5 Jun 2009: (2009) Correction: Systematic NMR Analysis of Stable Isotope Labeled Metabolite Mixtures in Plant and Animal Systems: Coarse Grained Views of Metabolic Pathways. PLoS ONE 4(6): 10.1371/annotation/b9b4135b-d76f-4990-b5e4-a70d85acf8e6. doi: 10.1371/annotation/b9b4135b-d76f-4990-b5e4-a70d85acf8e6 | View correction
16 Apr 2009: (2009) Correction: Systematic NMR Analysis of Stable Isotope Labeled Metabolite Mixtures in Plant and Animal Systems: Coarse Grained Views of Metabolic Pathways. PLoS ONE 4(4): 10.1371/annotation/55efe5d9-ca11-4f68-ac03-49a31d803161. doi: 10.1371/annotation/55efe5d9-ca11-4f68-ac03-49a31d803161 | View correction
Metabolic phenotyping has become an important ‘bird's-eye-view’ technology which can be applied to higher organisms, such as model plant and animal systems in the post-genomics and proteomics era. Although genotyping technology has expanded greatly over the past decade, metabolic phenotyping has languished due to the difficulty of ‘top-down’ chemical analyses. Here, we describe a systematic NMR methodology for stable isotope-labeling and analysis of metabolite mixtures in plant and animal systems.
The analysis method includes a stable isotope labeling technique for use in living organisms; a systematic method for simultaneously identifying a large number of metabolites by using a newly developed HSQC-based metabolite chemical shift database combined with heteronuclear multidimensional NMR spectroscopy; Principal Components Analysis; and a visualization method using a coarse-grained overview of the metabolic system. The database contains more than 1000 1H and 13C chemical shifts corresponding to 142 metabolites measured under identical physicochemical conditions. Using the stable isotope labeling technique in Arabidopsis T87 cultured cells and Bombyx mori, we systematically detected >450 HSQC peaks in each 13C-HSQC spectrum derived from model plant, Arabidopsis T87 cultured cells and the invertebrate animal model Bombyx mori. Furthermore, for the first time, efficient 13C labeling has allowed reliable signal assignment using analytical separation techniques such as 3D HCCH-COSY spectra in higher organism extracts.
Overall physiological changes could be detected and categorized in relation to a critical developmental phase change in B. mori by coarse-grained representations in which the organization of metabolic pathways related to a specific developmental phase was visualized on the basis of constituent changes of 56 identified metabolites. Based on the observed intensities of 13C atoms of given metabolites on development-dependent changes in the 56 identified 13C-HSQC signals, we have determined the changes in metabolic networks that are associated with energy and nitrogen metabolism.
Citation: Chikayama E, Suto M, Nishihara T, Shinozaki K, Hirayama T, et al. (2008) Systematic NMR Analysis of Stable Isotope Labeled Metabolite Mixtures in Plant and Animal Systems: Coarse Grained Views of Metabolic Pathways. PLoS ONE 3(11): e3805. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0003805
Editor: Lucia Banci, University of Florence, Italy
Received: May 1, 2008; Accepted: October 21, 2008; Published: November 25, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 Chikayama et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: J.K. and T.H. were supported in part by grants from RIKEN (the President's Special Research Grant), the Japan Science and Technology Agency (CREST to J.K.), Bio-oriented Technology Advancement Institution (BRAIN to J.K.) and the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology of Japan (No. 17710191 to J.K.).
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The tremendous advances in DNA sequencing technologies that have taken place over the last few years have made large-scale sequencing and genome comparison studies accessible for many applications. For example, the cost of human genotype characterization is now about $1000 per genome . These technologies have also made comparative metagenomic analyses of complex microbial communities sampled from diverse environments possible . However, methods are still needed to tie function to sequence, a step that is necessary to efficiently identify proteins that might serve as drug targets , or enzymatic activities that could be used to produce valuable products such as biofuels or other biomaterials . Because cellular metabolic contents or byproducts are good indicators of both genetic and environmental factors, metabolic phenotyping has found a place in the post-genomics and proteomics era , . Therefore, technological developments in both nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and mass spectrometry (MS) have provided key insights into metabolic phenotypes over the last half decade , . Versatile sampling and robust 1H-NMR methods have improved disease diagnosis – and personalized healthcare –, and have provided an important tool for the characterization of genetic variations . The use of high-resolution magic angle spinning methods has had an especially beneficial effect on measurements in intact tissues and in whole organisms –.
The introduction of stable isotope (SI) labeling techniques  has turned out to be an essential development for NMR analyses of metabolism. SI labeling-based metabolic analyses have been widely used in bacterial systems , and in higher plants and animals , . Metabolic flux analysis is a powerful method for following an incorporated 13C, or 2H nucleus through specific metabolic pathways in mammalian systems –. Furthermore, recent increases in the sensitivity of NMR detection with a dynamic nuclear polarization technique combined with in vivo 13C labeling have allowed metabolic imaging assays to be completed on a much faster time scale and with finer spatial resolution , .
Although these methodological advances have widely contributed to metabolic analyses in plant and animal systems, a key component of the overall technology is the accurate identification of metabolites in unpurified samples, including in vivo measurements. Using comprehensive SI labeling of metabolites in plants, we have recently shown that heteronuclear single quantum coherence (HSQC)–based 2D-NMR  enables higher resolution and sensitivity than classical 1D-NMR–based approaches –. The use of comprehensive SI labeling results in better signal-to-noise ratios for metabolites present in low concentrations, and makes 13C–13C through-bond connectivity experiments possible (i.e. HCACO) . Another strategy for identifying metabolite signals in crude biological mixtures involves the use of a standardized chemical shift metabolomics database , . This sort of database can only be reliably used if the quality of the datasets is assured by eliminating chemical shift data that have not been generated in a standard buffer and at a constant temperature. For example, the chemical shift data in conventional public  or commercial databases are inadequate for NMR-based metabolome studies because they were compiled with the main goal being to collect information on the largest possible number of compounds, but were measured under different solvent, temperature, pH, and ionic strength conditions, resulting in the potential for significant identification errors. The use of SI-labeled metabolites and an HSQC-based chemical shift database would allow the comprehensive detection of large numbers of metabolites in a metabolic network study.
SI-based metabolic flux analyses have been used to identify metabolic networks at the atomic level –. However, this ‘bottom-up’ approach  could be complemented by the analysis of macroscopic systems such as biological fluids, cells, or even tissues. This sort of ‘top-down’ metabolite analysis, or metabolic phenotyping, currently employs Principal Components Analysis (PCA) or its variations. As a result, complicated metabolic systems can be visualized by ‘birds-eye-view’ technology with quantitative multivariate calculation, whereas previous “bottom-up” approaches employ a focused, microscopic view of specific reactions and molecules. These “top-down” methods, and presumably others in various stages of development, can and will be employed in higher systems-level approaches. For example, invertebrate models are versatile systems which can be used for chemical phenotyping applications, such as drug discovery . Compared with bacterial or animal cell-line assays, invertebrate-based or fish-based assays can be used to identify physiological changes at the tissue or organ level, and can be used for large-scale metabolic screening of bioactive compounds ,  to provide a coarse-grained view of complicated biological networks –.
In this report, the concept of systematic NMR analysis of stable isotope-labeled metabolite mixtures is described and tested. Our concept consists of SI labeling of living plants and animals, and systematic metabolite identification using an HSQC-based metabolite chemical shift database combined with 2D and 3D NMR. We applied these methods to the metabolic analysis of two higher organisms whose genomes have been sequenced, Arabidopsis T87 cultured cells, and the model invertebrate, Bombyx mori (silkworm) larvae , , both of which have been used for studying physiological responses to pathogens and for screening potential human drugs by observing their phenotypes . An additional goal was to devise a visual representation of silkworm metabolic organization during a major developmental transformation by analyzing changes in 13C intensities of metabolites in a pathway. A time-series NMR analysis of 13C-labeled metabolites was used to represent metabolic changes as a coarse-grained view of KEGG reference metabolic pathways .
HSQC-based metabolite chemical shift database
An HSQC-based metabolite chemical shift database was compiled that contains only NMR spectra of standard compounds measured under standardized temperature, pH, solvent, and ionic strength conditions. The database thus contains only highly reproducible chemical shifts, which makes it a reliable source for identifying metabolic products. Currently it consists of 1018 1H and 13C chemical shifts corresponding to 142 metabolites. Each chemical shift was derived from an NMR spectrum for one or a few metabolites measured at 298 K and dissolved in 100 mM potassium phosphate buffer at pH 7.0. Chemical shifts were distributed from 0.6 to 9.4 ppm for 1H and from 10.4 to 155.7 ppm for 13C (Fig. 1a). The average number of 13C-HSQC peaks per metabolite was 7.2. A linear regression of all 1018 peaks indicated that a 13C chemical shift = 17.5×1H chemical shift – 2.5 (r2 = 0.892). The 1H and 13C chemical shifts were around 2 and 40 ppm in lipids, 3.5 and 70 ppm in sugars, and 7 and 130 ppm in aromatic compounds, respectively. There were dense and sparse regions along the regression line, with an especially dense region near 3.5 ppm of the 1H shift, due mostly to sugars. On average, however, 58% of the 13C-HSQC-derived chemical shifts per metabolite did not overlap with any other metabolites in the database if the tolerances for overlapping were set at 0.03 and 0.3 ppm for 1H and 13C chemical shifts, respectively. As a result, 130 (92%) of 142 metabolites included one or more chemical shift markers, which we defined as chemical shifts that did not overlap with any other metabolites in the database.
Figure 1. HSQC-based metabolite chemical shift database.
(a) 1018 HSQC peaks derived from 142 metabolites compiled in the database are displayed as sugars (blue), nucleic acids (pink), metabolites having aromatic rings (green), organic acids (orange), lipids (red), and other metabolites (black). (b) The robustness of the database was tested statistically in terms of both 1H and 13C (upper right) chemical shifts (Δ1H and Δ13C, respectively). Chemical shift fluctuations of reference compounds (16 proteinogenic amino acids, glucose, succinate, and fumarate) with T87 crude extracts (red, 539 chemical shifts) were small enough to be used as representative chemical shifts for comparison with database records. Chemical shifts of reference compounds without added extracts are shown in gray (553 chemical shifts). In contrast, the chemical shifts of reference compounds at different pHs (blue, 525 chemical shifts) fluctuated over a wider range (compare blue and gray bars). A chemical shift fluctuation was defined as the difference from the average of the chemical shifts without added extracts.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0003805.g001
The robustness of the HSQC-based metabolite chemical shift database was tested with actual biological extracts. Standard reference compounds were dissolved in the standardized buffer with and without added crude Arabidopsis T87 cell extracts and the chemical shifts of the two solutions were compared. Sixteen proteinogenic amino acids (16AA, excluding asparagine, glutamine, cysteine, and tryptophan) along with succinate, fumarate, and glucose were used as reference compounds. The distribution of chemical shift fluctuations (n = 7, corresponding to more than 500 chemical shifts) in the solution with T87 extracts were all within 0.03 ppm for both 1H and 13C (Fig. 1b, red), which is comparable to the experimental resolution (0.01 and 0.5 ppm for 1H and 13C, respectively).
None of the samples fluctuated in pH (average 7.2; standard deviation<0.1). Reference compound chemical shift fluctuations in standardized buffer (pH 7) and in buffers from pH 3 to pH 9 were used as controls (Fig. 1b). There was a broad distribution of chemical shift fluctuations in buffer solutions with a pH 3 to 7, though 83.1% were still within 0.03 ppm. For example, the chemical shifts of phenylalanine Cβ, arginine Cδ, and proline Cδ showed little pH dependence, but glycine Cα and histidine Cβ shifts were relatively pH-dependent (Fig. S1).
Systematic batch identification of metabolites
An SI-labeling technique, the HSQC-based metabolite chemical shift database, and heteronuclear multidimensional NMR spectroscopy were combined in a systematic method for simultaneously identifying a large number of metabolites. 13C-HSQC spectra of crude silkworm and T87 cell extracts were analyzed with an in-house program that consults the database and compares 13C-HSQC spectra with the data. A large number of metabolites were identified in a single batch experiment (Fig. 2). However, although this system can only be used to identify candidate metabolites by matching observed chemical shifts with those in the database, it is capable of high-throughput, which makes large-scale approaches possible. In the silkworm extract, 453 peaks appeared in the 13C-HSQC spectrum (Fig. 2a). 174 of them had candidate matches in the database, corresponding to 95 metabolites, and 119 of the 174 peaks, corresponding to 57 metabolites, had a unique candidate match. The most abundant identified metabolite by peak intensities was lysine, which is a hub metabolite . Other abundant metabolites were the hub metabolite glycine, and glutamine. Further analysis using 3D HCCH-COSY  (data not shown) also detected cross peaks corresponding to trehalose, glucose, lysine, glutamine, alanine, proline, threonine, leucine, ornithine, and 4-hydroxy proline. The 57 uniquely identified metabolites are related to 81 metabolic pathways, according to the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) database . There were 544 13C-HSQC spectrum peaks in the T87 cultured cell extract, of which 192 correspond to 108 metabolites; and 124 of the 192 peaks, corresponding to 61 metabolites, were uniquely identified in the database (Fig. 2b). These 61 metabolites are related to 73 metabolic pathways. The most abundant identified metabolite was choline, and other abundant metabolites were d-gluconic lactone, glycerol, gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), lysine, uridine, and glucose. Lysine and glucose were abundant in both silkworm and T87 extracts, whereas other metabolites were abundant in one or the other but not both. Peak intensities ranged from 1 to 10−3 or 10−4 in both silkworm and T87 cells, and we observed a power-law relationship between the number of peaks and peak intensities –; that is, the majority of metabolites were present in lower concentrations, whereas a minority of metabolites were at higher concentrations (Fig. S2).
Figure 2. Metabolite identification using the HSQC-based metabolite chemical shift database.
(a) A total of 453 peaks were detected in the B. mori HSQC spectrum, of which 174 had candidate matches in the database (red), and 119 were uniquely identified (no more than one candidate match, numbered in red; see Table S1 for the metabolite names), and 279 had no candidate matches (black). The spectrum was acquired with 2048 points per 16 ppm of 1H, 32 transients per free induction decay, and 160 increments per 40 ppm of 13C. (b) A total of 544 peaks were detected in extracts from T87 cultured cells, of which 192 had candidate matches in the database (red) and 124 were uniquely identified (numbered in red; see Table S1), and 352 had no candidate matches (black). The spectrum was acquired with 1024 points per 16 ppm of 1H, 32 transients per free induction decay, and 200 increments per 40 ppm of 13C.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0003805.g002
Assignments in which the chemical shift matched more than one candidate metabolite in the database could be refined or avoided by using 3D HCCH-COSY spectra, a 3D heteronuclear NMR experiment in which another dimension is added to 2D (Fig. 3). Four 1H–1H planes cut the 3D 1H–1H–13C spectrum of the T87 extract sample at various points along the 13C axis, which allows the identification of 1H–13C–13C–1H bonds, thus confirming 13C-HSQC assignments by using 1H–13C–13C–1H information to connect two 1H–13C HSQC peaks (Fig. 2b). For the first time then, efficient 13C labeling provides reliable signal assignment from 3D HCCH-type spectra in higher organism extracts. A number of cross peaks were thus be identified which correspond to 89 HSQC peaks and 24 metabolites. For example, GABA, asparagine, glucose, uridine, lactate, malate, choline, and ribose could be used to verify the identification, thus resulting in a high degree of accuracy (Table S2).
Figure 3. 3D HCCH-COSY spectrum.
A heteronuclear 3D NMR spectrum of crude 13C-labeled T87 cultured cell extracts. 2D 1H–1H planes at 57.702, 62.702, 72.077, and 77.701 ppm of 13C cut through the 3D HCCH-COSY spectrum are shown (for each spectrum, the relative position of each cut is shown in a 3D box at the upper left corner). Red lines connect detected cross peaks of the named metabolites. In total, 89 HSQC peaks corresponding to 24 metabolites were confirmed. The spectrum was acquired with 1024 points per 14 ppm in the 1H direct dimension, accumulating 16 transients per free induction decay, 100 increments per 40 ppm in the 13C dimension, and 48 increments per 8 ppm in the indirect 1H dimension.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0003805.g003
Pilot application: coarse-grained views of overall physiological changes in silkworms fed with 13C-labeled nutrient
A pilot 13C labeling experiment was conducted to test whether our method could be used to visualize the metabolic state of a model invertebrate. B. mori larvae were fed an SI-labeled diet containing [13C6]glucose and [13C,15N]amino acids for 12 days, a time which corresponds to the larval developmental course that extends from the fourth instar through ecdysis into the fifth instar. Extracts were sampled on days 2, 6, 7, 10, and 12. Duplicate 13C-HSQC spectra were recorded on each of the five sampling days to detect and identify metabolites. Peak intensities in each spectrum gradually increased throughout the experiment, demonstrating that 13C atoms accumulated in the larval bodies (Fig. 4a). There were in all 56 different candidate metabolite matches that could be used to follow metabolic changes (Table S3). Of the 56 candidate metabolites, 71% were also found in the silkworm batch experiment (compare Tables S1 and S3). The total peak intensities of all 56 candidate metabolites in relation to sampling days (Fig. S3) were converted to a 56×56 (metabolite–metabolite) correlation matrix (Fig. 4b). The matrix was analyzed by principal components analysis (PCA) and PC loadings were determined (Fig. 4c for PC1). The matrix showed clear positive and negative correlations in peak intensities among the 56 metabolites. For example, l-ornithine (Fig. 4b, first row) was positively correlated with asparagine (second row) but negatively correlated with 3-phosphoglycerate (last row). These correlations were interpreted as indicators of physiological changes that accompany the developmental progress of silkworm larvae. On the basis of the first two principal components (PC1 and PC2), larval growth was divided into three phases: the fourth instar (days 2 and 6), just after ecdysis (day 7), and the fifth instar (days 10 and 12, Fig. 5a). The contribution ratios were 31.0% by PC1 and 25.4% by PC2. We selected the PC1 as the better indicator of metabolic change from day 7 to day 12. Since PC1 loadings (Fig. 4c) correspond to the metabolic change, all 132 KEGG reference metabolic pathways were mapped to obtain a coarse-grained view of the metabolic system of a silkworm at each of three sampling stages (Fig. 5b–d). Each pathway could then be assigned a defined total loading and a total intensity. Total loading was defined as the sum of the loadings on PC1 of the detected metabolites included in a pathway. Similarly, total intensity was defined as the sum of the standardized intensities of the detected metabolites in a pathway (see Fig. S3 for intensities before standardization). Total loadings and total intensities can be represented as colors and positions, respectively, so the same pathway retains the same color throughout the time course. Positions were determined with a simulated annealing technique by optimizing pathways that had large total intensities toward the center and those having small total or null intensities away from the center (Fig. 5b–d). By comparing the patterns in color and position, we found that the positions of the pathways were differently laid out at each sampling stage. The coarse-grained pattern of metabolic pathways at day 2 (Fig. 5b) appears to be random because it was not highly correlated with metabolic changes along the PC1 axis. In contrast, days 7 and 12 show clear patterns, indicating the emergence of organization among the labeled metabolic pathways (Fig. 5c and d). Pathways that were negatively correlated with the PC1 axis (cyan) crowded the center of the figure at day 7 (Fig. 5c), but migrated away from the center by day 12 (Fig. 5d). Similarly, pathways that were positively correlated with the PC1 axis (yellow) were peripheral at day 7 (Fig. 5c), but crowded the center by day 12 (Fig. 5d). This observation offers a coarse-grained view of metabolic changes taking place along the PC1 axis, and suggests that the roles of some pathways interchange along the PC1 axis during larval development. The pathways in the KEGG database with the most positive and most negative total loadings were glutamate metabolism (contributed from GABA, glutamate, malate, oxalacetate, fumarate) and glycolysis/gluconeogenesis (contributed from 3-phosphoglycerate, lactate, and pyruvate), respectively (see Table S4). From the point of view of PC1 metabolite loadings, pathways could be classified into two categories: those including detected metabolites of mostly positive PC1 loadings (yellow) and those of mostly negative ones (cyan). Furthermore, contributions from positive and negative loadings in the same pathway appear as gradations of green (see Text S1 for specific methods used to make these calculations). Observed 13C intensities for metabolites in a given pathway can thus be viewed averagely as yellow for almost metabolites increasing in terms of 13C, cyan for almost decreasing ones, and greenish intermediate colors (i.e. combinations of yellow and cyan) for combinations of increasing and decreasing ones. These coarse-grained representations allow visualization of the emergence of organization among cooperating pathways starting around day 7 and reversed by day 12. Conversely, there was little evidence for pathway organization at day 2. Related pathways could be expected to have correlated changes during development or other coordinated metabolic changes. For example, glutamate metabolism, the urea cycle, and metabolism of amino groups, which have positive total loadings, are possibly correlated. Similarly, glycolysis/ gluconeogenesis and cysteine metabolism, which have negative total loadings, should also be correlated (Table S4).
Figure 4. 13C labeling of B. mori larvae as a pilot application in an invertebrate animal model.
(a) Fourth instar silkworm larvae were reared on 13C-labeled diets for 12 days through ecdysis to the fifth instar stage, resulting in the gradual assimilation of 13C-labeled metabolites. Two bars per sample stage are shown. (b) Correlation matrix of 56 commonly selected metabolites used for the analysis of metabolites detected during the 12 days of the feeding experiment. Positively correlated metabolites are in red and negatively correlated metabolites are in blue. The metabolites are sorted by their loadings on PC1. (c) Loadings of the metabolites on the PC1 axis.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0003805.g004
Figure 5. Coarse-grained views of metabolic pathways computed from 13C-labeled B. mori during the developmental changes associated with fourth to fifth instars.
(a) PCA score plot. The sample stages were classified into fourth instar (days 2 and 6); post ecdysis (day 7); and fifth instar (days 10 and 12). Note that incorporated nutrients are stored toward metamorphosis after the fifth instar stage. (b–d) Coarse-grained representations of silkworm metabolic pathways. The loadings on PC1 of the 56 metabolites were mapped onto all 132 KEGG metabolic pathways as total loadings and the positions of the pathways in a plane were calculated by a simulated annealing technique with total intensities. Total loadings are represented by yellow, cyan, or their intermediates, by linearly superimposing colors corresponding to the loadings of metabolites included in each pathway. Yellow (or cyan) pathways have mostly positive (or negative) metabolites in loading on PC1, and green pathways result from the linear mixture of yellow and cyan. Gray pathways contained no identified metabolites. The simulated annealing technique used the total intensities at each sampling stage rather than total loadings, which optimized the locations of pathways with larger (or smaller) total intensities toward the center (outside). Movement of the metabolic state from negative to positive on the PC1 axis, caused a coincident movement of yellow (cyan) pathways, reflecting actively accumulating (dispersing) 13C atoms. The plot may include implicit coarse-grained information about the metabolic system that includes higher-dimensional correlations, or organization, among metabolic pathways.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0003805.g005
Our method of systematic metabolite identification using an HSQC-based metabolite chemical shift database is practical. Because of the tremendous number of both primary and secondary metabolites in nature, a highly efficient strategy for accumulating chemical shift data for many biological compounds is required for high-throughput NMR-based metabolic analyses. The HSQC-based database is a fast and cost-effective way of accumulating information about a huge number of standard compounds, although further specific analyses of NMR-based atomic assignments using NMR spectra obtained by additional methods such as COSY or total correlation spectroscopy (TOCSY) are required. The requirement that HSQC spectra be measured in a standardized buffer under physicochemically constant conditions is critical for minimizing identification errors. In general, crude extracts contain a mixed bag of biological molecules such as metabolites, ions, and biopolymers. Although these compounds have the potential to cause unpredictable fluctuations in the chemical shifts of metabolites, all of the reference compounds dissolved in standard buffer with crude T87 extracts had fluctuations within 0.03 ppm for both 1H and 13C (Fig. 1b, red). This suggests that identifying metabolites in (ideally dilute) crude extracts by using only standardized representative chemical shifts is generally practical for most metabolites, although the chemical shifts of some metabolites tend to fluctuate slightly. Citrate, which has been discussed elsewhere , is one such example (data not shown). In our experiment on pH dependence (Fig. 1b, blue), more than 80% of fluctuations were small, also indicating that metabolite identification with our method is reasonable for in vivo NMR experiments.
Our HSQC-based detection method (Fig. 2) offers more reliable metabolite identification than detection based simply on 1H 1D NMR spectra, which are frequently used in NMR-based studies on drug toxicity and gene function . A previous report described a 1H-NMR-based method which was used to identify 53 metabolites, GC/MS was used to identify 40 metabolites, and LC-FT/MS was used to identify 17 . Recent reports using 1H-NMR-based methods indicate that somewhere between 40 to 60 metabolites can be identified –, but 1H-NMR-based methodology has its limits . The introduction of 13C nuclei offers more accurate metabolite identification, but does not necessarily increase the total number of identifiable compounds –. It is likely, however, that expansion in the contents of the database will improve this situation.
One apparent shortcoming of our method, however, is false positives, which might occur when the number of database records or user query peaks is very large. This is because there are more metabolites when the concentration of each is lower (Fig. S2 and related studies supporting these results –, ). A false positive is an observed peak that has been wrongly identified as belonging to a particular metabolite. One solution to this problem is to use defined chemical shift markers. For example, our database includes more than 90% of metabolites that had one or more internal chemical shift markers [i.e. those having tolerances of 0.03 (1H) and 0.3 ppm (13C)]. Even using tolerances of 0.1 (1H) and 1.8 ppm (13C), which are significantly larger than what is normally used, this calculation reaches 40%, suggesting that, by knowing which peaks are chemical shift markers, peaks can often be used to discriminate between metabolites, greatly helping to preclude false positives. This validation can be accomplished merely by knowing which peaks can be uniquely identified by our definition. Any increase in the content of the defined conditions database improves the reliability and utility of the chemical shift markers. Expanding the database thus increases both the range and accuracy of metabolite identification. We are currently developing a method for predicting candidate compounds from unknown chemical shifts in HSQC-spectra of biological extracts. New methodologies like this one, and empirical tests will likely contribute toward truly comprehensive metabolite identification, and thus overcome the problem of simultaneously identified metabolites.
In the case of molecules, or types of molecules with overlapping chemical shifts (e.g., sugars generally tend to overlap in the database), other techniques will be required. One possible solution is to combine data from our method with those of other 2D NMR experiments, which are used to identify compounds in complex mixtures , . Additionally, we demonstrated that the number of ambiguous assignments could be reduced by the introduction of a third dimension, that is, by using heteronuclear 3D NMR spectra (Fig. 3). HCCH-COSY spectrum analysis is a good example of the use SI labeling techniques in living organisms, since the natural abundance of 13C–13C bonds is very low (1/100×1/100 = 1/10000), making them impossible to detect without SI amendment. Currently, heteronuclear 3D or higher-dimensional NMR experiments are standard methods in protein NMR spectroscopy , and one point of emphasis in this current work was to test the feasibility of using heteronuclear 3D NMR spectroscopy in NMR-based metabolome analysis. In addition to the problem of false positives, there is a general lack of confidence in the reproducibility of correct metabolite identification in crude biological extracts. In fact, there were frequent fluctuations in the observations of metabolites from individual silkworm extracts (for example, compare Tables S1 and S3). Such fluctuations may be due to individual genetic differences, subtle heterogeneous growth or developmental conditions, or artifacts introduced during sample preparation. Another challenging problem associated with the use of NMR techniques in metabolome analysis is low sensitivity, but some possibilities for resolving these shortcomings have been proposed , .
Based on a new type of metabolomic analysis, we have presented a method for coarse-grained representation of changes in a metabolic network in developing silkworms (Fig. 5b–d), whereas classical SI-labeled metabolic studies are based on targeted analyses of specific metabolic pathways, such as glycolysis or gluconeogenesis. –. Recent metabolomics/metabonomics progress using unlabeled biological fluids – or intact tissues – has made an NMR approach a leading tool in the post-genomics and proteomics era , . A combination of SI-labeling with multidimensional NMR analysis opens a new avenue of metabolic phenotyping in higher organisms, and allows complicated metabolic networks to be visualized with ‘birds-eye-view’ graphics technology, whereas classical targeted approaches focus on specific molecules. We have proposed using a coarse-grained view of metabolic pathways as a method of metabolic phenotyping, in which the overall changes in organization among metabolic pathways can be appreciated. Historically, General System Theory (GST)  as expounded by Ludwig von Bertalanffy was an early attempt to understand the interactions between natural phenomena which tend to organize large numbers of independent components, like very large numbers of cells, tissues, organs and organ systems. Currently, many researchers are dedicating significant resources to systems biology approaches –, with the fundamental principals of GST as their foundation. A coarse-grained representation based on a top-down approach must contain information about organization of the system to shed light on biological changes or interactions. In another words, a complex system like a living organism is essentially dependent on higher-dimensional correlations (i.e. organization) among a large number of elements. Coarse-grained representations are widely used in various scientific disciplines , –, and in this work we have successfully discriminated the patterns of metabolic pathways associated with developmental stages in a model invertebrate.
For convenience, we supposed that PC1 reflected a specific phenomenon, possibly ecdysis, because there was a relatively large difference in PC1 scores before and just after ecdysis (Fig. 5a). However, starvation might be a better interpretation of PC1, because silkworms do not eat during ecdysis. Either way, the loading of a metabolite on PC1 was interpreted to reflect the correlation between the change of 13C intensities in the metabolite and ecdysis or its associated behaviors. The optimized relative positions of KEGG metabolic pathways based on the total intensities of metabolites within each pathway thus provides a relatively robust coarse-grained pattern of silkworm metabolic activity around ecdysis (Fig. 5b–d). The shift from ecdysis to fifth instar resulted in a reduction in 13C intensities in negatively correlated pathways (Fig. 5d, toward the perimeter, cyan), and in an increase in positively correlated pathways (Fig. 5d, in the center, yellow), suggesting that metabolic activities can be detected at the metabolic pathway level as well as at the metabolite level. Simultaneous identification of multiple metabolites, and information about their coexistence within a single pathway can provide clues about the relationship between development or environmental interactions, and the metabolic adjustments that accompany such events. Further, our coarse-grained view may offer information about correlated pathways.
The identified pathways could be classified into two categories and assigned colors, making changes in their activities relatively easy to follow during ecdysis (Fig. 5b–d). The color of a pathway is determined by the superimposition of the two weighted colors with green as the intermediate indicator of increasing or decreasing relative 13C intensities during ecdysis from day 7 to day 12. These two metabolic categories exhibited weak tendencies of energy and nitrogen metabolism in the insect hemolymph . Nitrogen is a major constituent of many major metabolites, such as L-ornithine, asparagine and GABA, which increased toward day 12 (yellow in Fig. 5b–d, see also Table S3). These metabolites, along with fumarate and glutamate, are synthesized and catabolized as part of the general urea cycle, and the metabolism of amino groups. Furthermore, GABA, glutamate, malate, oxalacetate, fumarate and glutamine relating to glutamate metabolism also exhibited similar tendencies. Nitrogen metabolism is the common thread between these structurally diverse compounds from assimilation to elimination . The metabolites belonging to metabolic pathways in positive total loadings of PC1, e.g. L-ornithine, asparagine, oxalacetic acid, or GABA, which had higher positive loadings, exhibted non-linear (V-shaped) time-dependence of signal intensities in which the intensities all went down at ecdysis (day 7) and up during the fifth instar stage (day 10–12). Related metabolic pathways tended to be organized toward the center rather than in the periphery at day 12 (Fig. 5d). A previous report also discussed the strong regulation of nitrogen metabolism (especially re-assimilation of ammonia) during the development of B. mori larvae . The silkworm is in a fasting state during metamorphosis (after day 12), so these key metabolites may be stockpiled in the hemolymph in anticipation of nutrient deprivation. On the other hand, 3-phosphoglycerate, acetate, lactate, serine, and pyruvate increased only at day 7, by which time ecdysis (starved state) would be finished. These metabolites are a part of the glycolysis/gluconeogenesis pathways and cysteine metabolism (blue in Fig. 5b–d). Since the insect can derive energy from the catabolism of lipids during its starvation periods , these metabolite levels might be increased at day 7. Incorporated 13C can be highly accumulated in lipid bodies (Nishihara, T., unpublished results). Overall, these physiological changes in silkworm growth were well-characterized by our method.
One of the limitations of applying this method to higher organisms is the ability to label with SI at high concentrations, especially in chemoheterotrophic organisms. However, our experience with SI labeling in a wide range of higher organisms, indicates that invertebrates, and insects in particular, tend to be easily labeled by incorporation of glucose and/or amino acids. Hence omnivores, such as rodents, might become important model organisms in metabolomics as well as in other meta-analytical fields for comparisons with humans. We have recently reported SI labeling in mouse intestine, resulting in the successful in vivo detection of the anti-bacterial metabolite reuterin .
Another limitation is that there is no direct evidence linking an identified metabolite with a unique pathway if the connection is limited to the methods reported here, because many metabolites are substrates or products of several pathways. Coincident detections of a metabolite in the same pathway, and correlation on the PC1 axis lend some support. Combining SI-labeling techniques can also support them. For example, 13C-labeled positions inside a molecule offer a hint about paths of molecular conversions.
Our graphic representation may not be adequate to serve as a quantitative tool for understanding these higher dimensional correlations, but the apparent coarse-grained patterns of increasing and decreasing 13C intensities in metabolites and pathways occurred coincidently throughout related metabolic pathways during the period from ecdysis to the fifth instar. This method can thus be used to screen physiological changes in organisms by using coarse-grained views of metabolic pathways in which it would be useful to have an overview of several specific metabolic states.
Chemicals and biological samples
SI-labeled compounds were purchased and fed to Bombyx mori fourth instar larvae (Ehimesansyu Co. Ltd., Ehime, Japan) or T87 Arabidopsis thaliana cells (RIKEN BioResource Center, Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan) to examine chemical shifts (see Text S1). T87 cells were incubated and subcultured every 7 days in 20 mL of JPL medium  supplemented with 0.5% (v/v) glucose in a 100-mL baffled Erlenmeyer flask on a rotary shaker at 100 rpm and 24°C under a 16-h light / 8-h dark cycle unless otherwise noted. Cells were labeled with [13C6]glucose as described elsewhere . B. mori larvae were grown on 1 g of a semi-synthetic diet medium (Katakura-kogyo Co. Ltd., Hachioji, Japan) supplemented with 200 µL of an aqueous solution containing 2% (w/w) [13C6]glucose and 1% (w/w) [13C,15N]amino acids (AA) at 26°C under a 10-h light/14-h dark cycle for 12 days. The hemolymph from SI-labeled silkworms was sampled on days 2, 6, 7, 10, and 12.
Standard buffer for NMR
Chemical shift reference buffer (100 mM, pH 7.0, 1.0 mM DSS) was made from 1 M aqueous potassium phosphate stock solutions (KH2PO4 and K2HPO4), and 2,2-dimethyl-2-silapentane-5-sulfonate (DSS) in deuterium oxide (D2O) water.
Non-labeled T87 cells were washed twice with water, lyophilized, and ground to powder. 5 mg of the powder was suspended in 600 µL of the standard buffer, heated to 50°C for 5 min, and centrifuged at 10000× g for 5 min. 500 µL of supernatant was decanted into a 5-mm ø NMR tube. 13C-labeled T87 extracts were prepared essentially as described elsewhere . 13C- and 15N-labeled silkworm hemolymph was extracted from one or a few silkworms by centrifugation of hemocytes at 4000× g for 5 min. 162 µL of each hemolymph sample was added to 18 µL of 1 M potassium phosphate buffer (10% D2O, 5 mM DSS), and then transferred to a 5-mm ø Shigemi NMR tube.
All HSQC  and 3D HCCH-COSY  spectra were acquired at 298 K on a Bruker AVANCE DRX 500 (AVANCE DRU 700) NMR spectrometer operating at 500.13 (700.15) MHz and equipped with an 1H inverse cryogenic probe with Z-axis gradients (see Text S1). Spectra were processed using the NMRPipe software package  with window functions, zero-fillings, linear predictions, and polynomial baseline corrections. 13C-HSQC peaks were identified by an automated algorithm embedded in the software and refined manually. Peak intensities were determined with peak heights.
Metabolite chemical shift database
Each purchased standard compound for compiling into the database was measured by NMR under standardized conditions. Chemical shift fluctuations with and without the addition of unlabeled T87 cell extracts from seven different cultures were examined. One of the extracts was from cells grown under a 24-h light (LL) cycle. The pH of samples was determined (model B-212 Horiba pH meter) and 13C-HSQC spectra were recorded in standard buffer only (control), standard buffer with non-labeled T87 extract, or in standard buffer with labeled T87 extract. Chemical shift fluctuations were defined as the differences in chemical shifts between labeled and control. The chemical shifts of labeled compounds were derived by comparing labeled and non-labeled spectra. Chemical shift fluctuations for succinate and fumarate in T87 extracts were examined by 13C-HSQC and identified by their chemical shift values and visual inspection. Chemical shift fluctuations due to very small differences in buffer preparation (artifacts) were determined by a comparison of control spectra using standardized buffers from different lots but having the same composition. The pH dependence of chemical shifts for 16AA, glucose, succinate, and fumarate was examined by 13C-HSQC at seven different pH values in citric acid–phosphate buffer at pH 3; acetate–sodium acetate or succinate buffer at pH 4 and 5; potassium phosphate buffers at pH 6 and 7; and sodium hydroxide–boric acid buffers at pH 8 and 9. Our chemical shift data are continuously updated and are available on the PRIMe website  (http://prime.psc.riken.jp/).
Systematic batch identification of metabolites
The metabolite chemical shift database was implemented with an in-house Java program which allows systematic batch identification of large numbers of metabolites by simply matching the queried observed 13C-HSQC peaks with peaks in the implemented metabolite chemical shift database. It also allows aliased chemical shifts. Each of the queried observed peaks was defined as identified or assigned when the chemical shift difference in each dimension between the observed peak and that of the database was less than some tolerance value. Typically, tolerances of 0.03 to 0.04 ppm for 1H and 0.3 to 0.4 ppm for 13C were used in this study. An identification or assignment was defined as unique if there was only one candidate in the database within the specified tolerances for an observed peak.
Coarse-grained views of metabolic networks
Sequential 13C-HSQC spectra for silkworms in a 13C-feeding experiment were obtained twice daily on five different days. The resulting 56 uniquely identified metabolites common throughout these ten spectra were converted to a 56×56 (metabolite–metabolite) correlation matrix in which an element of the matrix was defined as Pearson's coefficient of correlation between the representative intensity of a metabolite and that of any other metabolite (Fig. 4b). The representative intensity of a metabolite was defined as the ratio of the summation of the intensities of all of the 13C-HSQC peaks for a metabolite to that of DSS, and corresponds to the abundance of 13C atoms to the metabolite. Principal Components Analysis (PCA) was performed on the correlation matrix by Eigenvalue decomposition with Mathematica software (Wolfram Research), and the principal component scores and loadings on PC1 and PC2 were determined. Using a simulated annealing technique and 132 KEGG Markup Language files (KGML, version 0.6) obtained from KEGG  (http://www.genome.ad.jp/kegg/), we computed coarse-grained representations of metabolic pathways. The simulated annealing algorithm first allocated a total intensity value to each pathway, consisting of the summation of the representative intensities of the identified metabolites in the pathway. The color of a pathway was computed on the basis of total loadings on the PC1 of the pathway (see the Pilot Application section in the Results section). Next, all of the pathways were randomly scattered within the area of the figure, and Metropolis Monte Carlo simulations were sequentially performed by gradually cooling the temperature to calculate a coarse-grained representation of the metabolic pathways. The total energy of the system was defined in terms of the distance of each pathway from the center, overlapped areas between two pathways, and between a pathway and the periphery of the figure (see Text S1). The algorithm was designed to minimize overlaps between pathways and to place the pathways that have a larger (or smaller) total intensity toward the center (or outside) (see the Pilot Application section). Since a simulated annealing technique is a heuristic procedure, it was performed 3 times for each sampling stage, resulting in 15 coarse-grained views. Although similar views were obtained at each day stage, we selected one of the views by visual inspection in which the positions of the pathways were maintained according to their colors (Fig. 5b–d). Since this layout algorithm only includes general parameters such as the sizes of components or intensities, it does not include any specific parameters dependent on only KEGG database. However, the results can vary slightly if the definition of a metabolic pathway, or a component of a pathway, is slightly different from that used in our method.
(0.07 MB DOC)
(0.18 MB DOC)
(0.09 MB DOC)
(0.89 MB DOC)
(0.11 MB DOC)
(0.06 MB DOC)
(0.06 MB DOC)
(0.19 MB DOC)
The authors thank Yasuyo Sekiyama (RIKEN), Yuuri Tsuboi (RIKEN), Mami Okamoto, and Yumiko Nakanishi (Yokohama City University) for valuable discussion and technical assistance.
Conceived and designed the experiments: EC TN KS TH JK. Performed the experiments: MS TN JK. Analyzed the data: EC. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: EC. Wrote the paper: EC JK.
- 1. Service RF (2006) Gene sequencing. The race for the $1000 genome. Science 311: 1544–1546.
- 2. Schmeisser C, Steele H, Streit WR (2007) Metagenomics, biotechnology with non-culturable microbes. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 75: 955–962.
- 3. Cheng AC, Coleman RG, Smyth KT, Cao Q, Soulard P, et al. (2007) Structure-based maximal affinity model predicts small-molecule druggability. Nat Biotechnol 25: 71–75.
- 4. Ragauskas AJ, Williams CK, Davison BH, Britovsek G, Cairney J, et al. (2006) The path forward for biofuels and biomaterials. Science 311: 484–489.
- 5. Raamsdonk LM, Teusink B, Broadhurst D, Zhang N, Hayes A, et al. (2001) A functional genomics strategy that uses metabolome data to reveal the phenotype of silent mutations. Nat Biotechnol 19: 45–50.
- 6. Nicholson JK, Connelly J, Lindon JC, Holmes E (2002) Metabonomics: a platform for studying drug toxicity and gene function. Nature Reviews Drug Discovery 1: 153–161.
- 7. Fernie AR, Trethewey RN, Krotzky AJ, Willmitzer L (2004) Metabolite profiling: from diagnostics to systems biology. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 5: 763–769.
- 8. Lenz EM, Wilson ID (2007) Analytical strategies in metabonomics. J Proteome Res 6: 443–458.
- 9. Brindle JT, Antti H, Holmes E, Tranter G, Nicholson JK, et al. (2002) Rapid and noninvasive diagnosis of the presence and severity of coronary heart disease using 1H-NMR-based metabonomics. Nat Med 8: 1439–1444.
- 10. Dumas ME, Barton RH, Toye A, Cloarec O, Blancher C, et al. (2006) Metabolic profiling reveals a contribution of gut microbiota to fatty liver phenotype in insulin-resistant mice. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 12511–12516.
- 11. Huang JT, Leweke FM, Tsang TM, Koethe D, Kranaster L, et al. (2007) CSF metabolic and proteomic profiles in patients prodromal for psychosis. PLoS ONE 2: e756.
- 12. Fearnside JF, Dumas ME, Rothwell AR, Wilder SP, Cloarec O, et al. (2008) Phylometabonomic patterns of adaptation to high fat diet feeding in inbred mice. PLoS ONE 3: e1668.
- 13. Clayton TA, Lindon JC, Cloarec O, Antti H, Charuel C, et al. (2006) Pharmaco-metabonomic phenotyping and personalized drug treatment. Nature 440: 1073–1077.
- 14. Nicholson JK (2006) Global systems biology, personalized medicine and molecular epidemiology. Mol Syst Biol 2: 52.
- 15. Holmes E, Loo RL, Stamler J, Bictash M, Yap IK, et al. (2008) Human metabolic phenotype diversity and its association with diet and blood pressure. Nature 453: 396–400.
- 16. Dumas ME, Wilder SP, Bihoreau MT, Barton RH, Fearnside JF, et al. (2007) Direct quantitative trait locus mapping of mammalian metabolic phenotypes in diabetic and normoglycemic rat models. Nat Genet 39: 666–672.
- 17. Griffin JL, Shockcor JP (2004) Metabolic profiles of cancer cells. Nat Rev Cancer 4: 551–561.
- 18. Blaise BJ, Giacomotto J, Elena B, Dumas ME, Toulhoat P, et al. (2007) Metabotyping of Caenorhabditis elegans reveals latent phenotypes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 19808–19812.
- 19. Schirra HJ, Anderson CG, Wilson WJ, Kerr L, Craik DJ, et al. (2008) Altered metabolism of growth hormone receptor mutant mice: a combined NMR metabonomics and microarray study. PLoS ONE 3: e2764.
- 20. Lane AN, Fan TW, Higashi RM (2008) Isotopomer-based metabolomic analysis by NMR and mass spectrometry. Methods Cell Biol 84: 541–588.
- 21. Sauer U (2006) Metabolic networks in motion: 13C-based flux analysis. Mol Syst Biol 2: 62.
- 22. Ratcliffe RG, Shachar-Hill Y (2006) Measuring multiple fluxes through plant metabolic networks. Plant J 45: 490–511.
- 23. de Graaf RA, Mason GF, Patel AB, Rothman DL, Behar KL (2004) Regional glucose metabolism and glutamatergic neurotransmission in rat brain in vivo. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 12700–12705.
- 24. Jue T, Rothman DL, Shulman GI, Tavitian BA, DeFronzo RA, et al. (1989) Direct observation of glycogen synthesis in human muscle with 13C NMR. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 86: 4489–4491.
- 25. Kalderon B, Korman SH, Gutman A, Lapidot A (1989) Estimation of glucose carbon recycling in children with glycogen storage disease: A 13C NMR study using [U-13C]glucose. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 86: 4690–4694.
- 26. Rothman DL, Magnusson I, Katz LD, Shulman RG, Shulman GI (1991) Quantitation of hepatic glycogenolysis and gluconeogenesis in fasting humans with 13C NMR. Science 254: 573–576.
- 27. Merritt ME, Harrison C, Storey C, Jeffrey FM, Sherry AD, et al. (2007) Hyperpolarized 13C allows a direct measure of flux through a single enzyme-catalyzed step by NMR. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 19773–19777.
- 28. Golman K, in 't Zandt R, Thaning M (2006) Real-time metabolic imaging. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 11270–11275.
- 29. Bodenhausen G, Ruben DJ (1980) Natural Abundance N-15 Nmr by Enhanced Heteronuclear Spectroscopy. Chemical Physics Letters 69: 185–189.
- 30. Kikuchi J, Shinozaki K, Hirayama T (2004) Stable isotope labeling of Arabidopsis thaliana for an NMR-based metabolomics approach. Plant Cell Physiol 45: 1099–1104.
- 31. Kikuchi J, Hirayama T (2007) Practical aspects of uniform stable isotope labeling of higher plants for heteronuclear NMR-based metabolomics. Methods Mol Biol 358: 273–286.
- 32. Sekiyama Y, Kikuchi J (2007) Towards dynamic metabolic network measurements by multi-dimensional NMR-based fluxomics. Phytochemistry 68: 2320–2329.
- 33. Ikura M, Kay LE, Bax A (1990) A novel approach for sequential assignment of 1H, 13C, and 15N spectra of proteins: heteronuclear triple-resonance three-dimensional NMR spectroscopy. Application to calmodulin. Biochemistry 29: 4659–4667.
- 34. Wishart DS, Tzur D, Knox C, Eisner R, Guo AC, et al. (2007) HMDB: the Human Metabolome Database. Nucleic Acids Res 35: D521–526.
- 35. Cui Q, Lewis IA, Hegeman AD, Anderson ME, Li J, et al. (2008) Metabolite identification via the Madison Metabolomics Consortium Database. Nat Biotechnol 26: 162–164.
- 36. Steinbeck C, Kuhn S (2004) NMRShiftDB – compound identification and structure elucidation support through a free community-built web database. Phytochemistry 65: 2711–2717.
- 37. Oliver SG (2006) From genomes to systems: the path with yeast. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 361: 477–482.
- 38. Segalat L (2007) Invertebrate animal models of diseases as screening tools in drug discovery. ACS Chem Biol 2: 231–236.
- 39. Bhavsar AP, Brown ED (2006) The worm turns for antimicrobial discovery. Nat Biotechnol 24: 1098–1100.
- 40. Lieschke GJ, Currie PD (2007) Animal models of human disease: zebrafish swim into view. Nat Rev Genet 8: 353–367.
- 41. Novak BA, Jain AN (2006) Pathway recognition and augmentation by computational analysis of microarray expression data. Bioinformatics 22: 233–241.
- 42. Tadmor AD, Tlusty T (2008) A coarse-grained biophysical model of E. coli and its application to perturbation of the rRNA operon copy number. PLoS Comput Biol 4: e1000038.
- 43. Ma W, Lai L, Ouyang Q, Tang C (2006) Robustness and modular design of the Drosophila segment polarity network. Mol Syst Biol 2: 70.
- 44. Arabidopsis Genome Initiative (2000) Analysis of the genome sequence of the flowering plant Arabidopsis thaliana. Nature 408: 796–815.
- 45. Mita K, Kasahara M, Sasaki S, Nagayasu Y, Yamada T, et al. (2004) The genome sequence of silkworm, Bombyx mori. DNA Res 11: 27–35.
- 46. Orihara Y, Hamamoto H, Kasuga H, Shimada T, Kawaguchi Y, et al. (2008) A silkworm baculovirus model for assessing the therapeutic effects of antiviral compounds: characterization and application to the isolation of antivirals from traditional medicines. J Gen Virol 89: 188–194.
- 47. Kanehisa M, Goto S, Hattori M, Aoki-Kinoshita KF, Itoh M, et al. (2006) From genomics to chemical genomics: new developments in KEGG. Nucleic Acids Res 34: D354–357.
- 48. Jeong H, Tombor B, Albert R, Oltvai ZN, Barabasi AL (2000) The large-scale organization of metabolic networks. Nature 407: 651–654.
- 49. Kay LE, Ikura M, Bax A (1990) Proton Proton Correlation Via Carbon Carbon Couplings - a 3-Dimensional Nmr Approach for the Assignment of Aliphatic Resonances in Proteins Labeled with C-13. Journal of the American Chemical Society 112: 888–889.
- 50. Kuznetsov VA, Knott GD, Bonner RF (2002) General statistics of stochastic process of gene expression in eukaryotic cells. Genetics 161: 1321–1332.
- 51. Ueda HR, Hayashi S, Matsuyama S, Yomo T, Hashimoto S, et al. (2004) Universality and flexibility in gene expression from bacteria to human. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 3765–3769.
- 52. Almaas E, Kovacs B, Vicsek T, Oltvai ZN, Barabasi AL (2004) Global organization of metabolic fluxes in the bacterium Escherichia coli. Nature 427: 839–843.
- 53. Cloarec O, Dumas ME, Trygg J, Craig A, Barton RH, et al. (2005) Evaluation of the orthogonal projection on latent structure model limitations caused by chemical shift variability and improved visualization of biomarker changes in 1H NMR spectroscopic metabonomic studies. Anal Chem 77: 517–526.
- 54. Wishart DS, Lewis MJ, Morrissey JA, Flegel MD, Jeroncic K, et al. (2008) The human cerebrospinal fluid metabolome. J Chromatogr B Analyt Technol Biomed Life Sci.
- 55. Graca G, Duarte IF, Goodfellow BJ, Barros AS, Carreira IM, et al. (2007) Potential of NMR spectroscopy for the study of human amniotic fluid. Anal Chem 79: 8367–8375.
- 56. Martin FP, Dumas ME, Wang Y, Legido-Quigley C, Yap IK, et al. (2007) A top-down systems biology view of microbiome-mammalian metabolic interactions in a mouse model. Mol Syst Biol 3: 112.
- 57. Bundy JG, Sidhu JK, Rana F, Spurgeon DJ, Svendsen C, et al. (2008) ‘Systems toxicology’ approach identifies coordinated metabolic responses to copper in a terrestrial non-model invertebrate, the earthworm Lumbricus rubellus. BMC Biol 6: 25.
- 58. Saric J, Li JV, Wang Y, Keiser J, Bundy JG, et al. (2008) Metabolic Profiling of an Echinostoma caproni Infection in the Mouse for Biomarker Discovery. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2: e254.
- 59. Nicholson JK, Foxall PJ, Spraul M, Farrant RD, Lindon JC (1995) 750 MHz 1H and 1H-13C NMR spectroscopy of human blood plasma. Anal Chem 67: 793–811.
- 60. Fan WMT (1996) Metabolite profiling by one- and two-dimensional NMR analysis of complex mixtures. Progress in Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy 28: 161–219.
- 61. Sobolev AP, Brosio E, Gianferri R, Segre AL (2005) Metabolic profile of lettuce leaves by high-field NMR spectra. Magn Reson Chem 43: 625–638.
- 62. Lewis IA, Schommer SC, Hodis B, Robb KA, Tonelli M, et al. (2007) Method for determining molar concentrations of metabolites in complex solutions from two-dimensional 1H-13C NMR spectra. Anal Chem 79: 9385–9390.
- 63. Sattler M, Schleucher J, Griesinger C (1999) Heteronuclear multidimensional NMR experiments for the structure determination of proteins in solution employing pulsed field gradients. Progress in Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy 34: 93–158.
- 64. Sakellariou D, Le Goff G, Jacquinot JF (2007) High-resolution, high-sensitivity NMR of nanolitre anisotropic samples by coil spinning. Nature 447: 694–697.
- 65. Shanaiah N, Desilva MA, Nagana Gowda GA, Raftery MA, Hainline BE, et al. (2007) Class selection of amino acid metabolites in body fluids using chemical derivatization and their enhanced 13C NMR. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 11540–11544.
- 66. Bertalanffy Lv (1969) General System Theory, Foundations, Development, Applications. New York: George Braziller.
- 67. Tomita M, Hashimoto K, Takahashi K, Shimizu TS, Matsuzaki Y, et al. (1999) E-CELL: software environment for whole-cell simulation. Bioinformatics 15: 72–84.
- 68. Ideker T, Galitski T, Hood L (2001) A new approach to decoding life: systems biology. Annu Rev Genomics Hum Genet 2: 343–372.
- 69. Kitano H (2002) Systems biology: a brief overview. Science 295: 1662–1664.
- 70. Kirschner MW (2005) The meaning of systems biology. Cell 121: 503–504.
- 71. Weckwerth W (2003) Metabolomics in systems biology. Annu Rev Plant Biol 54: 669–689.
- 72. Weston AD, Hood L (2004) Systems biology, proteomics, and the future of health care: toward predictive, preventative, and personalized medicine. J Proteome Res 3: 179–196.
- 73. Megason SG, Fraser SE (2007) Imaging in systems biology. Cell 130: 784–795.
- 74. Rabani E, Reichman DR, Geissler PL, Brus LE (2003) Drying-mediated self-assembly of nanoparticles. Nature 426: 271–274.
- 75. Garrahan JP, Chandler D (2003) Coarse-grained microscopic model of glass formers. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: 9710–9714.
- 76. Russell R, Millett IS, Tate MW, Kwok LW, Nakatani B, et al. (2002) Rapid compaction during RNA folding. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99: 4266–4271.
- 77. Sotelo C (2004) Cellular and genetic regulation of the development of the cerebellar system. Prog Neurobiol 72: 295–339.
- 78. Wyatt GR, Loughheed TC, Wyatt SS (1956) The chemistry of insect hemolymph; organic components of the hemolymph of the silkworm, Bombyx mori, and two other species. J Gen Physiol 39: 853–868.
- 79. Hirayama C, Nakamura M (2002) Regulation of glutamine metabolism during the development of Bombyx mori larvae. Biochim Biophys Acta 1571: 131–137.
- 80. Ryan RO, van der Horst DJ (2000) Lipid transport biochemistry and its role in energy production. Annu Rev Entomol 45: 233–260.
- 81. Morita H, Toh H, Fukuda S, Horikawa H, Oshima K, et al. (2008) Comparative Genome Analysis of Lactobacillus reuteri and Lactobacillus fermentum Reveal a Genomic Island for Reuterin and Cobalamin Production. DNA Res 15: 151–161.
- 82. Axelos M, Curie C, Mazzolini L, Bardet C, Lescure B (1992) A Protocol for Transient Gene-Expression in Arabidopsis-Thaliana Protoplasts Isolated from Cell-Suspension Cultures. Plant Physiology and Biochemistry 30: 123–128.
- 83. Delaglio F, Grzesiek S, Vuister GW, Zhu G, Pfeifer J, et al. (1995) Nmrpipe - a Multidimensional Spectral Processing System Based on Unix Pipes. Journal of Biomolecular Nmr 6: 277–293.
- 84. Akiyama K, Chikayama E, Yuasa H, Shimada Y, Tohge T, et al. (2008) PRIMe: a Web site that assembles tools for metabolomics and transcriptomics. In Silico Biol 8: 0027.