31 Jul 2013: (2013) Correction: The Mitochondrial Genomes of Nuttalliella namaqua (Ixodoidea: Nuttalliellidae) and Argas africolumbae (Ixodoidae: Argasidae): Estimation of Divergence Dates for the Major Tick Lineages and Reconstruction of Ancestral Blood-Feeding Characters. PLoS ONE 8(7): 10.1371/annotation/19fe1c45-57c3-4008-9733-ebdf39202075. doi: 10.1371/annotation/19fe1c45-57c3-4008-9733-ebdf39202075 | View correction
Ixodida are composed of hard (Ixodidae), soft (Argasidae) and the monotypic Nuttalliellidae (Nuttalliella namaqua) tick families. Nuclear 18S rRNA analysis suggested that N. namaqua was the closest extant relative to the last common ancestral tick lineage. The mitochondrial genomes of N. namaqua and Argas africolumbae were determined using next generation sequencing and de novo assembly to investigate this further. The latter was included since previous estimates on the divergence times of argasids lacked data for this major genus. Mitochondrial gene order for both was identical to that of the Argasidae and Prostriata. Bayesian analysis of the COI, Cytb, ND1, ND2 and ND4 genes confirmed the monophyly of ticks, the basal position of N. namaqua to the other tick families and the accepted systematic relationships of the other tick genera. Molecular clock estimates were derived for the divergence of the major tick lineages and supported previous estimates on the origins of ticks in the Carboniferous. N. namaqua larvae fed successfully on lizards and mice in a prolonged manner similar to many argasids and all ixodids. Excess blood meal-derived water was secreted via the salivary glands, similar to ixodids. We propose that this prolonged larval feeding style eventually gave rise to the long feeding periods that typify the single larval, nymphal and adult stages of ixodid ticks and the associated secretion of water via the salivary glands. Ancestral reconstruction of characters involved in blood-feeding indicates that most of the characteristics unique to either hard or soft tick families were present in the ancestral tick lineage.
Citation: Mans BJ, de Klerk D, Pienaar R, de Castro MH, Latif AA (2012) The Mitochondrial Genomes of Nuttalliella namaqua (Ixodoidea: Nuttalliellidae) and Argas africolumbae (Ixodoidae: Argasidae): Estimation of Divergence Dates for the Major Tick Lineages and Reconstruction of Ancestral Blood-Feeding Characters. PLoS ONE 7(11): e49461. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049461
Editor: Pedro Lagerblad Oliveira, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Received: August 3, 2012; Accepted: October 9, 2012; Published: November 8, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Mans et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This project was funded by the Joy Liebenberg Trust (21/19/JT02) allocated to BM and a South African National Research Foundation grant allocated to AL (NRF-Spain). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: B.J. Mans is currently serving on the Editorial Board of PLOS ONE. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Differentiation of the Argasidae and Ixodidae is uncomplicated based on biology and morphology. Hard ticks of all life stages possess a sclerotized scutum, an apical located gnathostoma, feed for prolonged periods (several days to weeks) and ingest more than 100× their body mass in blood –. Soft ticks do not possess a scutum, their prognathous mouthparts are located anterior ventrally and they have a leathery integument that can rapidly expand, allowing nymphs and adults to engorge up to ten times their body mass within minutes to hours –. Hard ticks secrete blood meal-derived water back into the host via their salivary glands, while soft ticks use their coxal organs –. Nuttalliella namaqua, however, exhibit features associated with both hard and soft ticks. Like soft ticks, its nymphal and adult stages possess a leathery cuticle and engorge rapidly . However, larvae possess a sclerotized scutum, while nymphs and adults have a semi-sclerotized pseudo-scutum and their mouthparts are located apically –. It differs from the other families in that nymphal and adult stages possess ball and socket leg joints and blood meal-derived water is secreted via the Malpighian tubules –. Classification with regard to its relationship to the other tick families based on morphology and biology therefore remains problematic .
Analysis of the nuclear 18S ribosomal RNA from N. namaqua indicated that it grouped basal to the other tick families, suggesting that it is the closest extant relative to the last common ancestral tick lineage . The monophyly of the Ixodida as well the validity of the Nuttalliellidae as a separate tick family –, , were also supported. The monophyly of the main tick families was also supported by analysis of mitochondrial genomes . However, discrepancies between nuclear and mitochondrial gene phylogenies have been found within arthropods and ticks –. This raises the question whether mitochondrial data will also support the position of N. namaqua at the base of the tick tree. Divergence dates were also estimated for the origin of ticks, based on the mitochondrial dataset , but did not include data for N. namaqua, or the genus Argas. The date estimates for the Ixodida as well as the Argasidae therefore lacked important divergence points, one for the origin of the Ixodida and the second for the divergence of the main argasid lineages. To address these issues, we sequenced the mitochondrial genomes of N. namaqua and Argas africolumbae . We also derived parameters associated with feeding of larval N. namaqua that we used in ancestral reconstruction. A model for the evolution of characters involved in blood-feeding were presented and resolved in part the existing dichotomy regarding the biology of the two major families .
Results and Discussion
Comparison of mitochondrial genomes
The mitochondrial genome gene order found in Nuttalliella and Argas was similar to argasids (Ornithodorinae), prostriate ixodids (Ixodes) and the inferred ancestral gene order of all arthropods as exhibited by Limulus polyphemus –. This included 13 protein-coding genes, the 16S and 12S ribosomal RNA genes, 22 tRNA genes and a single control region (Table 1). Given the basal position of N. namaqua to the other tick families , this suggested that the ancestral arthropod gene order was conserved in the last common ancestral tick lineage. This gene order differed from that of the metastriate ticks where a block of genes (ND1-tRNA-Glu) has translocated , –. Prediction of the secondary structures of the tRNA genes indicated that they can form the conventional four-leaved clover structures, except for the tRNA's for serine that lack the D-loop, similar to other metazoans .
Table 1. The mitochondrial genomes of N. namaqua and A. africolumbae compared to C. capensis, O. moubata and I. hexagonus .doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049461.t001
Phylogenetic analysis using the 16S rRNA gene
Given the current confusion in argasid systematics –, all argasid species will be referred to according to the sub-genera classification system of Hoogstraal . The use of the 16S rRNA gene predominates in argasid molecular systematics, even though recognized to be of little use for resolution of relationships above genus or sub-genus level –. However, it is useful to identify closely related species or groups. BLASTN analysis using the 16S rRNA gene for A. (Argas) africolumbae retrieved as best hits members of the genus Argas (6E−164-1E−110) in agreement with its original classification . Phylogenetic analysis indicated that A. (Argas) africolumbae grouped with members of the genus Argas, with A. (Argas) neghmei as closest neighbour (Fig. 1). Nodal support was overall weak confirming previous observations –. The rest of the tree includes the Ornithodorinae which shows little support for any of the classic taxonomical classifications proposed –, as reviewed recently .
Figure 1. Maximum parsimony analysis using the 16S rRNA gene.
The 50% consensus tree from 10000 bootstraps with support above 50% is shown. Species are indicated by their species designation in their Genbank description lines with accession numbers in parenthesis. New sequences reported in this study are underlined. Sub-genera as described by Hoogstraal are indicated .doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049461.g001
Phylogenetic analysis using the 18S rRNA gene
To confirm the relationship of A. (Argas) africolumbae in the genus Argas and retest the hypothesis that N. namaqua group at the base of the tick tree, a phylogenetic analysis using the 18S rRNA gene was performed using Bayesian analysis. For this, all available tick 18S rRNA sequences >1500bp was included as well as Opilioacarid and Holothyrid sequences for outgroups (Fig. 2). A. (Argas) africolumbae grouped basal in a monophyletic clade with A. (Persicargas) persicus and A. (Alveonasus) lahorensis supporting the monophyly of the genus Argas –. As with the 16S rRNA analysis, the 18S rRNA dataset did not resolve members of the Ornithodorinae. However, the monophyly of ticks, the basal position of N. namaqua to the argasid and ixodid families and established relationships of most major tick genera as previously defined by 18S rRNA analysis were overall well supported , .
Figure 2. Bayesian analysis using the 18S rRNA gene.
The 50% consensus tree is shown with posterior probability support for nodes higher than 90% indicated. Nodes were condensed below 90%. The scale bar indicates Bayesian distances. Species are designated by their Genbank description lines and accession numbers in parenthesis.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049461.g002
Phylogenetic analysis using mitochondrial genomic data
Both 16S and 18S data do not resolve all nodes in their respective trees or give nodes with low support. This might be due to low taxon sampling, saturation of phylogenetic signal or inappropriate mutation time scales for the markers used. They are as such not useful for use in molecular divergence estimation. Mitochondrial genome data was investigated as an alternative marker since this was previously used for molecular divergence estimation . Nucleotide compositional reverse strand-bias exists in arthropod mitochondrial genomes and can lead to artificial clustering during phylogenetic analysis . The existence of mutational saturation, especially at deep levels of phylogeny also makes the use of protein sequences more attractive than nucleotide sequences . A recent in-depth analysis of the mitochondrial genes from insects showed that not all mitochondrial genes were suitable for analysis of systematic relationships at deep phylogenetic levels, specifically due to long-branch attraction . The genes most suitable to retrieve the correct topology included the cytochrome c oxidase I (COI), cytochrome b (Cytb), NADH dehydrogenase 1, 2 and 4 (ND1, ND2 and ND4) genes . To test the hypotheses that ticks are monophyletic and that N. namaqua groups basal to the tick families, a concatenated supermatrix of the COI, Cytb, ND1, ND2 and ND4 protein genes were analysed using Bayesian analysis. The horseshoe crab, L. polyphemus and the pycnogonid, Achelia bituberculata were used as outgroups according to the Euchelicerate hypothesis . The majority of the nodes for the 50% consensus tree gave posterior probabilities above 95% (Fig. 3), which were considered to be significant . Within the Parasitiformes, N. namaqua grouped at the base of the Ixodida supporting the monophyly of ticks in agreement with previous analysis based on the nuclear 18S rRNA gene . The branch for the hard and soft tick families retrieved recognized relationships for the tick families and genera, with the Argasinae and Ornithodorinae forming a monophyletic clade . Relationships within the Metastriata did not correlate with nuclear 18S rRNA data, similar to recent findings based on mitochondrial data .
Figure 3. Bayesian analysis using the mitochondrial protein gene set (COI-Cytb-ND1- ND2-ND4).
The 50% consensus tree is shown with nodal posterior probability support above 90% indicated. Species are designated by their Genbank description lines and accession numbers in parenthesis. The scale bar indicates Bayesian distances.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049461.g003
Estimation of divergence dates for the major tick lineages
The topology obtained using Bayesian analysis (Fig. 3) was used for the estimation of divergence dates (Table 2). Divergence times were estimated for the Ixodida-Mesostigmata (350±23 MYA), Ixodida (319±25 MYA), the Argasidae-Ixodidae (290±23 MYA) and the Prostriate-Metastriates (249±23 MYA). Within the Argasidae the molecular divergence between the Argasinae and Ornithodorinae was estimated at 234±25 MYA and between the subgenus Ornithodoros and Carios (Alectorobius) capensis at 158±24 MYA. However, as indicated by cladistic as well as 16S analysis, a close genetic relationship exists between Alectorobius, Antricola and Nothoaspis – and these sub-genera were also included in this split.
Table 2. Estimation of the divergence dates for the major lineages of the Ixodida.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049461.t002
Implications of molecular clock estimates for the divergence of the major tick lineages
Molecular clock estimates placed the origin of ticks in the Carboniferous (Fig. 4), coinciding with the divergence of diapsids and synapsids . The estimates corresponded to previous estimates based on mitochondrial genome analysis , but were earlier than the proposed origins for the Ixodida in the middle Permian before the Late Permian extinction . The Permian hypothesis placed the origin of ticks in the Karoo basin in southern Africa and coincided with the origins of therapsids in this area , . However, due to extensive glaciation of southern Gondwana (330–290 MYA) that only ended in the early Permian –, and the limited distribution of N. namaqua in Africa , an origin in the Carboniferous would have had to occur in Northern Gondwana, most probably the region that now constitute Eastern Africa. This scenario implies subsequent migration and establishment of N. namaqua in the Karoo basin in the late Permian .
Figure 4. A model for the evolution of blood-feeding characteristics in the Ixodida.
Indicated are the date estimates for various nodes of the Ixodida and corresponding major events in evolution. Dates and names for Periods were obtained from the Geologic Time Scale . Blood feeding characters proposed to be present in ancestral and extant lineages are indicated by numbers at the different nodes and include: 1) Haller's organ for host detection. 2) Prolonged feeding in larvae and secretion of water via the salivary glands. 3) Prolonged feeding in nymphs and adults with water secretion via the salivary glands. 4) Rapid digestion of blood meal with lysis of red blood cells during engorgement. 5) One larval and nymphal molt. 6) Adult stages feed once and lay one large egg batch. 7) Presence of scutum. 8) Presence of pseudo-scutum. 9) Little or no cement. 10) Cement. 11) Fast feeding in nymphs and adults with water secretion via the Malpighian tubules. 12) Fast feeding in nymphs and adults with water secretion via the coxal organs. 13) Slow digestion of blood meal with little initial red blood cell lysis. 14) One larval and several nymphal molting stages. 15) Adult stages feed more than once and lay several small egg batches. 16) Loss of heme synthesizing capability and mechanisms to deal with heme toxicity.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049461.g004
Hard and soft ticks diverged during the Early Permian and coincided with the origin and diversification of therapsids –. Prostriate-metastriate divergence occurred after the End Permian extinction event and coincided with the diversification of dinosaurs, diapsids and synapsids –. The Prostriates can be divided into Ixodes from Australasia and the rest of the World, which grouped into specific clades that suggested geographical isolation . Molecular estimates for the divergence of the different Ixodes lineages occur well before the breakup of Gondwana into landmasses that separated Africa and Australia . The divergence of the metastriates correspond to the oldest ixodid fossils found to date, Cornupalpatum burmanicum, Compluriscutula vetulum and Amblyomma larvae, which were found in Burmese amber (100 MYA) –. These fossil species are morphologically the closest to the genus Amblyomma and therefore the root of the metastriate lineage. Divergence of the metastriates also coincided with the radiation of cenozoic mammals and marsupials . Within the metastriates, the genus Bothriocroton was considered basal and only occurred in Australia and this has been used as evidence for an origin of ticks as well as metastriate ticks in Australasia , . The estimates for the diversification of the metastriates and the breakup of Africa and Australia seem to support this. It should, however, be considered that Australia's link with Africa was via Antarctica, a large landmass that showed a rich fauna and flora before glaciation 35 MYA . South America was also linked to the Antarctic Peninsula up to 35 MYA . The origins of the Australian Ixodes lineage and the metastriate ticks could therefore have occurred in this area and colonization of the rest of the world by the metastriate ticks could have occurred via South America. It should also be noted that recent analysis of mitochondrial genomes of Bothriocroton placed doubt on its designation as a basal metastriate lineage , and by implication on the origins of ticks in the Australasian region.
Speciation of the Argasinae-Ornithodorinae occurred at a time when non-avian dinosaur lineages evolved feather-like appendages and when the most basal mammaliaform stem clades where diverging –. This could be significant since the main Argas sub-genera (Argas and Persicargas) are exclusive parasites of birds and their body plans are flat to enable movement through feathers, while most Ornithodorinae feed on mammals –, . Adaptation to the avian lineage would have been due to this ecological niche that opened up, rather than the much later evolution of flight , .
Estimates for the Ornithodoros-Alectorobius split predate the oldest argasid fossil, Carios jerseyi, identified in New Jersey amber (94 MYA) . The Ornithodoros-Alectorobius split occurred ~30 million years before the breakup of Africa and South America . It is likely that several basal sub-genera (i.e. Pavlovskyella, Reticulinasus) diverged in this period, which would put the divergence of the Alectorobius-Antricola lineage close to the Africa-South America breakup. This would fit with the majority of Alectorobius and all Antricola being endemic to the New World (Neotropics and Nearctic), while those species that do occur in the rest of the world parasitize marine birds –.
It is of interest, that the majority of ticks from the subgenera Alectorobius, Antricola, Carios, Chiropterargas, Nothoaspis, Parantricola, Reticulinasus and Subparmatus parasitize bats –, since the current molecular clock estimates would place the origin of these lineages above 100 MYA. Bats only originated in the Early Paleocene (~65 MYA)  which would suggest that all of these lineages adapted to bats independently, and is supported by paraphyly of Alectorobius-Antricola and Carios as suggested by 16S rRNA analysis. A possible common denominator in this would be that the ancestral Ornithodorinae parasitized burrow-inhabiting mammals that frequented cave systems and that the roosting behaviour of bats predisposed them towards parasitism by argasids. The peculiar biology of Antricola and Nothoaspis (adults are not obligate blood-feeding parasites, but possibly feed on bat guano) , would therefore be a recent derived character from within the Alectorobius lineage.
Biological data for ancestral character re-construction
Larval feeding of N. namaqua.
The biology of N. namaqua was further investigated to obtain information that can be used for ancestral character reconstruction. To this end, it was important to determine whether larvae feed in a prolonged manner like ixodids and some argasids, since this might provide clues to the large biological differences observed between hard and soft ticks . Since no data were available for the feeding kinetics of N. namaqua larvae, both lizards and mice were infested with recently hatched larvae. Larvae were obtained from two female ticks that each laid ~150 eggs from which larvae hatched after ~14 days . For lizards and mice, 9 and 50 larvae, respectively, fed to engorgement and molted to nymphs. In the case of the lizards the mean attachment time was 8–9 days and for the mice 4–5 days. In both cases a final rapid engorgement phase was observed on the last day of attachment. Approximately an eighty fold increase in body volume occurred during engorgement. Feeding of larvae on mice injected with bromophenol blue indicated that the salivary glands showed coloration, i.e. uptake of bromophenol blue, while the Malpighian tubules remained white. Similar results were obtained when it was shown that the coxal organs were responsible for water secretion in argasids , indicating active transport of bromophenol blue into these organs. Secretion of bromophenol blue stained saliva was also observed in a larvae that were detached prior to final engorgement. It was therefore concluded that the most likely route for blood meal concentration, is secretion of water back into the host, in a similar manner to ixodid ticks –.
Multiple feeding events and storage of blood meal.
The association of N. namaqua with a variety of hosts as revealed by gut meal analysis , raised questions regarding the ability to store blood meal over prolonged time periods, the maintenance of blood meal content during molting between life stages and whether ticks could feed multiple times. As proof of principle studies, intact red blood cells could be detected in the gut meal content of recently molted nymphs of which the larvae had fed on lizards (nucleated red blood cells) and mice (non-nucleated red blood cells), as well as an adult tick that fed more than six months previously. Female ticks that laid eggs, subsequently fed successfully and laid another egg batch. It was concluded that female N. namaqua could feed multiple times between egg laying cycles, stored blood meal for prolonged periods in an intact form and retained intact red blood cells after molting.
Reconstruction of the evolution of characters involved in blood-feeding behaviour
Phylogenetic analysis using the nuclear 18S rRNA gene and mitochondrial protein genes confirmed the grouping of N. namaqua at the base of the tick tree. This correlates with morphological and biological observations of different life stages of N. namaqua that indicate the presence of various features associated with both hard and soft ticks. It also assists in the evolutionary reconstruction of various characteristics associated with blood-feeding behaviour and the biology of ticks (Fig. 4), as well as a model for the differences observed between the hard and soft tick families .
Features that can be reconstructed as being present in ancestral tick lineages include (Fig. 4):
1) Haller's organ for host detection. Since Haller's organ is also present in the holothyrids , it was probably co-opted for host detection in the ancestral tick lineage.
2–3) Prolonged larval, nymphal and female feeding, with a rapid engorgement phase that results in blood meal intake >10-fold of body mass, accompanied by secretion of excess blood meal-derived water via the salivary glands. This feeding mode has been retained in larvae of N. namaqua and some argasid lineages (Argas, Alveonasus, Pavlovskyella, Alectorobius, Antricola), as well as all life stages of ixodids , , . In the subgenus Ornithodoros, larvae do not feed but molt directly to nymphs and should be considered a derived character , . We postulate that secretion of excess water via the salivary glands occurs in argasid larvae, since the latter unlike adults do not possess coxal organs . This is therefore an ancestral trait of larval feeding that was retained in nymphal and adult ixodid ticks.
4) Rapid lysis of red blood cells during prolonged feeding would allow for maximal concentration of the blood meal. This ability is present in all ixodids as well as some argasid larvae , although it was not specifically observed in N. namaqua larvae.
5–6) The ability to take in an excessively large blood meal and process it while feeding, probably led to subsequent changes in ixodid lifestyle that included a single nymphal molt and only one feeding event in the female before laying a large egg batch.
7–8) The presence of a scutum may be associated with the “ixodid-like” morphology of the larval ticks in the ancestral lineage that was retained by ixodids of all life stages. In this regard, the scutum serves a protective role against host grooming during the long attachment periods of feeding , . It also explains the presence of the pseudo-scutum in the nymphs and adults of N. namaqua. In this regard, the scutum was considered to be ancestral since it is also present in other mites .
9–10) Prolonged feeding led to ixodids developing the ability to anchor themselves mechanically in the hosts dermis using cement , . In prostriates, which have long mouthparts this ability is limited, while it is well developed in those metastriates with short mouthparts , , . This would seem to be a unique adaptation within the ixodid lineage, even though cement-like proteins are found in argasid salivary gland transcriptomes . The possibility therefore exists that cement might be secreted by argasid and N. namaqua larvae, which due to their small size has not been observed yet.
11–12) Rapid feeding in the nymphal and female stages occur in argasids and N. namaqua and were ancestral for ticks. The ancestral mode of dealing with excess water from the blood meal, was probably secretion via the Malpighian tubules as found in N. namaqua . This function in argasids was taken over by the coxal organs –. However, coxal organs are generally found in the Acari, the holothyrida included, and would therefore have been ancestral . Biological functions of coxal organs in the Acari are generally for the secretion of components involved in pre-oral digestion , and were probably lost in ixodids and N. namaqua, since secretion occurred via the salivary glands and Malpighian tubules. In the case of argasids their general increase in size might have led to the evolution of the coxal organs as a secretory system, as a more efficient mechanism of secretion compared to the Malpighian tubules.
13) During rapid feeding the blood meal ingested rarely exceeds 10-fold the body mass and is accompanied by little initial red blood cell lysis and slow digestion of the blood meal . This leads to the requirement for several nymphal molts and the female feeding more than once, laying small egg batches between feeding events. This lifestyle was retained in argasids and may be associated with the “argasid-like” morphology (leathery cuticle) of nymphal and adult ticks in the ancestral lineage , . In species of the Antricola, Nothoaspis, Subparmatus and Otobius sub-genera only larvae or nymphs require a blood-meal, while adults do not feed on vertebrates . This trait is considered derived and could be lifestyle dependent and led to a significant reduction in salivary gland proteins involved in the regulation of the hosts defence mechanisms .
14–15) From this reconstruction it is clear that lifestyle functions unique to either ixodid or argasid lineages were present in the ancestral lineage. Specific evolution of these traits in the soft and hard tick families were therefore not required, but by exaptation were modified to suit specific lineage lifestyles. In the case of argasids, their lifestyle resemble largely that of the ancestral lineage, i.e. targeting vertebrates that frequent burrows or return to specific habitats . This lifestyle accommodates shorter feeding events and the concomitant smaller egg batches, since progeny are guaranteed a blood-meal. In the case of ixodids, targeting of vertebrates without permanent burrows necessitated questing behaviour and strategies for optimal survival . It was estimated that less than 1% of ixodid progeny complete their lifecycle because they fail to encounter hosts . Ixodids therefore show a "type r" reproductive strategy, i.e. a high reproductive capacity to counteract low individual survival . By exaptation of the prolonged engorgement phase from larvae to nymphs and adults, ixodids reduced the number of nymphal stages and the number of feeding events (host encounters) required to lay the numbers of eggs necessary to ensure survival of a fraction of the population. In the extreme form, this resulted in the evolution from a three-host to one-host life-cycle as observed in the genus Rhipicephalus (Boophilus) . The evolution of ticks would therefore not have been necessarily shaped by host specificity but also by host and vector ecology , .
16) The presence of prolonged and rapid feeding capabilities in the ancestral lineage explains why ticks are the only blood-feeding arthropods with lineages that present both feeding modes. All other haematophagous arthropods feed rapidly . This raises the question why ticks have evolved both feeding modes. The sister-group to the ticks is the holothyrida, a group of free living arthropod scavengers . It has been assumed that ticks shared this lifestyle strategy before evolving blood-feeding behaviour . It was also considered that the ancestral lineage fed on lymphatic fluids of vertebrate hosts  and this feeding stage could have resulted in the long feeding periods observed in ancestral larvae. It is likely that ticks lost the ability to synthesize heme during this period and became obligate blood-feeding parasites . This in turn necessitated uptake of larger blood meals, which was initially accomplished by rapid feeding in nymphal and adult ticks. The lack of heme synthesizing capability has only been confirmed for ixodid ticks . However, all ticks utilize vitellogenin as heme carrier protein, a feature unique to the Ixodida . It′s therefore possible that loss of heme synthesizing capability and mechanisms to deal with heme toxicity occurred in the ancestral tick lineage.
The presence of shared characters in the Nuttalliella lineage that defines the major tick families is similar to that observed for stem groups, i.e. the presence of mixed characters found in extant lineages –. With the basal grouping of N. namaqua to the other tick families, this suggests that N. namaqua is not only the closest extant relative to the last common ancestral tick lineage, but may be an extant member of the stem group. This again supports the notion that this tick should be considered as a “living fossil” .
In conclusion, nuclear and mitochondrial markers confirm that N. namaqua groups basal to both tick families. Molecular clock estimates indicated an origin of ticks in the Carboniferous (319 MYA). Many features associated with the phylogeography and host preference of extant ticks supports this origin. Phylogenetic mapping of various features associated with blood-feeding behaviour suggests that both the prolonged feeding periods associated with ixodid feeding and the short feeding of argasids were present in the ancestral tick lineage. In addition, a number of characters unique to argasid or ixodid ticks are found in N. namaqua. This suggests that N. namaqua is an extant stem group lineage, and that its status as “living–fossil” remains valid.
Materials and Methods
All experiments related to lizard or mice feedings were performed in strict accordance with the Ethics guidelines from the Onderstepoort Veterinary Institute. Experiments were approved by the Onderstepoort Veterinary Institute Animal Ethics Committee (approval number: AEC12.11) and falls under the tick feeding and colony maintenance project. All necessary Nuttalliella collection and transport permits were obtained from the Veterinary Authorities (Permit number: SP2011/02/02/01).
The N. namaqua specimens used in the current study were collected as previously described . All necessary collection and transport permits were obtained from the Veterinary Authorities (Permit number: SP2011/02/02/01). In addition permission to collect ticks from Krymekaar and Voëlklip was granted by the owner, Mr. A. van Heerden. The A. africolumbae specimen was submitted to Onderstepoort for identification by Dr. Janet Mans, after this tick was found wandering among documents on the desk in her office at the Basic Medical Sciences Building, University of Pretoria, Pretoria. This building is the roosting site of numerous Speckled Rock pigeons and the tick was identified as a female A. africolumbae based on its original description , the fact that it was collected in the proximity of the original collection site and that it is the only member of the subgenus Argas thus far identified in South Africa.
Next generation sequencing of tick genomic DNA
Genomic DNA was extracted as previously described . Genomic DNA from single ticks (N. namaqua−40 ng, A. africolumbae−344 ng) was submitted to the Biotechnology Platform Next Generation Sequencing Service of the Agricultural Research Council (South Africa). Respectively, 26 and 55 ng of genomic DNA, for N. namaqua and A. africolumbae, was used for library preparation using the Nextera DNA sample preparation kit (Epicentre). Final prepared libraries were purified with the MinElute PCR purification kit (Qiagen) and quantified using a Qubit 2.0 fluorometer (Invitrogen). Sequencing was performed using Illumina V3 sequencing reagents and a mixture of Illumina and Nextera sequencing primers on the Illumina HiScanSQ sequencing machine. Single end sequencing reads of length 97 bp were generated, adapter sequences were trimmed and the last 19 bp removed before analysis. Reads were de novo assembled using the CLC Genomics Workbench v5.1 software package (mismatch cost-2, insertion cost-3, deletion cost-3, length fraction-0.5, similarity-0.95, minimum contig length-300, word size-50). The contigs obtained was formatted as a BLAST database and contigs coding for mitochondrial DNA were identified by TBLASTN analysis using the mitochondrial proteins from C. capensis and I. hexagonus as query sequences (Genbank accession numbers: 39653748, 5835680) , . For N. namaqua 22,452,825 (1.7 Gb) reads assembled into 7,305 contigs (6,760,983 reads). Of these two large contigs (Contig_755: 9,219 bp, 4,605 reads, 39.3 average coverage and Contig_752: 5,336 bp, 2,266 reads, 33.5 average coverage) were identified that covered 100% of the full-length mitochondrial genome with a final size of 14,431 bp (Genbank accession number: JQ665719). Overlaps between the contigs occurred within the COIII and ND6 genes, so that no ambiguity existed with regard to the gene order of the mitochondrial genome. For A. africolumbae 11,248,267 (0.88 Gb) reads assembled into 7,207 contigs (2,454,572 reads). One contig (Contig_7196: 14,528 bp, 52,074 reads, 280 average coverage) covered 100% of the full-length mitochondrial genome with a final size of 14,440 bp (Genbank accession number: JQ665720). Open reading frames for different mitochondrial proteins were identified by translation of DNA sequences using the invertebrate mitochondrial code (code 5). Non-coding regions that code for tRNAs were identified using the ARWEN server , or by global alignment to the mitochondrial genomes of O. moubata, O. porcinus, C. capensis, I. persulcatus and I. hexagonus. Ribosomal RNA (16S and 12S) and complementary loop regions were identified by BLAST analysis. The final assembled genome was used as a scaffold to map reads back to determine coverage using the CLC Genomics Workbench v5.1 software package (mismatch cost-2, insertion cost-3, deletion cost-3, length fraction-0.5, similarity-0.95). A total of 6,868 and 52,072 reads were mapped to the N. namaqua and A. africolumbae mitochondrial genomes giving ~37 and ~285 fold average coverage, respectively.
Phylogenetic analysis using the 16S rRNA gene
Soft tick sequences for the 16S rRNA gene was extracted from Genbank, as well as the sequences for N. namaqua and Allothyrida that was used as outgroups to give 44 sequences. Sequences were aligned using ClustalX , which yielded 299 parsimony informative sites. Maximum parsimony analysis was performed using MEGA5 . Gaps were treated as a fifth character using partial deletion and a site coverage of 80%, trees were searched using Close-Neighbor-Interchange with ten random initial trees and ten thousand bootstraps were performed to give a bootstrap 50% consensus tree.
Phylogenetic analysis using the 18S rRNA gene
The 18S rRNA gene for A. africolumbae was amplified, cloned and sequenced as previously described . Other tick, holothyrid and opilioacarid sequences were extracted from Genbank. Sequences were aligned using a consideration of the secondary structure of RNA (Q-INS-i) as implemented in MAFFT . Alignments were manually inspected, adjusted, edges trimmed, gapped positions and invariant sites removed to give 63 sequences with 273 phylogenetic informative sites. Bayesian analysis was performed using MrBayes 3.1.2 , using a General Time Reversible (GTR) model of nucleotide substitution with a proportion of invariant sites and a gamma distribution of among site heterogeneity using the nst = 6 rates = invgamma command. Four categories were used to approximate the gamma distribution and two runs were performed simultaneously, each with four Markov chains (one cold, three heated), which ran for 3,000,000 generations. The first 2,000,000 generations were discarded from the analysis (burnin) and every 100th tree was sampled to calculate a 50% majority-rule consensus tree. Nodal values represent the posterior probability that the recovered clades exist, given the sequence dataset and are considered significant above 95% .
Bayesian analysis of mitochondrial protein sequences
Sequences for the COI, Cytochrome b, ND1, ND2 and ND4 genes were extracted from the available arachnid mitochondrial genomes in GenBank. Multiple sequence alignment for each protein was performed separately using ClustalX . All ambiguous sites (positions with gaps) were removed and alignments were concatenated to produce a supermatrix that existed of 1561 positions of which 1228 were variable (i.e. phylogenetically informative). A maximum likelihood search was performed to find the amino acid substitution model that fits the dataset the best using MEGA5 . The MtREV24 +G +I model gave the lowest Bayesian information criterion (BIC) score (195023, range: 189933–225340) while using the lowest number of parameters (121, range: 119–140) with gamma shape parameter of 0.82.
Bayesian analysis was performed using MrBayes 3.1.2 , using the MtRev model of amino acid substitution with a proportion of invariant sites and a gamma distribution (Gamma factor = 0.82) of among site heterogeneity using the nst = 6 rates = invgamma command. Two runs were performed simultaneously, each with four Markov chains (one cold, three heated) which ran for 3,000,000 generations. The split frequencies were analysed to determine where the data converge and were used to determine the burnin at 1,000,000 generations. Every 100th tree was sampled to calculate a 50% majority-rule consensus tree from 40002 trees analysed. Nodal values represent the posterior probability that the recovered clades exist, given the sequence dataset and are considered significant above 95% .
Molecular clock estimation
Molecular clock estimates were performed using Bayesian analysis with PhyloBayes 3.3b . The multiple alignment and topology of the 50% consensus tree obtained from the previous phylogenetic analysis of the mitochondrial genomes using MrBayes was used as input. The Xiphosura-Pycnogonida node (445±5 MYA) was used to calibrate the root of the tree, while minimum ages were assigned to the Ornithodorinae (94 MYA) and Metastriate (100 MYA) nodes –, , . A. bituberculata was specified as outgroup and a log-normal autocorrelated relaxed clock (-ln) was assumed, with a uniform prior on divergence times. A gamma prior of mean 2000 and standard deviation of 2000 million years were specified for the age of the root. Two runs were done for each analysis to determine that convergence occurred and for each run approximately 38000 cycles were run of which the first 2500 were discarded for the analysis. Dates used for Periods and Epochs are from the most recent Geologic Time Scale .
Tick feeding on lizards and mice
Larvae were either fed on skinks (Mabuya genus) captured at Onderstepoort Veterinary Institute or Balb/c mice. Larvae were manually placed on animals and allowed to attach before animals were placed in their cages and monitored until larvae dropped. For proof of principle that larvae secrete water via their salivary glands, ticks were prefed on mice for three days, after which mice were injected intravenously with 100 mg/kg bromophenol blue in phosphate buffered saline solution. Larvae were removed after another five hours of feeding or were allowed to detach.
We thank Mr. A. van Heerden for permission to search his farm for ticks and Dr. Janet Mans who submitted the A. africolumbae tick to Onderstepoort for analysis.
Conceived and designed the experiments: BJM DDK RP MDC AAL. Performed the experiments: BJM DDK RP MDC AAL. Analyzed the data: BJM DDK RP MDC AAL. Wrote the paper: BJM DDK RP MDC AAL.
- 1. Barker SC, Murrell A (2004) Systematics and evolution of ticks with a list of valid genus and species names. Parasitology 129: S15–S36. doi: 10.1017/s0031182004005207
- 2. Guglielmone AA, Robbins RG, Apanaskevich DA, Petney TN, Estrada-Pena A, et al. (2010) The Argasidae, Ixodidae and Nuttalliellidae (Acari: Ixodida) of the world: a list of valid species names. Zootaxa 2528: 1–28.
- 3. Sonenshine DE (1991) Biology of ticks. Volume 1. Oxford University Press. 447p.
- 4. Mans BJ, Neitz AW (2004) Adaptation of ticks to a blood-feeding environment: evolution from a functional perspective. Insect Biochem Mol Biol 34: 1–17. doi: 10.1016/j.ibmb.2003.09.002
- 5. Mans BJ, de Klerk D, Pienaar R, Latif AA (2011) Nuttalliella namaqua: a living fossil and closest relative to the ancestral tick lineage: implications for the evolution of blood-feeding in ticks. PLoS One 6: e23675. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0023675
- 6. Bedford GAH (1931) Nuttalliella namaqua, a new genus and species of tick. Parasitology 23: 230–232. doi: 10.1017/s0031182000013573
- 7. Keirans JE, Clifford CM, Hoogstraal H, Easton ER (1976) Discovery of Nuttalliella namaqua Bedford (Acarina: Ixodoidea: Nuttalliellidae) in Tanzania and redescription of the female based on scanning electron microscopy. Ann Entomol S Amer 69: 926–932.
- 8. Latif AA, Putterill JF, de Klerk DG, Pienaar R, Mans BJ (2012) Nuttalliella namaqua (Ixodoidea: Nuttalliellidae): First Description of the Male, Immature Stages and Re-Description of the Female. PLoS One 7: e41651. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0041651
- 9. Klompen H, Lekveishvili M, Black WC 4th (2007) Phylogeny of parasitiform mites (Acari) based on rRNA. Mol Phylogenet Evol 43: 936–951. doi: 10.1016/j.ympev.2006.10.024
- 10. Jeyaprakash A, Hoy MA (2009) First divergence time estimate of spiders, scorpions, mites and ticks (subphylum: Chelicerata) inferred from mitochondrial phylogeny. Exp Appl Acarol 47: 1–18. doi: 10.1007/s10493-008-9203-5
- 11. Talavera G, Vila R (2011) What is the phylogenetic signal limit from mitogenomes? The reconciliation between mitochondrial and nuclear data in the Insecta class phylogeny. BMC Evol Biol 11: 315. doi: 10.1186/1471-2148-11-315
- 12. Rehm P, Borner J, Meusemann K, von Reumont BM, Simon S, et al. (2011) Dating the arthropod tree based on large-scale transcriptome data. Mol Phylogenet Evol 61: 880–887. doi: 10.1016/j.ympev.2011.09.003
- 13. Meusemann K, von Reumont BM, Simon S, Roeding F, Strauss S, et al. (2010) A phylogenomic approach to resolve the arthropod tree of life. Mol Biol Evol 27: 2451–2464. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msq130
- 14. Burger TD, Shao R, Beati L, Miller H, Barker SC (2012) Phylogenetic analysis of ticks (Acari: Ixodida) using mitochondrial genomes and nuclear rRNA genes indicates that the genus Amblyomma is polyphyletic. Mol Phyl Evol 64: 45–55. doi: 10.1016/j.ympev.2012.03.004
- 15. Hoogstraal H, Kaiser MN, Walker JB, Ledger JA, Converse JD, et al. (1975) Observations on the subgenus Argas (Ixodoidea: Argasidae: Argas). 10. A. (A.) africolumbae, n. sp, a Pretoria virus-infected parasite of birds in southern and eastern Africa. J Med Entomol 12: 194–201.
- 16. Black WC 4th, Roehrdanz RL (1998) Mitochondrial gene order is not conserved in arthropods: prostriate and metastriate tick mitochondrial genomes. Mol Biol Evol 15: 1772–1785. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.molbev.a025903
- 17. Shao R, Barker SC, Mitani H, Aoki Y, Fukunaga M (2005) Evolution of duplicate control regions in the mitochondrial genomes of metazoa: a case study with Australasian Ixodes ticks. Mol Biol Evol 22: 620–629. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msi047
- 18. Shao R, Aoki Y, Mitani H, Tabuchi N, Barker SC, et al. (2004) The mitochondrial genomes of soft ticks have an arrangement of genes that has remained unchanged for over 400 million years. Insect Mol Biol 13: 219–224. doi: 10.1111/j.0962-1075.2004.00447.x
- 19. Nava S, Guglielmone AA, Mangold AJ (2009) An overview of systematics and evolution of ticks. Front Biosci 14: 2857–2877. doi: 10.2741/3418
- 20. Estrada-Peña A, Mangold AJ, Nava S, Venzal JM, Labruna M, et al. (2010) A review of the systematics of the tick family Argasidae (Ixodida). Acarologia 50: 317–333. doi: 10.1051/acarologia/20101975
- 21. Hoogstraal H (1985) Argasid and Nuttalliellid ticks as parasites and vectors. Adv Parasitol 24: 135–238. doi: 10.1016/s0065-308x(08)60563-1
- 22. Klompen JSH, Oliver JH (1993) Systematic relationships in the soft ticks (Acari: Ixodida: Argasidae). Sys Entomol 18: 313–331. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-3113.1993.tb00669.x
- 23. Klompen JS, Black WC 4th, Keirans JE, Oliver JH Jr (1996) Evolution of ticks. Annu Rev Entomol 41: 141–161. doi: 10.1146/annurev.en.41.010196.001041
- 24. Hassanin A (2006) Phylogeny of Arthropoda inferred from mitochondrial sequences: strategies for limiting the misleading effects of multiple changes in pattern and rates of substitution. Mol Phylogenet Evol 38: 100–116. doi: 10.1016/j.ympev.2005.09.012
- 25. Talavera G, Vila R (2011) What is the phylogenetic signal limit from mitogenomes? The reconciliation between mitochondrial and nuclear data in the Insecta class phylogeny. BMC Evol Biol 11: 315. doi: 10.1186/1471-2148-11-315
- 26. Giribet G, Edgecombe GD (2012) Reevaluating the arthropod tree of life. Annu Rev Entomol 57: 167–186. doi: 10.1146/annurev-ento-120710-100659
- 27. Alfaro ME, Zoller S, Lutzoni F (2003) Bayes or bootstrap? A simulation study comparing the performance of Bayesian Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling and bootstrapping in assessing phylogenetic confidence. Mol Biol Evol 20: 255–266. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msg028
- 28. Benton MJ, Donoghue PCJ (2007) Paleontological evidence to date the Tree of Life. Mol Biol Evol 24: 26–53. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msl150
- 29. Rubridge BS (2005) Re-uniting lost continents - Fossil reptiles from the ancient Karoo and their wanderlust. S Afr J Geol 108: 135–172. doi: 10.2113/108.1.135
- 30. Fielding CR, Frank TD, Isbell JL (2008) The late Paleozoic ice age—A review of current understanding and synthesis of global climate patterns. Geol Soc Amer Special Paper 441: 343–354. doi: 10.1130/2008.2441(24)
- 31. Kemp TS (2005) The origin and early radiation of the therapsid mammal-like reptiles: a palaeobiological hypothesis. J Evol Biol 19: 1231–1247. doi: 10.1111/j.1420-9101.2005.01076.x
- 32. Sahney S, Benton MJ (2008) Recovery from the most profound mass extinction of all time. Proc R Soc B 275: 759–765. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2007.1370
- 33. Brusatte SL, Nesbitt SJ, Irmis RN, Butler RJ, Benton MJ, et al. (2010) The origin and early radiation of dinosaurs. Earth Sci Rev 101: 68–100. doi: 10.1016/j.earscirev.2010.04.001
- 34. Klompen JSH, Black WC IV, Keirans JE, Norris DE (2000) Systematics and biogeography of hard ticks, a total evidence approach. Cladistics 16: 79–102. doi: 10.1111/j.1096-0031.2000.tb00349.x
- 35. McLoughlin S (2001) The breakup history of Gondwana and its impact on pre-Cenozoic floristic provincialism. Aust J Bot 49: 271–300.
- 36. Poinar G, Brown AE (2003) A new genus of hard ticks in Cretaceous Burmese amber (Acari: Ixodida: Ixodidae). Syst Parasitol 54: 199–205. doi: 10.1023/a:1022689325158
- 37. Poinar GO, Buckley R (2008) Compluriscutula vetulum (Acari: Ixodida: Ixodidae), a new genus and new species of hard tick from Lower Cretaceous Burmese amber. Proc Entomol Soc Wash 110: 445–450. doi: 10.4289/07-014.1
- 38. Grimaldi DA, Engel MS, Nascimbene PC (2002) Fossiliferous Cretaceous amber from Myanmar (Burma): Its rediscovery, biotic diversity, and paleontological significance. Am Mus Nov 3361: 1–72. doi: 10.1206/0003-0082(2002)361<0001:fcafmb>2.0.co;2
- 39. Luo Z, Yuan C, Meng Q, Ji Q (2011) A Jurassic eutherian mammal and divergence of marsupials and placentals. Nature 476: 442–445. doi: 10.1038/nature10291
- 40. Barker SC, Murrel A (2002) Phylogeny, evolution and historical zoogeography of ticks: a review of recent progress. Exp Appl Acarol 28: 55–68. doi: 10.1023/a:1025333830086
- 41. Luo Z (2007) Transformation and diversification in early mammal evolution. Nature 450: 1011–1019. doi: 10.1038/nature06277
- 42. Chaippe LM, Dyke GJ (2002) The Mesozoic radiation of birds. Annu Rev Ecol Sys 33: 91–124. doi: 10.1146/annurev.ecolsys.33.010802.150517
- 43. Oliver JH Jr (1989) Biology and systematics of ticks (Acari: Ixodida). Ann Rev Ecol Syst 20: 397–430. doi: 10.1146/annurev.es.20.110189.002145
- 44. Klompen H, Grimaldi D (2001) First Mesozoic record of a parasitiform mite: A larval argasid tick in Cretaceous amber (Acari: Ixodida: Argasidae). Ann Entomol Soc Am 94: 10–15. doi: 10.1603/0013-8746(2001)094[0010:fmroap]2.0.co;2
- 45. Teeling EC, Springer MS, Madsen O, Bates P, O'Brien SJ, et al. (2005) A molecular phylogeny for bats illuminates biogeography and the fossil record. Science 307: 580–584. doi: 10.1126/science.1105113
- 46. Lees AD (1946) Chloride regulation and the function of coxal glands in ticks. Parasitology 37: 172–184. doi: 10.1017/s0031182000013330
- 47. Balashov YS (1972) Bloodsucking ticks (Ixodideae) - vectors of disease of man and animals. Misc Pub Entomol Soc Amer 8: 161–376.
- 48. Moorhouse DE (1975) Studies on the feeding of larval Argas persicus Oken Z Parasitenk. 48: 65–71. doi: 10.1007/bf00389830
- 49. Klompen JSH, Oliver JH Jr, Keirans JE, Homsher PJ (1997) A re-evaluation of relationships in the Metastriata (Acari: Parasitiformes: Ixodidae). Syst Parasitol 38: 1–24. doi: 10.1023/a:1005815925466
- 50. Maruyama SR, Anatriello E, Anderson JM, Ribeiro JM, Brandão LG, et al. (2010) The expression of genes coding for distinct types of glycine-rich proteins varies according to the biology of three metastriate ticks, Rhipicephalus (Boophilus) microplus, Rhipicephalus sanguineus and Amblyomma cajennense. BMC Genomics 11: 363. doi: 10.1186/1471-2164-11-363
- 51. Alberti G, Coons L (1999) Acari: Mites, in F.W. Harrison and R.F. Foelix (eds), Microscopic Anatomy of Invertebrates. Volume 8C. Chelicerate Arthopoda. New York: Wiley-Liss, 515–1265
- 52. Ribeiro JMC, Labruna MB, Mans BJ, Maruyama SR, Francischetti IMB, et al. (2012) The sialotranscriptome of Antricola delacruzi female ticks is compatible with non-hematophagous behavior and an alternative source of food. Insect Biochem Mol Biol 42: 332–342. doi: 10.1016/j.ibmb.2012.01.003
- 53. Nuttall GHF (1911) On the adaptation of ticks to the habits of their hosts. Parasitology 4: 46–67. doi: 10.1017/s0031182000002456
- 54. McKeever DJ (2009) Bovine immunity – a driver for diversity in Theileria parasites? Trends Parasitol 25: 269–276. doi: 10.1016/j.pt.2009.03.005
- 55. Mans BJ (2011) Evolution of vertebrate hemostatic and inflammatory control mechanisms in blood-feeding arthropods. J Innate Immun 3: 41–51. doi: 10.1159/000321599
- 56. Walter DE, Proctor HC (1998) Feeding behaviour and phylogeny: observations on early derivative Acari. Exp Appl Acarol 22: 39–50.
- 57. Donohue KV, Khalil SMS, Sonenshine DE, Roe RM (2009) Heme-binding storage proteins in the Chelicerata. J Insect Phys 55: 287–296. doi: 10.1016/j.jinsphys.2009.01.002
- 58. Budd GE (2003) The Cambrian Fossil Record and the Origin of the Phyla. Integr Comp Biol 43: 157–165. doi: 10.1093/icb/43.1.157
- 59. Budd GE (2001) Tardigrades as ‘Stem-Group Arthropods’: The Evidence from the Cambrian Fauna. Zool Anz 240: 265–279. doi: 10.1078/0044-5231-00034
- 60. Laslett D, Canbäck B (2008) ARWEN, a program to detect tRNA genes in metazoan mitochondrial nucleotide sequences. Bioinformatics 24: 172–175. doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btm573
- 61. Jeanmougin F, Thompson JD, Gouy M, Higgins DG, Gibson TJ (1998) Multiple sequence alignment with Clustal X. Trends Biochem Sci 23: 403–405. doi: 10.1016/s0968-0004(98)01285-7
- 62. Tamura K, Peterson D, Peterson N, Stecher G, Nei M, et al. (2011) MEGA5: Molecular evolutionary genetics analysis using maximum likelihood, evolutionary distance, and maximum parsimony methods. Mol Biol Evol 28: 2731–2739. doi: 10.1093/molbev/msr121
- 63. Katoh K, Toh H (2008) Improved accuracy of multiple ncRNA alignment by incorporating structural information into a MAFFT-based framework. BMC Bioinformatics 9: 212. doi: 10.1186/1471-2105-9-212
- 64. Ronquist F, Huelsenbeck JP (2003) MrBayes 3: Bayesian phylogenetic inference under mixed models. Bioinformatics 19: 1572–1574. doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btg180
- 65. Lartillor N, Lepage T, Blanquart S (2009) PhyloBayes 3: a Bayesian software package for phylogenetic reconstruction and molecular dating. Bioinformatics 25: 2286–2288. doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btp368
- 66. Dunlop JA (2010) Geological history and phylogeny of Chelicerata. Arthropod Struct Dev 39: 124–142. doi: 10.1016/j.asd.2010.01.003
- 67. Walker JD, Geissman JW, Compilers (2009) Geologic Time Scale. Geol Soc Amer. Doi: 10.1130/2009.CTS004R2C.