Figures
Abstract
The ratio between lengths of digit II and IV (digit ratio 2D:4D) is a morphological feature that likely affects tetrapod locomotor performances in different microhabitats. Modifications of this trait may be triggered by changes in steroids concentrations during embryo development, which might reflect direct selection acting on digit ratio or be solely a consequence of hormonal differences related for example to body size. Here we apply both conventional and phylogenetic analyses on morphological data from 25 lizard species of 3 families of Iguania (Iguanidae, Polychrotidae, and Tropiduridae), in order to verify whether selective pressures related to locomotion in different microhabitats could override the prenatal developmental cues imposed on the digit ratio 2D:4D by differences in body size between males and females. Data suggest that this trait evolved in association with ecological divergence in the species studied, despite the clear effect of body size on the digit ratio 2D:4D. The ecological associations of size-corrected digit ratios were restricted to one sex, and females of species that often use perches exhibited small digit ratios in the front limbs, which translated into larger sexual dimorphism indexes of arboreal species. The results, together with the subsequent discussion, provide outlines for further investigation about possible developmental mechanisms related to the evolution of adaptive changes in digit lengths that may have occurred during the evolution of ecological divergence in squamates.
Citation: Gomes CM, Kohlsdorf T (2011) Evolution of Sexual Dimorphism in the Digit Ratio 2D:4D - Relationships with Body Size and Microhabitat Use in Iguanian Lizards. PLoS ONE 6(12): e28465. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0028465
Editor: Vincent Laudet, Ecole Normale Supérieure de Lyon, France
Received: June 21, 2011; Accepted: November 8, 2011; Published: December 5, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Gomes, Kohlsdorf. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This study was financed by a FAPESP (Fundacao de Amparo a Pesquisa do Estado de Sao Paulo, Brazil) grant to TK (2005/60140-4) and an undergraduate fellowship to CMG (Pró-Reitoria de Pesquisa from University of São Paulo, Brazil). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
The association between ecological diversity and morphological variation is very well documented in several animal taxa (e.g. Anurans: [1]–[5], Reptiles: [6]–[13], Mammals: [14]–[19]), although information about the mechanisms that probably elicit evolutionary changes in morphology during a process of ecological divergence is still scarce and restricted to few biological groups (for examples see [20], [21]). Evolutionary changes in the shape and size of a given structure are believed to reside on alterations that occurred during embryo development [22]–[27], but the evolution of morphological variation is very often inferred from adult morphologies, probably because in nature embryos are usually hard to access. The relationship between morphological divergence and possible deviations from an ancestral developmental program is difficult to infer also because the new shape or size of a given structure may either be an evolutionary response to direct selection or a consequence of selection acting on a different trait. For example, differences in the selective pressures related to microhabitats that are structurally distinct might result in morphological variation of structures used during locomotion, but such variation could also be a consequence of selection acting on other traits, such as clutch size or body mass. One morphological feature that may exemplify these postulated scenarios is the digit ratio 2D:4D. This trait likely affects locomotion, and therefore may diverge in response to ecological differentiation among lineages, but it is also possible that digit proportions modify exclusively as a consequence of changes in developmental programs triggered by variation in body size.
The ratio between the lengths of digit II and IV in tetrapods (digit ratio 2D:4D; [28]) is determined during embryo development, and differences between males and females may evolve through changes in prenatal steroids concentrations. In some mammals, females have larger digit ratios 2D:4D than males [29]-[31], in contrast with species of reptiles and birds where males have usually higher values than females [e.g. 32–34]. This morphological feature is established mostly during the embryonic period, and changes little after sexual maturation [35]–[39]. Limb development and digit elongation are coordinated by expression of Hox genes (for example, Hoxa-13 [40] and Hoxd-13 [41]), which in turn is directly affected by the concentration of sex hormones (testosterone and estrogen) in the embryo [42]. In this context, a subtle variation in the embryo's sexual steroids concentrations seems sufficient to modify the relative lengths of digits II and IV observed in adults [36], [37], [43]. The actions of androgens and estrogens on digit development are distinct: estrogen concentration positively affects the length of digit II, while testosterone levels seem related to the length of digit IV [28]. Consequently, the ratio between the lengths of digits II and IV (2D:4D) may be sexually dimorphic, which would be modulated by the differential concentration of these two hormones in developing male and female embryos [44]. It is not clear, however, if these probable differences in hormone levels between sexes are always primarily related to variation in sexual traits, such as body size, or if this developmental program could deviate from the ancestral state by selection acting directly on the digit ratio 2D:4D.
Sexual dimorphism in digit ratio 2D:4D has been reported in almost all tetrapod groups (lizards: [34], [35]; birds: [32]; mammals: [31], [45]; and particularly humans: [28], [42], [46]–[48]), but the historical processes that might lead to evolution of this pattern remain obscure, and it is not clear whether differences between males and females in autopodial morphology could have evolved independently from the divergences in body size. The connection between relative digit lengths and microhabitat usage is very feasible, given that in several taxa foot morphology is associated for example with the locomotor performance exhibited in different ecological settings (e.g. [49]–[56]), and may as well affect other ecological activities, as basking, foraging, and mating. Evolution of autopodium morphology in the context of habitat usage is particularly well investigated in squamates, where evolution of limb and foot lengths seems clearly associated with locomotion on different surfaces (e.g. [9], [11], [13], [53], [57]–[59]). Lizards constitute a great model for the investigation of this relationship because of their extensive morphological variation, great ecological diversity, and broad use of different locomotor modes, such as running, jumping, and climbing (e.g. [60]–[65]). Moreover, associations between morphology and ecology have been reported in several families, as Polychrotidae (particularly Anolis [6], [7], [57], [66]–[68]), Iguanidae [69], and Tropiduridae [9], [10], [13], [64], [70]–[72]. Some studies suggest for example that species from sandy environments exhibit longer feet (e.g. [9], [13]), although variation in squamate autopodium morphology in the context of habitat use is often inferred based exclusively on the length of the fourth toe. Thus, investigation of morphological divergence in this structure usually does not consider differences among digit ratios, and to our knowledge possible ecological associations of the digit ratio 2D:4D remain unexplored in a comparative framework. One complicating factor is that variation in this feature may also reflect hormonal changes related to differences in body size, and there is evidence that the snout-vent length is associated with ecological divergence in some lizard groups (e.g. [66], [71]). In this scenario, it remains obscure whether the digit ratio may evolve in association with ecological divergence in the absence of correlations between ecology and body mass. Such disconnection would provide evidence that ecological relationships of digit proportions may override the developmental program imposed exclusively by variation in steroids concentrations due to size differences between males and females.
Based on the theoretical context presented here, it is conceivable that the digit ratio 2D:4D may have evolved in parallel with ecological diversity in some clades of Squamata. even if part of the differences between sexes observed in this trait likely reflects variation in hormone levels related to divergence in body size. For example, it is plausible to expect that arboreal species would exhibit larger differences among digit lengths in the autopodium (i.e. smaller digit ratios), which would be particularly relevant for lizards that occupy the canopies and face a three-dimensional structural complexity composed by perches disposed on various orientations. However, if most of the arboreal species also exhibit larger body sizes (or increased dimorphism in body mass between sexes), variation in autopodial morphology could reflect developmental changes exclusively associated with differences in body mass. The present study tested the feasibility of these evolutionary scenarios, and verified whether selective pressures related to locomotion in different microhabitats could override the prenatal developmental cues imposed on the digit ratio 2D:4D by differences in body size between males and females. We predict that this morphological feature will be correlated with body size both in males and females of iguanian lizards, but size-corrected digit ratios may exhibit ecological associations even in the absence of significant correlations between body size and microhabitat indices. These ideas were examined using lizard species from three families of Iguania (Iguanidae, Polychrotidae, and Tropiduridae), and the evolution of ecological associations of body size and the digit ratio 2D:4D in iguanian lizards was tested considering males and females separately. All lineages of this clade, without exception, are pentadactylus (i.e. with five digits [73]), so in this group variation in autopodium morphology is given mostly by changes in the lengths of homologous structures, rather than by loss or fusion of osteological elements.
Methods
(a) Animals and Measurements
The present study was based on measurements of body size (SVL) and digit lengths (digits II and IV from the front and hind limbs) obtained for 25 species from 3 major families of Iguania: Iguanidae, Polychrotidae, and Tropiduridae (Table 1). Whenever it was possible, we preferred to use specimens from a single population. Up to 20 specimens of each species (see Table 1), including males and females, were measured using a digital caliper (accurate to 0.01 mm). For each species, specimens measured were the largest ones available at the Brazilian Herpetological Collections visited (MZUSP and INPA). Our study was performed using specimens from institutional herpetological collections of two Brazilian Museums of Natural History and, therefore, there was no need of approval from the ethics committee, as the study did not involve capture or manipulation of live animals.
Mean and standard error of SVL and digit ratio 2D:4D were calculated for each species separately for males and females. All morphological traits (i.e. digit lengths and SVL) were log10 transformed prior to calculations, and the digit ratio 2D:4D was calculated individually for front and hind limbs, by dividing length of digit II by the length of digit IV (both log transformed), as commonly reported in the current literature [28], [29], [33], [34]. Digit ratio 2D:4D ranged from 0 to 1, where values close to 1 were observed when digits II and IV had very similar lengths and very low values correspond to a morphology where digit IV is much larger than digit II. Digit ratio was significantly correlated with body size both in males and females, as is detailed in the results, and therefore the trait was corrected by SVL. Size-correction was performed following [74], and we computed residuals from a least squares regression analysis performed using a matrix containing information for the expected covariances of the data that are explained by the phylogenetic relationships among taxa. This transformation was performed using the R code described in [74] and a matrix with expected covariances proportional to a topology with Nee's branch lengths (see details for the topology in the item ‘d’ of the present section; diagnostic plots are presented in the supporting information file ‘METHODS- S1’).
We also calculated an index of sexual dimorphism (SDI) in the digit ratio 2D:4D for each species, based on the approach described by [75]. This calculation was performed using the size-corrected 2D:4D digit ratios explained above. Sexual dimorphism indexes are usually calculated by dividing the values of males by those of the females, but [75] suggests that an alternative calculation must be implemented when females exhibit values of the trait that are larger than those observed in the males. Specifically, the idea is to calculate the SDI using the standard approach only when the variable is larger in males: in our study, for all species where the largest values of digit ratio were associated to males SDI was calculated by dividing male's by female's values. According to [75], however, when the trait is larger in females, the SDI shall be calculated as [2-(female/male)]: in our study, this formula was applied for the species where the largest values of digit ratio were observed in the females. The residuals computed from the size-correction analysis detailed above [74] may be either positive or negative, which could influence the signal associated with the calculated SDI because it always results from a division between two traits. Therefore, we have turned all residuals computed from the size-correction transformation into positive values, by adding 1.0, and then calculated SDI as described above. Only right-side values were used in the comparative analyses, as most species studied (87%) were symmetrical between left and right sides.
(b) Ecological Indices
The evolutionary patterns of digit ratio 2D:4D in males and females of iguanian lizards were analyzed in relation to substrate use. Ecological indices reflecting the percentage of substrate usage were calculated based on published literature (see supporting information file ‘TABLE-S1’), which resulted in five ecological categories: sand, rocks, trunks, perches (branches+leaves), and ground (Table 2). These indices reflect the percentage of lizards from a given population found in each substrate type when performing ecologically relevant activities, as basking, foraging, mating, exploring the territory or evading predators. Values ranged from zero to one: values equal to one for a particular substrate indicate that all individuals of that species were observed on this substrate, while the value ‘zero’ was attributed to ecological categories where no individuals of the species were found. Due to the lack of information about sexual differences in substrate use for most of the species included here, the ecological indices were constructed for the species, and then were used as independent variables in regressions with the morphological variables (male and female digit ratios 2D:4D and SDI, all traits estimated for front and hind limbs).
(c) Statistical Analyses
The presence of sexual dimorphism in the digit ratio 2D:4D in Iguania was first verified by comparing mean values of the ratios between males and females, using paired t-tests (implemented in R; version 2.8.1; R Development Core Team, 2008). Given that body size may have a strong association with the levels of hormones secreted during development, which in turn may also affect the digit ratio 2D:4D, statistical associations between these two morphological traits were inferred using Pearson Correlations implemented in R (version 2.8.1; R Development Core Team, 2008). Correlations were implemented using log transformed variables (i.e. log2D/log4D and logSVL), as detailed above, and were performed using both conventional and phylogenetic statistics. Both analyses were implemented in R; the phylogenetic correlation was performed using independent contrasts, calculated with the packages geiger and picante and the topology with Nee's branch lengths that is detailed in the following section.
The digit ratios 2D:4D of front and hind limbs were significantly correlated to SVL both in males and females of Iguania (see results), and therefore a size-correction transformation was performed following [74], as detailed above. Morphological data of digit ratios and SDI were then analyzed in relation to substrate usage using both conventional and phylogenetic statistics, and the topology used is detailed in the next section (as well as in the supporting information file ‘METHODS- S1’). These associations between morphological traits (digit ratios in males and females and SDI) and ecological parameters (five categories that reflect the proportion of substrate used by a given species) were performed with REGRESSIONv.2.M for MATLAB (R2008 version for PC). In these analyses, OLS regressions (ordinary least-squares, based on a star phylogeny) and PGLS regressions (phylogenetic generalized least-squares, based on a hierarchical phylogeny) were compared by likelihood ratio tests, which indicate which of the two models better explains the data [13], [76]. The highest likelihood value indicates the model that better fits the data, and a model is considered significantly better than the other only if twice the difference between log-likelihood values is larger than 3.841, which is the critical value for a χ2 distribution with 1 d.f. and α = 0.05 [13], [77]. If the difference between log-likelihoods is lower than the critical value, then the phylogenetic model is preferred over the one assuming a star phylogeny.
The statistical design implemented here was based on multiple comparisons, and therefore the critical P values had to be corrected by the number of hypotheses tested. We tested for statistical associations of six traits among five substrates, using two models (star phylogeny and hierarchical topology), which equals to 60 hypotheses. A False Discovery Rate (FDR) analysis was carried out using the QVALUE software package [78] for R (version 2.8.1; R Development Core Team, 2008), with the ‘boostrap’ option. Significant q-values (corresponding to a positive FDR of 5%, [78]) indicate which significant regressions remain ‘true’ after correcting the analyses by the number of hypotheses being tested (in our study, 60).
(d) Phylogenetic Trees
The use of phylogenetic comparative methods requires the availability of a well-supported topology reflecting the evolutionary relationships among the groups studied. The phylogenetic relationships within Iguania are controversial, and a single hypothesis including all the genera studied here is not available. Because there is more than one phylogenetic hypothesis proposed for some of the genera studied, we have used some criteria for choosing the topology for each taxonomic group: 1) hypotheses with the largest number of the species studied here (in order to minimize the amount of compilations); 2) if more than one phylogenetic hypothesis for a given group fulfilled condition 1, we have used the topology that was proposed using different datasets (e.g., those including molecular and morphological data), or the one that included the largest amount of characters (see criteria used by [79]). We combined the published phylogenetic hypotheses available for several iguanian groups (within families: [80]; Tropiduridae: [81]; Polychrotidae: [82]; see supporting information file ‘METHODS-S1’ for details) into a single topology for the species studied here, using the program TREEVIEW for PC (Fig. 1).
The use of statistical methods based on phylogenies also presumes the adoption of branch lengths in units proportional to the expected variance of character evolution or to divergence time (reviewed in [13], [83]). It is suggested that the clade Iguania may have originated between 150 [84] and 180 Mya [85], but in the present study we have used a topology that is a composite of multiple phylogenetic hypotheses, and therefore precise estimates of phylogenetic branch lengths in units of divergence times or genetic distances are unavailable. Because the published phylogenetic hypotheses available for iguanians do not include the same molecular markers, we cannot run a new analysis to generate branch lengths proportional to rate of nucleotide substitutions. For these reasons, we have tested four different types of arbitrary branch lengths, including all = 1 (Constant) [86], Pagel [87], and Nee (cited in [88]), using the MS-DOS computer program PDTREE [89]–[91]. Nee branch lengths provided the best standardization of phylogenetically independent contrasts, which was indicated by the absence of statistically significant trends in all diagnostic plots produced using these branch lengths [92]. These diagnostic plots are presented in the supporting information file ‘FIGURE-S1’.
Results
The present study tested the hypothesis that variation in the digit ratio 2D:4D evolved in association with ecological divergence in Iguania, despite the expected effect of body size on the concentrations of steroids that ultimately determine the lengths of digits in the autopodium. In other words, we predict that the selective pressures imposed by locomotion in different microhabitats might overcome a developmental program imposed exclusively by the association of body size with the levels of hormones secreted in the embryo, so that size-corrected digit ratios might exhibit ecological associations even in the absence of significant correlations between body size and microhabitat indices. In the species studied, males overall exhibited larger digit ratios than females, both in the front limbs (Fig. 2A; paired t-tests: t = −2.086, d.f. = 24, P = 0.048) and in the hind limbs (Fig. 2B; paired t-tests: t = −2.496, d.f. = 24, P = 0.020). Differences in digit ratios might be explained by variation in body size, as all correlations between SVL and the digit ratios were significant, both in males and in females (Table 3), and males overall exhibited larger body sizes than females (paired t-tests: t = −3.565, d.f. = 24, P = 0.002). Our main hypothesis, however, predicts that selective pressures imposed by locomotion in different microhabitats might overcome part of the developmental program imposed by the association of body size with the levels of hormones secreted in the embryo. If this is true, then size-corrected digit ratios would be correlated microhabitat usage even when body size does not exhibit such ecological associations. In fact, SVL was not correlated with ecological indices, but both the digit ratios and the sexual dimorphism indices (SDI) exhibited significant associations with microhabitat usage (Table 4). Specifically, variation in the digit ratio 2D:4D was negatively correlated to the use of perches in Iguania, as females of species that move often on perches exhibit lower digit ratios in their front limbs (Table 4). Interestingly, such patterns were not identified in males, which may indicate the existence of sexual dimorphism in microhabitat use among arboreal iguanians.
Regression lines are included.
The differences in ecological associations of the digit ratio 2D:4D between males and females of Iguania are consistent with the results obtained for the sexual dimorphism index (SDI, size-corrected as described in the methods section). Calculated values of the SDI were statistically equivalent between front and hind limbs (Fig. 2C; paired t-tests: t = 0.321, d.f. = 24, P = 0.751), but this trait was significantly correlated to microhabitat usage only in the front limbs, where increased differences between males and females in digit ratios (given by larger values of SDI) were associated with the use of perches (Table 4).
Discussion
The presence of sexual dimorphism in the digit ratio 2D:4D has been suggested in representatives of most tetrapod groups (e.g. lizards: [34], [35]; birds: [32]; mammals: [28], [31], [42], [45]–[48]), but to our knowledge this is one of the first studies that uses a comparative framework to explore whether ecological divergence could trigger variation in autopodial morphology that might override the effects imposed on this morphological trait exclusively by sexual dimorphism of body size. Overall, in the species studied here the digit ratio 2D:4D differs between males and females, but the ecological associations identified were restricted to front limbs of females from iguanian lizards that often use perches. Body size was not related to microhabitat usage in the species of Iguania studied, which suggests that the selective pressures imposed by moving on arboreal environments likely modified a developmental program imposed on digit ratios exclusively by variation in hormone levels due to differences in body size. Interestingly, such ecological associations have evolved differently among males and females of iguanian lizards, and larger sexual dimorphism in the digit ratio 2D:4D is observed in the front limbs of arboreal species. We recognize that there may be multiple selecting forces acting on this scenario, so that effects of selection acting for example in male secondary sexual traits, which would be unrelated to habitat usage, might indirectly drive changes in androgens concentrations and affect the 2D:4D digit ratio. However, the patterns identified here suggest a clear association of digit ratios with ecological divergence that is independent of body size in Iguania, although the adaptive significance of the evolution of an autopodium sexually dimorphic in arboreal species remains to be tested.
The evolution of morphological differences between males and females in a given structure, as the autopodium, can be strongly associated with the performance exhibited in specific ecological settings, and very likely occurs in a scenario where the selective pressures acting over the trait are at least slightly distinct among sexes. Along these lines, our data suggests that some species of Iguania may be sexually dimorphic in relation to microhabitat usage, and maybe females of arboreal species differ from males in the diameter of the perches used or the time they spend basking or moving along different surfaces. Unfortunately, ecological information about sexual dimorphism of microhabitat usage in Iguania is still very scarce and limited to few species, so additional data on ecology is necessary to formally test this hypothesis. For example, although microhabitat use is apparently equivalent between males and females of some Tropidurinae species (e.g. T. itambere [93]), in this family there are also species that seem sexually dimorphic for ecological patterns (e.g. E. divaricatus, Zampieri & Kohlsdorf, pers. obs.; T. hygomi [94]). In Polychrotidae, there are some species where males and females apparently differ in microhabitat usage, as E. iheringi and E. perditus [95]. Given the fragmentation of this information set, our results emphasize the necessity of new data available from future studies focusing on sexual dimorphism and behavioral ecology of tropical lizards.
Evolutionary changes in the digit ratio 2D:4D associated with the use of different microhabitats are particularly interesting in a scenario where males and females exhibit different morphological patterns (as observed in Iguania) because some developmental mechanisms eliciting sexual dimorphism in digit lengths have already been proposed for tetrapods [36], [37], [42]. Specifically, Hox gene expression, which coordinates autopodium development, is influenced by sexual steroids [40], [42], and estrogen concentrations affect positively the lengths of digit II while digit IV length is affected by testosterone levels [28, but see 96]. In Anolis carolinensis lizards, estrogen concentration remains relatively constant during embryo development, but the testosterone levels reach their maximum concentrations in two developmental stages, the first peak derived from maternal supply around eight days after fecundation, and the second one produced by the embryo at the 24th day of incubation [97]. Digit patterning and elongation starts around the 11th day of incubation, so this process could be directly affected by maternal-origin testosterone [32], [33]. Moreover, as the process of digit growth may last until the second peak of testosterone (for details about variation in hormone concentrations during development, see [97], [98]), it is possible that digit length is also influenced by the amount of hormones produced by the embryo [99].
Developmental mechanisms may also explain how the ecological associations of the digit ratio 2D:4D observed in females of arboreal iguanians are restricted to the front limbs. Hind limb development often ends before the complete formation of the front limbs [100], and therefore changes in the timing and concentration of steroids secretion may also affect differently the development of these structures [101]. Although the present study did not quantify changes in steroids secretion during embryo development, it is possible to speculate that these evolutionary changes may have been modulated by modifications in hormone concentrations that differently affected front and hind limbs because development of these structures is temporally detached [101], [102]. A formal test of this hypothesis depends on embryo availability, which is constrained by the unsuitability of reproduction in captivity for most of the species studied.
The evolution of different morphological patterns of digit ratio in association with changes in microhabitat use possibly has biomechanical implications for locomotion on different surfaces, besides the likely effects on other ecological activities, as basking, foraging and mating. Grasping ability is particularly relevant for arboreal species [53], [59], [62], [103], where the front limb plays a major role of keeping the center of mass close to the surface [11], [62], and evolutionary changes in foot morphology associated to the use of branches (and rocks) have been reported in Tropidurinae lizards [13]. Females of iguanian species that often use perches tend to exhibit smaller digit ratios 2D:4D (i.e., digit IV is much longer than digit II); this may reflect sexual dimorphism in microhabitat usage in species from forested environments, although these data are not available from the current ecological literature on tropical lizards. Arboreal primates, for example, exhibit the fourth digit considerably longer than the second one [104], and lizards with longer digits presumably reach perches far apart easier and have enough body weight support when travelling among branches [103]–[105].
The adaptive meaning of the evolutionary patterns identified in Iguania for the digit ratio 2D:4D of males and females will certainly be clarified when performance data of males and females running on different substrates, in addition to ecological information of sexual dimorphism in microhabitat usage, are incorporated to the present framework. To our knowledge, studies based on phylogenetic methods that compare the evolution of digit ratio 2D:4D between males and females in a scenario contrasting ecological divergence with body size effects are rare or inexistent. In this context, our study provides evidence that ecological associations of the digit ratio 2D:4D, which are restricted to front limbs of iguanian females, evolved independently of associations between body size and microhabitat usage. Therefore, selective pressures related to ecological divergence may accommodate changes in steroids concentrations during embryo development that override the developmental program imposed exclusively by variation in body size. These results, together with the subsequent discussion, provide substrate for further investigation on developmental mechanisms associated to the evolution of adaptive changes occurring during the colonization of novel environments by squamates.
Supporting Information
Figure S1.
Diagnostic plots using Nee branch lengths.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0028465.s001
(TIFF)
Methods S1.
Description of the phylogenetic trees used in the present study.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0028465.s002
(DOC)
Table S1.
Information about the literature source used to calculate the ecological indices used in the regressions with morphological traits of digit ratio 2D:4D.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0028465.s003
(DOCX)
Acknowledgments
We acknowledge the Museum of Zoology of USP (Hussam Zaher and Carolina S Castro-Mello) and the Institute for Amazonian Research (Richard Vogt and Ronnezza C.L.C. Pedrett) for access to the herpetological collections. We also thank two anonymous reviewers, M Kohlsdorf and the members from the Laboratory of Evolution and Eco-physiology of Tetrapods (FFCLRP/USP) for comments on early drafts of this manuscript.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: TK CMG. Performed the experiments: CMG. Analyzed the data: TK. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: TK. Wrote the paper: TK CMG.
References
- 1. Lannoo M, Townsend D, Wassersug R (1987) Larval life in the leaves: Arboreal tadpole types, with special attention to the morphology, ecology, and behavior of the oophagous Osteopilus brunneaus (Hylidae) larva. Field Zool 38: 1–31.
- 2. McCollum SA, Leimberger JD (1997) Predator-induced morphological changes in an amphibian: predation by dragonflies affects tadpole shape and color. Oecologia 109: 615–621.
- 3. Relyea RA (2001) Morphological and Behavioral Plasticity of Larval Anurans in Response to Different Predators. Ecology 82: 523–540.
- 4. Laurila A, Pakkasmaa S, Crochet PA, Merilä J (2002) Predator-induced plasticity in early life history and morphology in two anuran amphibians. Oecologia 132: 524–530.
- 5. Relyea RA, Auld JR (2005) Predator- and Competitor-Induced Plasticity: How Changes in Foraging Morphology Affect Phenotypic Trade-Offs. Ecology 86: 1723–1729.
- 6. Losos JB, Sinervo B (1989) The effects of morphology and perch diameter on sprint performance of Anolis lizards. Journal of Experimental Biology 145: 23–30.
- 7.
Irschick D, Losos J (1996) Morphology, Ecology, and Behavior of the Twig Anole, Anolis angusticeps. In: Powell B, Henderson B, editors. Contributions to west indian herpetology: a tribute to Albert Schwartz. Ithaca, NY: Society for the study of amphibians and reptiles. pp. 291–301.
- 8. Aerts P, Damme RV, Vanhooydonck B, Zaaf A, Herrel A (2000) Lizard locomotion: how morphology meets ecology. Netherlands Journal of Zoology 50: 261–277.
- 9. Kohlsdorf T, Garland T, Navas CA (2001) Limb and tail lengths in relation to substrate usage in Tropidurus lizards. Journal of morphology 248: 151–164.
- 10. Kohlsdorf T, Grizante MB, Navas CA, Herrel A (2008) Head shape evolution in Tropidurinae lizards: does locomotion constrain diet? Journal of evolutionary biology 21: 781–790.
- 11. Herrel A, Meyers JJ, Vanhooydonck B (2002) Relations between microhabitat use and limb shape in phrynosomatid lizards. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 77: 149–163.
- 12. Irschick DJ, VanHooydonck B, Herrel A, Meyers J (2005) Intraspecific correlations among morphology, performance and habitat use within a green anole lizard (Anolis carolinensis) population. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 85: 211–221.
- 13. Grizante M, Navas C, Garland J, Kohlsdorf T (2010) Morphological evolution in Tropidurinae squamates: an integrated view along a continuum of ecological settings. Journal of evolutionary biology 23: 98–111.
- 14. Chivers DJ, Hladik CM (1980) Morphology of the gastrointestinal tract in primates: comparisons with other mammals in relation to diet. Journal of Morphology 166: 337–386.
- 15. Strait SG (1993) Molar morphology and food texture among small-bodied insectivorous mammals. Journal of Mammalogy 74: 391–402.
- 16. Jernvall J, Hunter J, Fortelius M (1996) Molar tooth diversity, disparity, and ecology in Cenozoic ungulate radiations. Science 274: 1489–1492.
- 17. MacFadden B, Shockey B (1997) Ancient feeding ecology and niche differentiation of Pleistocene mammalian herbivores from Tarija, Bolivia: morphological and isotopic evidence. Paleobiology 23: 77–100.
- 18. Freeman P (2000) Macroevolution in Microchiroptera: recoupling morphology and ecology with phylogeny. Evolutionary Ecology Research 2: 317–335.
- 19. Miller-Butterworth C, Jacobs D, Harley E (2003) Strong population substructure is correlated with morphology and ecology in a migratory bat. Nature 424: 187–191.
- 20. O'Meara BC, Ané C, Sanderson MJ, Wainwright PC (2006) Testing for different rates of continuous trait evolution using likelihood. Evolution 60: 922–933.
- 21. Collar D, Wainwright P (2006) Discordance between morphological and mechanical diversity in the feeding mechanism of centrarchid fishes. Evolution 60: 2575–2584.
- 22. Goodman CS, Coughlin BC (2000) The evolution of evo-devo biology. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 97: 4424–4425.
- 23. Raff RA (2000) Evo-devo: the evolution of a new discipline. Nature Reviews Genetics 1: 74–79.
- 24. Brakefield PM (2003) The power of evo-devo to explore evolutionary constraints: experiments with butterfly eyespots1. Zoology 106: 283–290.
- 25. Hall BK (2003) Evo-Devo: evolutionary developmental mechanisms. The International journal of developmental biology 47: 491–495.
- 26. Hoekstra HE, Coyne JA (2007) The locus of evolution: evo devo and the genetics of adaptation. Evolution 61: 995–1016.
- 27. Carroll SB (2008) Evo-devo and an expanding evolutionary synthesis: a genetic theory of morphological evolution. Cell 134: 25–36.
- 28. Manning JT, Scutt D, Wilson J, Lewis-Jones DI (1998) The ratio of 2nd to 4th digit length: a predictor of sperm numbers and concentrations of testosterone, luteinizing hormone and oestrogen. Human reproduction 13: 3000–3004.
- 29. Brown WM, Hines M, Fane BA, Breedlove SM (2002) Masculinized Finger Length Patterns in Human Males and Females with Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia. Hormones and Behavior 42: 380–386.
- 30. Manning J, Callow M, Bundred P (2003) Finger and toe ratios in humans and mice: implications for the aetiology of diseases influenced by HOX genes. Medical Hypotheses 60: 340–343.
- 31. Leoni B, Canova L, Saino N (2005) Sexual dimorphism in metapodial and phalanges length ratios in the wood mouse. The anatomical record Part A, Discoveries in molecular, cellular, and evolutionary biology 286: 955–961.
- 32. Burley NT, Foster VS (2004) Digit ratio varies with sex, egg order and strength of mate preference in zebra finches. Proceedings of the Royal Society 271: 239–244.
- 33. Chang JL, Doughty SDS, Wade JWJ, Lovern MBLMB (2006) Sexual dimorphism in the second-to-fourth digit length ratio in green anoles, Anolis carolinensis (Squamata: Polychrotidae), from the southeastern United States. Canadian journal of zoology 84: 1489–1494.
- 34. Rubolini D, Pupin F, Sacchi R, Gentilli A, Zuffi MAL, et al. (2006) Sexual dimorphism in digit length ratios in two lizard species. The anatomical record Part A, Discoveries in molecular, cellular, and evolutionary biology 288: 491–497.
- 35. Buck JJ, Williams RM, Hughes IA, Acerini CL (2003) In-utero androgen exposure and 2nd to 4th digit length ratio:comparisons between healthy controls and females with classical congenital adrenal hyperplasia. Human Reproduction 18: 976–979.
- 36. Lutchmaya S, Baron-Cohen S, Raggatt P, Knickmeyer R, Manning JT (2004) 2nd To 4th Digit Ratios, Fetal Testosterone and Estradiol. Early human development 77: 23–28.
- 37. Romano M, Rubolini D, Martinelli R, Bonisoli Alquati A, Saino N (2005) Experimental manipulation of yolk testosterone affects digit length ratios in the ring-necked pheasant (Phasianus colchicus). Hormones and behavior 48: 342–346.
- 38. Malas MA, Dogan S, Evcil EH, Desdicioglu K (2006) Fetal development of the hand, digits and digit ratio (2D:4D). Early human development 82: 469–475.
- 39. Galis F, Ten Broek CMA, Van Dongen S, Wijnaendts LCD (2010) Sexual dimorphism in the prenatal digit ratio (2D:4D). Archives of sexual behavior 39: 57–62.
- 40. Mortlock D, Innis J, Post L (1996) The molecular basis of hypodactyly (Hd): a deletion in Hoxa13 leads to arrest of digital arch formation. Nature genetics 13: 284–289.
- 41. Kondo T, Zákány J, Innis JW, Duboule D (1997) Of fingers, toes and penises. Nature 390: 29.
- 42.
Manning J (2002) Digit ratio: A pointer to fertility, behavior, and health. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press. 175 p.
- 43. Saino N, Rubolini D, Romano M, Boncoraglio G (2007) Increased egg estradiol concentration feminizes digit ratios of male pheasants (Phasianus colchicus). Naturwissenschaften 94: 207–212.
- 44. Lovern MB, Wade J (2003) Yolk testosterone varies with sex in eggs of the lizard, Anolis carolinensis. Journal of experimental zoology Part A, Comparative experimental biology 295: 206–210.
- 45. Brown WM, Finn CJ, Breedlove SM (2002) Sexual dimorphism in digit-length ratios of laboratory mice. The Anatomical record 267: 231–234.
- 46. Manning JT, Baron-Cohen S, Wheelwright S, Sanders G (2001) The 2nd to 4th digit ratio and autism. Developmental medicine and child neurology 43: 160–164.
- 47. Manning JT, Fink B, Neave N, Szwed A (2006) The second to fourth digit ratio and asymmetry. Annals of human biology 33: 480–492.
- 48. McFadden D, Bracht MS (2005) Sex differences in the relative lengths of metacarpals and metatarsals in gorillas and chimpanzees. Hormones and behavior 47: 99–111.
- 49. Emerson SB, Diehl D (1980) Toe pad morphology and mechanisms of sticking in frogs. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 13: 199–216.
- 50. Carothers JH (1986) An experimental confirmation of morphological adaptation: toe fringes in the sand-dwelling lizard Uma scoparia. Evolution 40: 871–874.
- 51. Gebo D (1988) Foot morphology and locomotor adaptation in Eocene primates. Folia Primatologica 50: 3–41.
- 52. Emerson SB, Koehl M (1990) The interaction of behavioral and morphological change in the evolution of a novel locomotor type: “flying” frogs. Evolution 44: 1931–1946.
- 53. Zani PA (2000) The comparative evolution of lizard claw and toe morphology and clinging performance. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 13: 316–325.
- 54. Melville J, Swain R (2000) Evolutionary relationships between morphology, performance and habitat openness in the lizard genus Niveoscincus (Scincidae: Lygosominae). Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 70: 667–683.
- 55. Muray D, Larivière S (2002) The relationship between foot size of wild canids and regional snow conditions: evidence for selection against a high footload? Journal of Zoology 256: 289–299.
- 56. Carrano MT (1997) Morphological indicators of foot posture in mammals: a statistical and biomechanical analysis. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 121: 77–104.
- 57. Losos JB, Creer D A, Glossip D, Goellner R, Hampton A, et al. (2000) Evolutionary Implications of Phenotypic Plasticity in the Hindlimb of the Lizard Anolis sagrei. Evolution 54: 301–305.
- 58. Vanhooydonck B, Herrel A, Irschick DJ (2006) Out on a limb: The differential effect of substrate diameter on acceleration capacity in Anolis lizards. The Journal of experimental biology 209: 4515–4523.
- 59. Spezzano LC, Jayne B (2004) The effects of surface diameter and incline on the hindlimb kinematics of an arboreal lizard (Anolis sagrei). Journal of Experimental Biology 207: 2115–2131.
- 60. Jayne B, Irschick D (1999) Effects of incline and speed on the three-dimensional hindlimb kinematics of a generalized iguanian lizard (Dipsosaurus dorsalis). The Journal of experimental biology 202: 143–159.
- 61. Higham TE, Davenport MS, Jayne BC (2001) Maneuvering in an arboreal habitat: the effects of turning angle on the locomotion of three sympatric ecomorphs of Anolis lizards. The Journal of experimental biology 204: 4141–4155.
- 62. Zaaf A, Van Damme R (2001) Limb proportions in climbing and ground-dwelling geckos (Lepidosauria, Gekkonidae): a phylogenetically informed analysis. Zoomorphology 121: 45–53.
- 63. Toro E, Herrel A, Irschick D (2004) The evolution of jumping performance in Caribbean Anolis lizards: solutions to biomechanical trade-offs. The American naturalist 163: 844–856.
- 64. Kohlsdorf T, James R, Carvalho J, Wilson R, Pai-Silva M, et al. (2004) Locomotor performance of closely related Tropidurus species: relationships with physiological parameters and ecological divergence. Journal of Experimental Biology 207: 1183–1192.
- 65. Kohlsdorf T, Navas CA (2007) Evolution of jumping capacity in Tropidurinae lizards: does habitat complexity influence obstacle-crossing ability? Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 91: 393–402.
- 66. Losos J (1990) The evolution of form and function: morphology and locomotor performance in West Indian Anolis lizards. Evolution 44: 1189–1203.
- 67. Macrini T, Irschick D, Losos J (2003) Ecomorphological differences in toepad characteristics between mainland and island anoles. Journal of herpetology 37: 52–58.
- 68. Vanhooydonck B, Herrel A, Van Damme R, Irschick DJ (2006) The quick and the fast: the evolution of acceleration capacity in Anolis lizards. Evolution 60: 2137–2147.
- 69. Tulli MJ, Cruz FB, Herrel A, Vanhooydonck B, Abdala V (2009) The interplay between claw morphology and microhabitat use in neotropical iguanian lizards. Zoology 112: 379–392.
- 70. Colli GR, de Araújo AFB, da Silveira R, Roma F (1992) Niche partitioning and morphology of two syntopic Tropidurus (Sauria: Tropiduridae) in Mato Grosso, Brazil. Journal of Herpetology 26: 66–69.
- 71. Vitt LJ, Caldwell JP, Zani PA, Titus TA (1997) The role of habitat shift in the evolution of lizard morphology: evidence from tropical Tropidurus. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 94: 3828–3832.
- 72. Ribas SC, Velloso ALR, Teixeira-Filho P, Rocha-Barbosa O, Evangelista H, et al. (2004) Structure of claws and toes of two tropidurid lizard species of Restinga from Southeastern Brazil: adaptations to the vertical use of the habitat. Revista chilena de 77: 599–606.
- 73.
Pough F, Andrews R, Cadle J, Chump M, Savitzkim A, et al. (1998) Herpetology. New Jersey: Prentice- Hall Inc. 577 p.
- 74. Revell LJ (2009) Size-correction and principal components for interspecific comparative studies. Evolution 63: 3258–3268.
- 75. Corl A, Davis AR, Kuchta SR, Comendant T, Sinervo B (2010) Alternative mating strategies and the evolution of sexual size dimorphism in the side-blotched lizard, Uta stansburiana: a population-level comparative analysis. Evolution 64: 79–96.
- 76. Lavin SR, Karasov WH, Ives AR, Middleton KM, Garland T (2008) Morphometrics of the avian small intestine compared with that of nonflying mammals: a phylogenetic approach. Physiological and biochemical zoology 81: 526–550.
- 77.
Felsenstein J (2004) Inferring phylogenies from protein sequences by parsimony, distance, and likelihood methods. Massachusetts: Sinauer Associates. 644 p.
- 78. Storey JD (2002) A direct approach to false discovery rates. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B 64: 479–498.
- 79. Gartner GE A, Hicks JW, Manzani PR, Andrade DV, Abe AS, et al. (2010) Phylogeny, ecology, and heart position in snakes. Physiological and biochemical zoology 83: 43–54.
- 80. Conrad JL, Rieppel O, Grande L (2007) A Green River (Eocene) Polychrotid (Squamata: Reptilia) and a re-examination of iguanian systematics. Journal of Paleontology 81: 1365–1373.
- 81. Frost DR, Rodrigues MT, Grant T, Titus TA (2001) Phylogenetics of the lizard genus Tropidurus (Squamata: Tropiduridae: Tropidurinae): direct optimization, descriptive efficiency, and sensitivity analysis of congruence between molecular data and morphology. Molecular phylogenetics and evolution 21: 352–371.
- 82. Poe S (2004) Phylogeny of Anoles. Herpetological Monographs 18: 37–89.
- 83. Garland T, Bennett AF, Rezende EL (2005) Phylogenetic approaches in comparative physiology. The Journal of experimental biology 208: 3015–3035.
- 84. Wiens JJ, Hollingsworth BD (2000) War of the Iguanas: conflicting molecular and morphological phylogenies and long-branch attraction in iguanid lizards. Systematic biology 49: 143–159.
- 85. Vidal N, Hedges SB (2004) Molecular evidence for a terrestrial origin of snakes. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 271: S226–S229.
- 86. Grafen A (1989) The phylogenetic regression. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B, Biological Sciences 326: 119–157.
- 87. Pagel MD (1992) A method for the analysis of comparative data. Journal of Theoretical Biology 156: 431–442.
- 88. Purvis A (1995) A composite estimate of primate phylogeny. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B: Biological Sciences 348: 405–321.
- 89. Garland T, Dickerman a W, Janis CM, Jones JA (1993) Phylogenetic Analysis of Covariance by Computer Simulation. Systematic Biology 42: 265–292.
- 90. Garland T, Díaz-Uriarte R (1999) Polytomies and phylogenetically independent contrasts: examination of the bounded degrees of freedom approach. Systematic Biology 48: 547–558.
- 91. Garland T, Ives A (2000) Using the past to predict the present: confidence intervals for regression equations in phylogenetic comparative methods. The American Naturalist 155: 346–364.
- 92. Garland T, Harvey PH, Ives AR (1992) Procedures for the analysis of comparative data using phylogenetically independent contrasts. Systematic Biology 41: 18–32.
- 93. Van Sluys M (1992) Aspectos da ecologia do lagarto Tropidurus itambere (Tropiduridae) em uma área do sudeste do Brasil. Revista Brasileira de Zoologia 52: 181–185.
- 94. Vanzolini P, Gomes N (1979) On Tropidurus hygomi: redescription, ecological notes, distribution and history (Sauria, Iguanidae). Pap Avuls Zool 32: 243–259.
- 95.
Liou NS (2008) História natural de duas espécies simpátricas de Enyalius (Squamata, Leiosauridae) na Mata Atlântica do sudeste brasileiro. Universidade de São Paulo.
- 96. Lilley T, Laaksonen T, Huitu O, Helle S (2010) Maternal corticosterone but not testosterone level is associated with the ratio of second-to-fourth digit length (2D: 4D) in field vole offspring (Microtus agrestis). Physiology & behavior 99: 433–437.
- 97. Lovern MB, Wade J (2003) Sex steroids in green anoles (Anolis carolinensis): uncoupled maternal plasma and yolking follicle concentrations, potential embryonic steroidogenesis, and evolutionary implications. General and Comparative Endocrinology 134: 109–115.
- 98. Eising C, Müller W, Dijkstra C, Groothuis T (2003) Maternal androgens in egg yolks: relation with sex, incubation time and embryonic growth. General and Comparative Endocrinology 132: 241–247.
- 99. Forstmeier W (2005) Quantitative genetics and behavioural correlates of digit ratio in the zebra finch. Proceedings of the Royal Society 272: 2641–2649.
- 100. Tickle C, Eichele G (1994) Vertebrate limb development. Annual review of cell biology 10: 121–152.
- 101. Bininda-Emonds ORP, Jeffery JE, Sánchez-Villagra MR, Hanken J, Colbert M, et al. (2007) Forelimb-hindlimb developmental timing changes across tetrapod phylogeny. BMC evolutionary biology 7: 182.
- 102. Hornbruch A, Wolpert L (1991) The spatial and temporal distribution of polarizing activity in the flank of the pre-limb-bud stages in the chick embryo. Development 111: 725–731.
- 103. Higham TE, Jayne BC (2004) Locomotion of lizards on inclines and perches: hindlimb kinematics of an arboreal specialist and a terrestrial generalist. Journal of experimental biology 207: 233–248.
- 104. Peters M, Mackenzie K, Bryden P (2002) Finger length and distal finger extent patterns in humans. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 117: 209–217.
- 105. Peterson J (1984) The locomotion of Chamaleo (Reptilia: Sauria) with particular reference to the forelimb. Journal of Zoology 202: 1–42.