chemotactic effectors (CXCL9/10/11) and immune cell response-modulating cytokines (IL-6, IL-7 and BAFF), RANTES has been associated with immune enhancement and increased vascular permeability following dengue virus infection [36, 37]. Conversely, in vitro experiments revealed that hantavirus can infect human lung microvascular endothelial cells (HMVEC-Ls) and stimulate secretion of RANTES by these cells without increasing vascular permeability [38]. Together, these observations still arise skeptical thoughts that lead to a more careful discussion concerning a direct link between RANTES and vascular permeability enhancement in dengue.
The higher amounts of TNF-α-producing cells characterized in the post-mortem samples were in line with reports in the literature. TNF-α is considered as a major pro-inflammatory mediator in dengue infections since its activity has been linked to the immunopathogenesis of the disease [28, 39]. Apart from the existing drawbacks regarding animal models to reproducing dengue, reports showed that the inhibition of TNF-α by administrating specific antibodies was associated with reduced severity [39, 40]. Although the TNF-α inhibition assay was key to infer its importance in severe dengue, in practical terms, targeting TNF with antibody or receptor antagonists for treating human diseases is controversial. In other diseases with immunological basis, not all patients were helped despite the clinical effectiveness of anti-TNF aproaches. This fact, perhaps, reflected the existence of distinct underlying mechanisms that drive the symptoms apart from the TNF network [41].
Along with TNF-α, IFN-γ was also found to be increased in terms of production by infiltrated mononuclear cells in peripheral tissues of the studied fatal dengue cases. Hence, the present work showed INF-γ as a pro-inflammatory element that may contribute to tissue distress, also representing an in situ evidence of disease severity. In a recent report, metabolomics was adopted to screen dengue-induced metabolites in 116 dengue patients (60 presenting DF and 56 with severe dengue). It was found that circulating IFN-γ combined with serotonin levels provided accurate early prognosis of severe dengue, thus revealing its importance and an additional clinical usage of this pro-inflammatory cytokine to assess severity [42].
The mononuclear cell migration that targeted the studied tissues were also proposed to be correlated with local impairments. In liver samples, CD4+ T cells, Kupffer cells and monocytes were characterized near hepatocellular necrosis and steatosis in the presence of pro-inflammatory cytokines, IFN-γ and TNF-α. Additional alterations on hepatocytes, such as nuclear vacuolar degeneration and the presence of swollen mitochondria, based on preceeding studies, suggested an ongoing mechanism of apoptotic cell death possibly mediated by the cytokine environment [13, 43–47]. In our previous report, the lung scenario of the studied dengue fatal cases was marked by a peculiar histopathological evidence. The presence of septum thickening with an increase of cellularity characterized a hyaline membrane formation possibly due to dengue shock syndrome [13]. As the activity of pro-inflammatory cytokines (IFN-γ and TNF-α) were previously associated with lung injury [48, 49], we envisioned a possible correlation between local cytokine production and tissue alterations. Under this idea, the hyaline membrane structure could be formed in function of an exacerbated cytokine release by hyperplasic alveolar macrophages combined with tissue alterations such as edema and hemorrhage, which is also found in other non-related diseases [50, 51]. Parenchyma and circulatory damages found in kidney samples would likely be immune-mediated due to the presence of mononuclear infiltrates in cortical and medullar regions. A recent report correlated kidney injuries of severe dengue cases with the local recruitment of T cells [52]. In line with our findings, authors also found that infiltrated CD8+ T lymphocytes were outnumbered by CD4+ T cells, suggesting an important role of this subpopulation in tissue damages. Hence, considering all analyzed tissues under the above circumstances, it would be reasonable to suggest a key role of cellular immunity to determine local tissue alterations/dysfunctions. It is important to note that when referring to CD8-expressing lymphocytes a number of different cell populations, other than classical T cells, may also be taken into account. Due to the close morphology, NK cells and mucosal-associated invariant T (MAIT) cells are examples of CD8-expressing subsets that may also present roles in severe dengue. While the participation of NK cells in DENV infection has been extensively reported [53–57], the role of MAIT cells in such disease is still a novel and eye-catching mater of debate [58].
At this point, a relevant question emerges considering the induction of the evident immune reaction found in the analyzed tissues. Considering the environmental circumstances and the debilitating situation of a patient under severe dengue, it would be possible that immunity induced against other opportunistic pathogens would also be occurring. Such hypothesis can not be excluded, however, the DENV-specific participation over the elicited immunity was confirmed in this work. In situ hybridization together with IHC experiments showed, qualitatively, that DENV produces a direct effect over pro-inflammatory cytokine production. As noted by the historic of symptoms, laboratory workup [13] and our present evaluation, we consider that the major element leading to the observed effects over immunity is the infection by DENV.
Under the immune-mediated theory for the pathogenesis of dengue, anti-inflammatory or regulatory cytokines would, at first glance, contribute to a better prognosis. An interesting fact that occurred during tissue analysis (mainly liver and kidney samples) was the detection of anti-inflammatory cells with production of IL-10 or TGF-β, even in the presence of the above discussed pro-inflammatory environment. One hypothesis to explain this atypical finding would be the triggering of a host immunity attempt to circumvent the local inflammatory process. Under this idea, as the studied tissues were previously characterized with local impairments [13], this would indicate the existence of a strong ongoing inflammatory effect capable of overwhelming regulatory responses. In line with this assumption, a report in the literature showed that the overexpression of pro-inflammatory cytokines has been suggested to cause an inhibitory influence on regulatory cells [59]. Another recent report revealed that, in fact, a disturbance in the balance between inflammatory (IL-6 and IL-8) and anti-inflammatory (IL-10) cytokines, would characterize possible mechanisms related to the occurrence of hemorrhagic manifestations in dengue [60]. Additionally, IL-10 has also been interpreted as a marker of disease progression in severe dengue cases [61]. Regardless of these corroborating evidences from the literature, we still find it difficult and risky to draw conclusions over these aspects from the studied post-mortem samples. Investigations considering the time dependency of the immune events along with the host clinical evolution would still be necessary for a more consistent description about this pro- versus anti-inflammatory balance.
In conclusion, the study of post-mortem samples from peripheral organs of severe dengue cases provided valuable information about the local environment under an immunological approach. The existence of a strong ongoing pro-inflammatory response was suggested to be occurring in liver and manly in lung and kidney samples. The presence of mononuclear cell infiltrates, higher counts of pro-inflammatory cells (as found by the production of TNF-α, IFN-γ and RANTES) and the apparent outrun of inflammation over anti-inflammatory elements (such as IL-10 and TGF-β) were the major evidences for such characterization. Apart from many other known hypotheses for the determination of severe dengue cases [20], this work provided additional evidences that supported the cellular immune-mediated theories, hence, contributing to a better understanding of dengue pathogenesis.
Supporting Information
S1 Fig. Liver tissue controls of immunohistochemistry assays.
Histological sections of a non-dengue case organ showing regular structures and preserved parenchyma. Slides were stained with anti-CD68 (a), anti-CD4 (b), anti-CD8 (c), anti-TNFα (d), anti-IFNγ (e), anti-IL-10 (f), anti-TGFβ (g) and anti-RANTES (h).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0168973.s001
(TIF)
S2 Fig. Lung tissue controls of immunohistochemistry assays.
Histological sections of a non-dengue case organ showing regular structures and preserved parenchyma. Slides were stained with anti-CD68 (a), anti-CD4 (b), anti-CD8 (c), anti-TNFα (d), anti-IFNγ (e), anti-IL-10 (f), anti-TGFβ (g) and anti-RANTES (h).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0168973.s002
(TIF)
S3 Fig. Kidney tissue controls of immunohistochemistry assays.
Histological sections of a non-dengue case organ showing regular structures and preserved parenchyma. Slides were stained with anti-CD68 (a), anti-CD4 (b), anti-CD8 (c), anti-TNFα (d), anti-IFNγ (e), anti-IL-10 (f), anti-TGFβ (g) and anti-RANTES (h).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0168973.s003
(TIF)
S1 Table. Quantification of positive cells by immunohistochemistry.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0168973.s004
(XLSX)
Acknowledgments
We thank Rodrigo Mexas (Service of Production and Image Treatment/IOC/Fiocruz) and Geraldo (Gaffrée Hospital-UNIRIO) for technical assistance in the production of slides for the immunohistochemical assays and FAPERJ for financial support (grant number: E-26/110.511/2014). We also acknowledge Dr. Ada Alves from Laboratory of Biotechnology and Physiology of Viral Infections (LABIFIV-Fiocruz) for the environment where experiments were set up.
Author Contributions
- Conceptualization: MVP ERAO TFP.
- Data curation: MVP TFP GJN NGS.
- Formal analysis: MVP TFP ERAO.
- Funding acquisition: MVP.
- Investigation: MVP TFP ERAO GJN NGS EMM.
- Methodology: MVP ERAO TFP GJN.
- Project administration: MVP TFP ERAO.
- Resources: MVP CAB GJN VLAC EMM.
- Supervision: MVP ERAO TFP.
- Validation: MVP ERAO TFP.
- Visualization: TFP ERAO MVP.
- Writing – original draft: ERAO.
- Writing – review & editing: ERAO MVP.
References
- 1.
WHO: Global strategy for dengue prevention and control 2012-2020. World Health Organization. 2012. Available from: www.who.int
- 2.
WHO: Dengue: Guidelines for diagnosis, treatment, prevention and control. World Health Organization. 2009. Available from: www.who.int
- 3. Bhatt S, Gething PW, Brady OJ, Messina JP, Farlow AW, Moyes CL, et al. The global distribution and burden of dengue. Nature. 2013;496:504–507. pmid:23563266
- 4. Halstead SB, Cohen SN. Dengue hemorrhagic fever at 60 Years: early evolution of concepts of causation and treatment. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev. 2015;79:281–291. pmid:26085471
- 5. Guzman MG, Halstead SB, Artsob H, Buchy P, Farrar J, Gubler DJ, et al. Dengue: a continuing global threat. Nat Rev Microbiol. 2010;8:S7–16. pmid:21079655
- 6. Carabali M, Hernandez LM, Arauz MJ, Villar LA, Ridde V. Why are people with dengue dying? A scoping review of determinants for dengue mortality. BMC Infect Dis. 2015;15:301–315. pmid:26223700
- 7. Huy NT, Van Giang T, Thuy DH, Kikuchi M, Hien TT, Zamora J, et al. Factors associated with dengue shock syndrome: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2013;7:e2412. pmid:24086778
- 8. Pang T, Cardosa MJ, Guzman MG. Of cascades and perfect storms: the immunopathogenesis of dengue haemorrhagic fever-dengue shock syndrome (DHF/DSS). Immunol Cell Biol. 2007;85:43–45. pmid:17130899
- 9. Nielsen DG. The relationship of interacting immunological components in dengue pathogenesis. Virol J. 2009;6:211. pmid:19941667
- 10. Halstead SB. Dengue Antibody-Dependent Enhancement: Knowns and Unknowns. Microbiol Spectr. 2014;2. pmid:26104444
- 11. Green S, Rothman A. Immunopathological mechanisms in dengue and dengue hemorrhagic fever. Curr Opin Infect Dis. 2006;19:429–36. pmid:16940865
- 12. Pawitan JA. Dengue virus infection: predictors for severe dengue. Acta Med Indones. 2011;43:129–35. pmid:21785176
- 13. Póvoa TF, Alves AM, Oliveira CA, Nuovo GJ, Chagas VL, Paes MV. The pathology of severe dengue in multiple organs of human fatal cases: histopathology, ultrastructure and virus replication. PLoS One. 2014;9:e83386.
- 14. Paes MV, Lenzi HL, Nogueira AC, Nuovo GJ, Pinhão AT, Mota EM, et al. Hepatic damage associated with dengue-2 virus replication in liver cells of BALB/c mice. Lab Invest. 2009;89:1140–1151. pmid:19721415
- 15. Braga EL, Moura P, Pinto LM, Ignácio SR, Oliveira MJ, Cordeiro MT, et al. Detection of circulant tumor necrosis factor-alpha, soluble tumor necrosis factor p75 and interferon-gamma in Brazilian patients with dengue fever and dengue hemorrhagic fever. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz. 2001;96:229–32. pmid:11285501
- 16. Huerre MR, Lan NT, Marianneau P, Hue NB, Khun H, Hung NT, et al. Liver histopathology and biological correlates in five cases of fatal dengue fever in Vietnamese children. Virchows Arch. 2001;438:107–115. pmid:11253111
- 17. Seneviratne SL, Malavige GN, de Silva HJ. Pathogenesis of liver involvement during dengue viral infections. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2006;100:608–614. pmid:16483623
- 18. Samanta J, Sharma V. Dengue and its effects on liver. World J Clin Cases. 2015;3:125–131. pmid:25685758
- 19. Vachvanichsanong P, Thisyakorn U, Thisyakorn C. Dengue hemorrhagic fever and the kidney. Arch Virol. 2016;161:771–778. pmid:26699788
- 20. Halstead SB. Pathogenesis of Dengue: Dawn of a New Era. F1000Res. 2015;4. pii: F1000 Faculty Rev-1353. pmid:26918141
- 21. Chan KW, Watanabe S, Kavishna R, Alonso S, Vasudevan SG. Animal models for studying dengue pathogenesis and therapy. Antiviral Res. 2015;123:5–14. pmid:26304704
- 22. John DV, Lin YS, Perng GC. Biomarkers of severe dengue disease—a review. J Biomed Sci. 2015;22:83. pmid:26462910
- 23. Rodrigues RS, Brum AL, Paes MV, Póvoa TF, Basilio-de-Oliveira CA, Marchiori E, et al. Lung in dengue: computed tomography findings. PLoS One. 2014;9:e96313. pmid:24836605
- 24. Mathew A, Kurane I, Green S, Stephens HA, Vaughn DW, Kalayanarooj S, et al. Predominance of HLA-restricted cytotoxic T-lymphocyte responses to serotype-cross-reactive epitopes on nonstructural proteins following natural secondary dengue virus infection. J Virol. 1998;72:3999–4004. pmid:9557687
- 25. Rothman AL, Ennis FA. Immunopathogenesis of Dengue hemorrhagic fever. Virology. 1999;257:1–6. pmid:10208914
- 26. Mongkolsapaya J, Dejnirattisai W, Xu XN, Vasanawathana S, Tangthawornchaikul N, Chairunsri A, et al. Original antigenic sin and apoptosis in the pathogenesis of dengue hemorrhagic fever. Nat Med. 2003;9:921–927. pmid:12808447
- 27. Rothman AL. Cellular immunology of sequential dengue virus infection and its role in disease pathogenesis. Curr Top Microbiol Immunol. 2010;338:83–98. pmid:19802580
- 28. Rothman AL. Immunity to dengue virus: a tale of original antigenic sin and tropical cytokine storms. Nat Rev Immunol. 2011;11:532–43. pmid:21760609
- 29. Hober D, Poli L, Roblin B, Gestas P, Chungue E, Granic G, et al. Serum levels of tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), interleukin-6 (IL-6), and interleukin-1 beta (IL-1 beta) in dengue-infected patients. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1993;48:324–331. pmid:8470771
- 30. Green S, Vaughn DW, Kalayanarooj S, Nimmannitya S, Suntayakorn S, Nisalak A, et al. Early immune activation in acute dengue illness is related to development of plasma leakage and disease severity. J Infect Dis. 1999;179:755–762. pmid:10068569
- 31. Chaturvedi UC, Agarwal R, Elbishbishi EA, Mustafa AS. Cytokine cascade in dengue hemorrhagic fever: implications for pathogenesis. FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol. 2000;28:183–188. pmid:10865168
- 32. Ebert LM, Schaerli P, Moser B. Chemokine-mediated control of T cell traffic in lymphoid and peripheral tissues. Mol Immunol. 2005;42:799–809. pmid:15829268
- 33. de-Oliveira-Pinto LM, Marinho CF, Povoa TF, de Azeredo EL, de Souza LA, Barbosa LD, et al. Regulation of inflammatory chemokine receptors on blood T cells associated to the circulating versus liver chemokines in dengue fever. PLoS One. 2012;7:e38527. pmid:22815692
- 34. Glass WG, Rosenberg HF, Murphy PM. Chemokine regulation of inflammation during acute viral infection. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol. 2003;3:467–473. pmid:14612671
- 35. Grandvaux N, Servant MJ, tenOever B, Sen GC, Balachandran S, Barber GN, et al. Transcriptional profiling of interferon regulatory factor 3 target genes: direct involvement in the regulation of interferon-stimulated genes. J Virol. 2002;76:5532–5539. pmid:11991981
- 36. Dalrymple NA, Mackow ER. Endothelial cells elicit immune-enhancing responses to dengue virus infection. J Virol. 2012;86:6408–15. pmid:22496214
- 37. Chen J, Ng MM, Chu JJ. Molecular profiling of T-helper immune genes during dengue virus infection. Virol J. 2008;5:165. pmid:19117515
- 38. Sundstrom JB, McMullan LK, Spiropoulou CF, Hooper WC, Ansari AA, Peters CJ, et al. Hantavirus infection induces the expression of RANTES and IP-10 without causing increased permeability in human lung microvascular endothelial cells. J Virol. 2001;75:6070–6085. pmid:11390609
- 39. Shresta S, Sharar KL, Prigozhin DM, Beatty PR, Harris E. Murine model for dengue virus-induced lethal disease with increased vascular permeability. J Virol. 2006;80:10208–10217. pmid:17005698
- 40. Atrasheuskaya A, Petzelbauer P, Fredeking TM, Ignatyev G. Anti-TNF antibody treatment reduces mortality in experimental dengue virus infection. FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol. 2003;35:33–42. pmid:12589955
- 41. Croft M, Benedict CA, Ware CF. Clinical targeting of the TNF and TNFR superfamilies. Nat Rev Drug Discov. 2013;12:147–68. pmid:23334208
- 42. Cui L, Lee YH, Thein TL, Fang J, Pang J, Ooi EE, et al. Serum Metabolomics Reveals Serotonin as a Predictor of Severe Dengue in the Early Phase of Dengue Fever. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2016;10(4):e0004607. pmid:27055163
- 43. Ding WX, Yin XM. Dissection of the multiple mechanisms of TNF-alpha-induced apoptosis in liver injury. J Cell Mol Med. 2004;8:445–454. pmid:15601573
- 44. Quaresma JA, Barros VL, Pagliari C, Fernandes ER, Guedes F, Takakura CF, et al. Revisiting the liver in human yellow fever: virus-induced apoptosis in hepatocytes associated with TGF-beta, TNF-alpha and NK cells activity. Virology. 2006;345:22–30. pmid:16278000
- 45. Rimkunas VM, Graham MJ, Crooke RM, Liscum L. TNF-alpha plays a role in hepatocyte apoptosis in Niemann-Pick type C liver disease. J Lipid Res. 2009;50:327–333. pmid:18815434
- 46. Quaresma JA, Pagliari C, Medeiros DB, Duarte MI, Vasconcelos PF. Immunity and immune response, pathology and pathologic changes: progress and challenges in the immunopathology of yellow fever. Rev Med Virol. 2013;23:305–318. pmid:23873723
- 47. Rowan PJ, Dunn NJ, El-Serag HB, Kunik ME. Views of hepatitis C virus patients delayed from treatment for psychiatric reasons. J Viral Hepat. 2007;14:883–889. pmid:18070292
- 48. Bhargava R, Altmann CJ, Andres-Hernando A, Webb RG, Okamura K, Yang Y, et al. Acute lung injury and acute kidney injury are established by four hours in experimental sepsis and are improved with pre, but not post, sepsis administration of TNF-α antibodies. PLoS One. 2013 Nov 12;8(11):e79037. pmid:24265742
- 49. Spender LC, Hussell T, Openshaw PJ. Abundant IFN-gamma production by local T cells in respiratory syncytial virus-induced eosinophilic lung disease. J Gen Virol. 1998;79:1751–1758. pmid:9680139
- 50. Kwong KY, Jones CA, Cayabyab R, Lecart C, Stotts CL, Randhawa I, et al. Differential regulation of IL-8 by IL-1beta and TNFalpha in hyaline membrane disease. J Clin Immunol. 1998;18:71–80. pmid:9475356
- 51. Groneck P, Götze-Speer B, Oppermann M, Eiffert H, Speer CP. Association of pulmonary inflammation and increased microvascular permeability during the development of bronchopulmonary dysplasia: a sequential analysis of inflammatory mediators in respiratory fluids of high-risk preterm neonates. Pediatrics. 1994;93:712–718. pmid:8165067
- 52. Pagliari C, Simões Quaresma JA, Kanashiro-Galo L, de Carvalho LV, Vitoria WO, da Silva WL, et al. Human kidney damage in fatal dengue hemorrhagic fever results of glomeruli injury mainly induced by IL17. J Clin Virol. 2016;75:16–20. pmid:26741825
- 53. Lim DS, Yawata N, Selva KJ, Li N, Tsai CY, Yeong LH, et al. The combination of type I IFN, TNF-α, and cell surface receptor engagement with dendritic cells enables NK cells to overcome immune evasion by dengue virus. J Immunol. 2014;193:5065–5075. pmid:25320280
- 54. Townsley E, O’Connor G, Cosgrove C, Woda M, Co M, Thomas SJ, et al. Interaction of a dengue virus NS1-derived peptide with the inhibitory receptor KIR3DL1 on natural killer cells. Clin Exp Immunol. 2016;183:419–430. pmid:26439909
- 55. Petitdemange C, Wauquier N, Devilliers H, Yssel H, Mombo I, Caron M, et al. Longitudinal Analysis of Natural Killer Cells in Dengue Virus-Infected Patients in Comparison to Chikungunya and Chikungunya/Dengue Virus-Infected Patients. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2016;10:e0004499. pmid:26938618
- 56. Petitdemange C, Wauquier N, Rey J, Hervier B, Leroy E, Vieillard V. Control of acute dengue virus infection by natural killer cells. Front Immunol. 2014;5:209. pmid:24860571
- 57. Beltrán D, López-Vergès S. NK Cells during Dengue Disease and Their Recognition of Dengue Virus-Infected cells. Front Immunol. 2014;5:192. pmid:24829565
- 58. van Wilgenburg B, Scherwitzl I, Hutchinson EC, Leng T, Kurioka A, Kulicke C, et al. MAIT cells are activated during human viral infections. Nat Commun. 2016;7:11653. pmid:27337592
- 59. Tillu H, Tripathy AS, Reshmi PV, Cecilia D. Altered profile of regulatory T cells and associated cytokines in mild and moderate dengue. Eur J Clin Microbiol Infect Dis. 2016;35:453–461. pmid:26861813
- 60. Iani FC, Caldas S, Duarte MM, Cury AL, Cecílio AB, Costa PA, et al. Dengue Patients with Early Hemorrhagic Manifestations Lose Coordinate Expression of the Anti-Inflammatory Cytokine IL-10 with the Inflammatory Cytokines IL-6 and IL-8. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2016;95:193–200. pmid:27139443
- 61. Tauseef A, Umar N, Sabir S, Akmal A, Sajjad S, Zulfiqar S. Interleukin-10 as a Marker of Disease Progression in Dengue Hemorrhagic Fever. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2016;26:187–90. pmid:26975948