Figures
Abstract
Invasive insect pests are responsible for important damage to native and plantation forests, when population outbreaks occur. Understanding the spatial pattern of attacks by forest pest populations is essential to improve our understanding of insect population dynamics and for predicting attack risk by invasives or planning pest management strategies. The woodwasp Sirex noctilio is an invasive woodwasp that has become probably the most important pest of pine plantations in the Southern Hemisphere. Our aim was to study the spatial dynamics of S. noctilio populations in Southern Argentina. Specifically we describe: (1) the spatial patterns of S. noctilio outbreaks and their relation with environmental factors at a landscape scale; and (2) characterize the spatial pattern of attacked trees at the stand scale. We surveyed the spatial distribution of S. noctilio outbreaks in three pine plantation landscapes, and we assessed potential associations with topographic variables, habitat characteristics, and distance to other outbreaks. We also looked at the spatial distribution of attacked trees in 20 stands with different levels of infestation, and assessed the relationship of attacks with stand composition and management. We found that the spatial pattern of pine stands with S. noctilio outbreaks at the landscape scale is influenced mainly by the host species present, slope aspect, and distance to other outbreaks. At a stand scale, there is strong aggregation of attacked trees in stands with intermediate infestation levels, and the degree of attacks is influenced by host species and plantation management. We conclude that the pattern of S. noctilio damage at different spatial scales is influenced by a combination of both inherent population dynamics and the underlying patterns of environmental factors. Our results have important implications for the understanding and management of invasive insect outbreaks in forest systems.
Citation: Lantschner MV, Corley JC (2015) Spatial Pattern of Attacks of the Invasive Woodwasp Sirex noctilio, at Landscape and Stand Scales. PLoS ONE 10(5): e0127099. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0127099
Academic Editor: João Pinto, Instituto de Higiene e Medicina Tropical, PORTUGAL
Received: January 7, 2015; Accepted: April 10, 2015; Published: May 18, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Lantschner, Corley. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: Funding came from SaFo-109 - UCAR-Ministerio de Agricultura, Ganadería y Pesca, Argentina (http://www.ucar.gob.ar/) and PICT-2013-0557 - Agencia Nacional para la Promoción Científica y Tecnológica, Argentina to JC (http://www.agencia.mincyt.gob.ar/). Both grants provided funding for study design, data collection and analysis, and preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Invasive forest insects can cause important damage to planted and natural forests, which can result in widespread tree mortality when pest population outbreaks occur [1–3]. Populations of outbreaking forest insects exhibit spatial patterns at multiple scales that can provide insights into why and how outbreaks develop. In turn, the spatial distribution of eruptive insect populations is affected by many factors that act at different scales, such as resource availability, habitat heterogeneity, climate, natural enemies, and insect dispersal behavior (see for example, [4–6]).
The spatial distribution of trees attacked by insects at a stand scale can be either randomly distributed or show some degree of clumping and this may vary with population size [7–10]. However at the landscape scale, insect populations that outbreak may show a spatial pattern that has an epicenter, where the outbreak begins and then spreads out through the forest or else, may occur as multiple simultaneous eruptions that tend to coalesce [3, 11, 12]. Variability in the spatial patterns observed and the variety of factors acting at different scales suggests that understanding the spatial pattern of attacks by forest pest populations is essential. This is not only because of its importance to improve our understanding of insect population dynamics in general but also because it is critical to predicting attack risk by invasives or planning pest management strategies.
Sirex noctilio is an invasive woodboring wasp that is native to Europe, northern Asia and Africa but that has established in several other regions of the world during the last century, such as Australasia, South America, South Africa, and North America [13–17]. This wasp has become one of the most important pests of softwood plantations in the Southern Hemisphere attracting much research aimed at controlling spread and preventing local outbreaks of established populations [18–23]. Sirex noctilio is a solitary hymenopteran insect that in association with a symbiotic fungus, Amylostereum areolatum and a phytotoxic venom, is the only siricid wasp capable of killing healthy host trees [13, 24, 25].
Sirex noctilio populations are known to remain at low densities in their native range and the insect is hence considered as a secondary pest there. However, in most of the invaded areas, this woodboring insect displays a pulse-like eruptive population behavior, which is when tree mortality becomes significant [13, 26]. Eruptive dynamics are characterized by lengthy periods during which the populations remain at relatively low densities and rapidly increase to outbreak levels in an unpredictable fashion [27]. Pulse-like outbreaks are rapid, they may last between 4 and 10 years, and are usually terminated by natural enemies, resource defenses or depletion [27].
The distribution and magnitude of S. noctilio outbreaks can be related to resource availability as well as to woodwasp life history traits [13, 28]. In this sense, Madden [13] proposed the “intermittent drought hypothesis” to explain the occurrence of S. noctilio outbreaks, according to which, discontinuous drought levels occurring during the woodwasp emergence season increase tree attractiveness and susceptibility to S. noctilio attacks. In contrast, Corley, Villacide and Bruzzone [7] suggest that limited dispersal behavior could lead to increased wood wasp performance through the concentration of attacks on trees, pontentially leading to local outbreaks (see also [28]).
While in general it is believed that any individual tree stressing factors may lead to enhanced susceptibility to woodwasp attacks, how these relate to outbreak magnitude and spatial population behavior is affected by scale. For instance, at a regional scale, extreme climatic events, like area-wide droughts may increase infestation probability by affecting tree vigor and susceptibility to insect attacks throughout a region [13]. At a finer scale, in turn, such as landscapes (defined as a spatially heterogeneous area of around 100 km2), topographic variables like elevation, slope, and slope aspect may also drive tree eco-physiological processes that may influence tree vulnerability. The degree of gross host availability (i.e., the amount of host species forest cover in an area) might also influence infestation occurrence. Finally, some stand-level factors, such as forest management (e.g. pruning, thinning) may determine the probability of trees to resist insect attacks [29, 30].
Although intensive research efforts have been carried out during the last decades toward understanding the biology, behavior, and control methods of S. noctilio (reviewed in [31]), there is still little information on the spatial distribution pattern of woodwasp attacks and its relationship with environmental factors at landscape or stand scale (but see [7][7]). By studying the outbreaks of current S. noctilio populations in NW Patagonia, our aims were: (1) to determine the spatial pattern of outbreaks and their relation with environmental factors at a landscape scale; and (2) to characterize the spatial pattern of trees attacked by S. noctilio at a stand scale. This information may contribute to a better understanding of the factors influencing S. noctilio outbreaks in general and also aid managers in predicting future infestations at both the stand and landscape scales.
Methods
Study area
The study was carried out in NW Patagonia (from 39° 15’ S to 43° 00’ S; and from 71° 00 W to 71° 34’ W). The climate of this area is temperate, dominated by a marked west-to-east decrease in precipitation. The study region is located in the forest/steppe transition area, where native vegetation ranges from forests of Austrocedrus chilensis and Nothofagus antarctica in the west, to a steppe dominated by bunchgrasses and low shrubs in the east. Mean annual rainfall ranges between 700 and 1,200 mm/year [32]. Pine plantations in the study region comprise mainly of three species: ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa), lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta), and Monterey pine (Pinus radiata).
Spatial distribution of outbreaks at the landscape scale
We studied the distribution of S. noctilio outbreaks, in three of the largest pine plantation landscapes of Patagonia: Arroyo del Medio (41°10'- 41°16'S; 71°10'- 71°16'W), Meliquina (40°22'- 40°30'S; 71°09'- 71°17'W) y Abra Ancha (39°18'- 39°21'S; 70°55'- 71°00'W) (Fig 1). The study was carried out on private lands, with permission of the owners. At each of these afforested landscapes, we developed maps of S. noctilio outbreak distribution. We conducted extensive visual surveys of S. noctilio damage at each landscape, with vehicles and on foot, within each stand-defined as woodlands with species and ages susceptible to be attacked by S. noctilio of surfaces from 5 to 20 ha-. In each stand we identified the occurrence of current and recent outbreaks. We defined outbreaks as stands with more than 5% of trees attacked by S. noctilio [22]. Observations were made from hills and/or places with panoramic view of each stand, near enough to detect levels of individual dead and dying co-dominant/ dominant trees below 5%. We identified as attacked trees those with obvious browning of the needle, or foliar senescence. In Patagonia, S. noctilio is to our knowledge the only insect species known to kill healthy pines, and is the only pest that develops outbreaks in pine plantations causing extensive tree mortality. Thus, by observing patches of trees with typical symptoms of the woodwasp attack, we confidently assumed that it represented a S. noctilio outbreak (see also below).
Detailed ground surveys were conducted in 20 stands inside the surveyed areas to confirm the presence of S. noctilio, and to calibrate the remote visual detection of outbreaks. We randomly selected 10 stands previously classified as outbreaks and 10 stands previously classified as not-outbreaks. In each stand we randomly established 7 transects, maximizing the coverage of the area. At each transect we walked along a plantation line, examining 70 trees and recording the number of attacked trees (trees with emergence holes or resin droplets). Surveys were performed during the months of January to April 2013.
We considered a set of 12 environmental variables as potential predictors of variation in S. noctilio outbreak occurrence. Variables examined included 8 that were obtained for all the surveyed stands: presence of P. ponderosa or P. contorta in the affected stand, proportion of P. ponderosa or P. contorta in a 1km radius neighborhood, altitude, slope, aspect, and distance to the nearest outbreak.
We used 1:500,000 resolution maps of plantation forests in the study area [33, 34] to define the location and planted species in each stand. Landscapes around each stand were described using a circular area of radius = 1km. We use this size of buffer to evaluate S. noctilio perception of landscape features, based on prior knowledge. Recent work has shown that the dispersal distances of adult females—using intercept baited traps- into a non-pine habitat, does not exceed 1,000 m from the plantation edge (Villacide unpublished data). We calculated the proportion of P. ponderosa and P. contorta surface inside this buffer area.
We used 30 m resolution ASTER digital elevation models of the study area [35] to estimate the topographic variables (altitude, slope angle, aspect), using ArcGIS 9.2 software (ESRI, Redlands, California, USA). To assign one value of each variable for each stand, we used the midpoint of each stand.
We performed Moran’s I autocorrelation test to assess the existence of spatial autocorrelation of attacked stands along each sampled basin. The univariate global Moran’s I, measures the linear association of a variable with itself in space and was used to test the strength of global spatial autocorrelation of S. noctilio attacked stands in each region. Moran’s I ranges between −1 and +1. A positive Moran’s I, indicates spatial clustering of either high or low values, whereas a Moran’s I near zero implies no spatial autocorrelation, or spatial randomness.
We used multiple logistic regressions to assess how S. noctilio outbreaks are related to environmental variables at the landscape level. We used presence/ absence of outbreaks as the dependent variable and included environmental variables as independent variables. Prior to analysis, aspect values were transformed from circular variables to a measure relevant to vegetation as: aspect = cosine (45° —azimuth degrees) + 1 [36]. Values range from 0 on south-western slopes commonly exposed to the sun to 2 on the least exposed north-eastern slopes. To understand the correlational structure in our data, and to pre-select variables for model comparison, we performed Spearman’s correlations in a pairwise fashion between all predictor variables and with estimated spread rate. Variables that showed at least moderate correlation with spread (p>0.15) were selected. To avoid multicollinearity, we performed Spearman correlations between pairs of predictor variables, setting a limit of rρ< 0.5 for keeping two correlated variables. In case of two variables been highly correlated, we excluded the variable less correlated with presence of S. noctilio outbreaks. All possible combinations of selected predictor variables were modeled, using logistic regression. The models were compared using Akaike’s Information Criterion for small sample sizes (AICc). Predictor variable pre-selection was necessary to allow us to employ an all possible regressions approach due to small sample size.
We calculated Ivlev’s electivity index (Ei, [37][37]), to assess which host species were selected (0 < Ei ≤ 1) and which were avoided (-1 ≤ Ei < 0) by S. noctilio eruptive populations, at a landscape scale. Ivlevs electivity index (Ei) was calculated as: Ei = (oi—li)/(oi + li), where oi is the proportion of stands of host species i with S. noctilio outbreaks, and li is the proportion of stands of host species i in each studied landscape.
To assess the niche breadth of S. noctilio eruptive populations in terms of host use, we calculated the proportional similarity index (PS) or the Czekanowsky index [38]: PS = 1–0.5 Σ | pi - qi |, where pi is the proportion of stands composed by species i with occurrence of S. noctilio outbreaks; and qi is the proportion of stands of species i, available to the population in each of the studied landscapes. The values for PS range from 1 for the broadest possible niche (a population uses resources in proportion to their availability) to 0 for the narrowest possible niche (a population is specialized exclusively on the rarest resource).
Spatial distribution of attacked trees at stand scale
We randomly selected 20 sites distributed among pine plantations of NW Patagonia (Fig 1). At each site, we selected one stand attacked by S. noctilio, with the highest attack level possible to find, based on the observation of external symptoms (browning or dead trees). Sampling sites were separated by a minimum of 8 km from one another to ensure spatial independence among S. noctilio populations.
At each sampling site we established a point in the middle of the stand, and from this point we established four transects, one in each cardinal direction. Each transect consisted of two parallel tree lines, totaling 70 trees (280 trees per site, Fig 1). We identified and recorded the number of attacked trees (trees with emergence holes or resin droplets), specifying the species and relative position within the transect for each attacked tree. Surveys were performed during the months of January to April 2014.
We performed the non parametric Kruskal-Wallis test to check for differences in the proportion of attacked trees between tree species, followed by post-hoc multiple comparisons. We performed a non-parametric Mann-Whitney test, to assess if there were differences in the proportion of attacked trees between stands with different management practices (thinned vs. unthinned, and pruned vs. not pruned).
We used Moran’s I to measure spatial autocorrelation and to identify spatial clustering in the attacked trees along transects, at stand scale. We also performed a quadratic regression analysis of the relationship between Moran’s Index and % of S. noctilio attacked trees at each site, to assess how the spatial aggregation the attacked trees varied with the total percentage of attacked trees in the stand.
Results
Spatial distribution at the landscape scale
Overall, we sampled and mapped a total of 7350 ha of pine plantations, including 741 stands: 370 in Meliquina (3,642 ha), 205 in Arroyo del Medio (1,685 ha), and 161 in Abra Ancha (2,023 ha). Seventy-five percent of the sampled stands were composed of pure Pinus ponderosa, 12% were mixed stands of P. ponderosa and P. contorta, 8% were of pure P. contorta, and 4% mixed stands of several other species (P. jeffreyi, P. radiata, Pseudotsuga menziesii).
We identified the presence of S. noctilio outbreaks in 64 of the sampled stands. From the ground transects we confirmed that in all cases we correctly identified the presence of S. noctilio attacks from outside of the stand. Additionally, in 90% of the cases, we correctly identified the presence or absence of an outbreak as defined by Villacide and Corley [22].
To assess how S. noctilio outbreaks relate to environmental variables at the landscape scale, we included four environmental variables in the logistic model regressions (Tables 1 and 2). The model with the lowest AIC score contained three variables: presence of P. contorta and aspect, which were positively related with S. noctilio outbreak occurrence; and distance to nearest outbreak, which was negatively related with S. noctilio outbreak occurrence (Table 3, Fig 2).
We found that Ivlev’s electivity index, was 0.603 for P. contorta stands, and -0.621 for P. ponderosa, indicating a clear selection of S. noctilio for P. contorta stands. We also found that the proportional similarity index (PS), was PS = 0.361. This indicates a relatively narrow niche breath of S. noctilio eruptive populations in terms of host use, which means that the woodwasp only reaches outbreak levels in stands composed of referred host species.
Spatial distribution at stand scale
At the stand scale, within the 20 sampled stands with S. noctilio presence, 72% of the sampled trees were P. contorta, 18% P. ponderosa, and 10% P. radiata. The proportion of attacked trees was significantly different among pine species (Chi2 = 31.22, p < 0.001). P. contorta was the species with the highest percentage of attacked individuals among the available individuals of the same species (24% of the total available trees were attacked), and was significantly more attacked than P. ponderosa (4% of the total trees where attacked, Z = 3.82, P < 0.001) and P. radiata (1% of the total trees where attacked, Z = 4.78, p < 0.001). We also found that among 280 trees sample in each of the 20 sites, the proportion of attacked trees in stands that were thinned was significant lower than in those that were not (Mann-Whitney U test, Z = 2.08, p<0.04), while no significantly differences in proportion of attacked trees were found among stands that were and were not pruned (Mann-Whitney U test, Z = 0.31, p<0.76).
We observed that the spatial arrangement of attacked trees varies according to woodwasp population density (Fig 3). We found a significant quadratic relationship between the level of aggregation of the attacked trees, and the total proportion of attacked trees in the stand: y = -15.4x2 + 10.4x + 0.11 (F = 3.89, p<0.041, R2 = 0.314). At endemic densities, the pattern of distribution of the attack is random. But, when the density of attack starts to increase towards epidemic values, the attack becomes clustered, showing the highest level of aggregation at densities of about 30% of attacked trees. At even higher attack densities, the distribution of attacked trees then becomes random again (Fig 3).
Discussion
The spatial pattern of pine stands with S. noctilio outbreaks in NW Patagonia, is mainly influenced by the relative abundance of the host species present, the topographic aspect (i.e. north and east slope aspects), and the distance to other outbreaks, at a landscape scale. In turn, at the stand scale, we noted a clear aggregation of the attacked trees in stands with increasing infestation levels, and again, the degree of S. noctilio attacks is strongly influenced by the host species abundance and by plantation thinning. Generally our findings confirm, as it has been observed for other forest pests around the world, that scale dependent factors interplay in determining the magnitude of the impact of S. noctilio in pine plantations, either directly by influencing the underlying woodwasp population dynamics, or indirectly by determining the susceptibility of the host resources to attack [12, 39–41].
At the landscape scale, we found that stands with P. contorta were preferred significantly more by S. noctilio, than any other species planted in the region. Although P. ponderosa is much more abundant than P. contorta in all three afforested landscapes we studied here (P. ponderosa was present in 88% of the stands, while P. contorta was present in only 16% of the stands), we found that in most stands in which S. noctilio outbreaks were observed (79%), the most common tree species was P. contorta. This strong preference of S. noctilio for P. contorta is probably due to differences in physical and chemical defenses of the tree species to woodwasp attacks. P. ponderosa has been found to produce higher amounts of resins than P. contorta, and has a bark that is thicker than that of P. ponderosa which could negatively affect preferences and successful oviposition by S. noctilio females (Martinson et al. in preparation). While no Pinus species has shown resistance against S. noctilio attacks along the invaded regions in the world, it is well known that some species are more vulnerable than others. For example, in Uruguay and Brazil Pinus elliottii appears to be less affected by woodwasps than Pinus taeda, while in South Africa, S. noctilio appears to prefer P. patula over P. elliottii [12, 42, 43]. Within the current distribution of S. noctilio in North America, P. strobus and P. resinosa seem to be the species being more heavily attacked, although non-native P. sylvestris plantations are also suffering heavy mortality [44].
We also found a significant effect of slope aspect on the probability of occurrence of S. noctilio outbreaks. Topographic characteristics such as slope aspect are known to influence site moisture conditions, and thus may trigger tree stress [39, 45]. In NW Patagonia, slope aspect is a key topographic variable influencing site moisture availability. North-facing slopes receive more solar radiation, experience greater evapotranspiration, and have less plant available soil moisture compared to south-facing slopes. Western aspects, on the other hand, are more exposed to the dominant winds, which are associated with higher precipitation and lower frequency of frosts [46]. Consequently, for plantations carried out on slopes as is commonly observed in Patagonia, spatial and temporal variations in site moisture conditions may influence the spatial pattern and severity of drought induced tree stress. Since physiologically stressed trees are presumed to be more attractive and susceptible to S. noctilio attacks [47], we suggest that slope aspect influences the occurrence of S. noctilio outbreaks through its effects on host susceptibility. It has been shown that topographical aspect can also influence infestation levels in other forest pests such as the hemlock woolly adelgid (Adelges tsugae) and the Douglas-fir bark beetle (Dendroctonus pseudotsugae) [39, 40, 48]. In line with our findings, all these studies found more frequent insect pests attacks in warmer and more xeric slopes, and concluded that trees growing on these slopes might grow less vigorously due to increased moisture stress, becoming more susceptible to insect attacks.
Outbreak occurrence probability is higher when outbreaks are occurring in stands neighboring others with outbreaks (average of approximately 500 m). This pattern is not unexpected and suggests that stands with woodwasp epidemic population levels tend to occur near extant infestations. Although similar patterns may arise from multiple confounding processes [5], this aggregated pattern of outbreaks at landscape scales is possibly due to density-dependent dispersal from nearby pest-ridden source populations. Dispersal has been identified as an important factor determining the spread of epidemics in forest insect populations [5]. New outbreak spots developing in the vicinity of existing infestations are largely dependent on short-range movement of insects in relation to various host tree, stand, and site characteristics, as well as weather conditions [49]. S. noctilio females vary greatly in body size and in dispersal potential: the smallest individuals fly short distances, and the larger females display long and continuous flight patterns [50]. Although there is no information on whether dispersal occurs as a density dependent process in S. noctilio, still larger numbers of flying females leaving plantations are likely to be observed with increasing population density (Villacide unpublished data).
The particular scale at which insects respond to landscape characteristics will depend on the species life traits, particularly their size and mobility [51]. In this sense, S. noctilio is a highly mobile species and is thus expected to be affected by larger scales. In accordance with our results, Dodds, Garman and Ross [41] found a clustered pattern of Dendroctonus pseudotsugae epidemic populations, with an average nearest neighbor distance of 500 m, while Wichmann and Ravn [52] found that during population outbreaks of Ips typographus in Denmark, most attacks occurred within 250 m of previous attacks. These authors interpreted the observed clustered patterns of outbreaks as a result of two possible biological factors, either susceptible trees are likely spatially grouped because of local environmental factors (management, topography, pathogens, etc.); or else there are density-dependent factors that influence local insect populations, and in years of high pest numbers, more individuals would be attracted to stands undergoing attack and ultimately shift to other host trees within those stands [41].
At the stand scale, we observed spatial aggregation of attacked trees at stands with intermediate levels of attacked trees. Our findings show that at endemic population levels of the wasp (i.e.: < 5% attacked stems), attacks are randomly distributed along the stand. While, at the onset of an outbreak, attacked trees start to become aggregated at multiple simultaneous epicenters along the stand, during more advanced stages, (> 30% of attacked trees) aggregates coalesce, and the distribution of healthy and attacked trees starts to become random again. Our results agree with previous studies of the spatial distribution of attacked trees by S. noctilio at the stand scale that showed a strong spatial aggregation of S. noctilio within a pine plantation during the early stages of the outbreak [7]. These authors suggested then, that aggregation behavior of S. noctilio females could increase performance through the concentration of attacks on trees. Additionally, Aparicio, Corley and Rabinovich [28] developed a model for woodwasp population dynamics within a pine plantation, and found that eruptive dynamics of the S. noctilio may be related to aggregation of attacks, and that outbreaks may occur in the absence of density independent factors, such as droughts. Very recently Fernandez Ajo, Martínez, Villacide and Corley [53], provide evidence that fungal volatiles are attractive to foraging S. noctilio females, again suggesting that clumping of attacks on given trees is likely expected. Whether the underlying processes are behavioral aggregation or demographic clumping, aggregation of attacks has been shown to be common strategy of several eruptive forest pest species, such as some bark beetle species (i.e. Dendroctonus ponderosae, D. pseudotsugae, D. frontalis) in the early stages of outbreaks [39, 54–56].
After initial aggregation, spatial patterns are often self-generating as a result of feedback loops, between organisms and their abiotic and biotic environment [27, 57]. In this sense, we found that some other stand-level factors, such as the planted species and some forest management practices are also important in determining the number of attacked trees. Even during an outbreak and when the abundance of wasps is very high and in stands with more than one pine species, S. noctilio significantly prefers to attack the one species (P. contorta) over several other (P. ponderosa and P. radiata). We also found that pine stands that were thinned are significantly less attacked than those that are overstocked. Thinning reduces competition for resources, reducing stress, and thus tree susceptibility to pest attacks [30, 56, 58, 59].
Integrating multiple scales: implications for pest management
Studying the spatial configuration of S. noctilio populations provides insights into how outbreaks develop. Our results suggest that the observed aggregated distribution pattern of attacked trees at different spatial scales is influenced by a combination of both S. noctilio inherent population dynamics and behavior, and the distribution and availability of susceptible trees. We found that, at a landscape scale the probability of wasp populations reaching outbreak levels in any given stand is significantly higher when next to it, is another stand bearing a recent outbreak. Also, outbreaks are more likely in P. contorta dominated stands. Not unexpectedly, the observed spatial pattern of S. noctilio outbreaks distribution at stand and landscape scale, is a combination of habitat heterogeneity and population dynamics (population growth and female dispersal).
Information on tree mortality levels resulting from pest infestations at multiple spatial scales is critical for assessing pest migration rates, the extent of tree damage and decline and in determining specific factors responsible for the observed patterns [6, 12, 39, 40]. This information is also relevant for anticipating future outbreaks and prioritizing management efforts [57, 60]. It is important to note that temporal patterns are also important to understand S. noctilio population dynamics. Here, we did not explore this or else effects of factors such as weather and natural enemies, which are likely to influence the occurrence and intensity of S. noctilio outbreaks. Further studies considering both spatial and temporal dynamics of the pest at different scales will help to better identify potential mechanisms driving S. noctilio population eruptions.
At the stand scale, some management practices, such as thinning are important to reduce host susceptibility to S. noctilio attack. In this sense, implementation of timely thinning practices, where possible, may help preventing S. noctilio outbreaks, [25, 47]. Also, as previously noted by Corley and Villacide [26], knowledge on the aggregation levels of S. noctilio attacked trees allows focalizing management actions such as monitoring and the introduction of natural enemies [26].
At the landscape scale, areas susceptible to S. noctilio eruptions could be predicted based on site attributes as the planted species, slope aspect, and distance to other outbreaks. In Patagonia, we note that special attention should be paid to stands with P. contorta. Interestingly, North America, which has natural forests of P. contorta in regions in which S. noctilio has not arrived yet, are likely to be colonized in the future [61] and should be the focus of careful monitoring. Other factors contributing to tree stress at the landscape scale, such as the slope aspect, may also be considered for anticipating future outbreaks, tracing pest risk maps and planning management in susceptible stands.
Additionally, it is essential to know the status of S. noctilio populations at the landscape scale, since it has been shown that population dynamics at the stand scale are not independent of the surrounding populations. For established populations in invaded regions, good monitoring efforts are warranted to prevent and manage potential outbreaks. Based on our results, we propose that S. noctilio outbreaks start in given specific areas that are affected by local stressing factors, and then spread out to neighboring areas through larger females flying larger distances from these epicenters. In this way, suppression of epicenter outbreaks can be expected to have a positive impact on preventing outbreaks in neighboring areas.
In conclusion, the multi-scale approach we employed in this study allowed us to identify the relative roles of fine- versus coarse-scale factors on S. noctilio eruptive dynamics. We highlight the importance considering both habitat heterogeneity and population dynamics at different spatial scales to predict and or prevent future S. noctilio outbreaks. Knowledge of these factors, how they interact, and the spatiotemporal patterns of outbreak development are critical to improve woodwasp management, and to define decisions to implement strategies intended to minimize their impacts.
Acknowledgments
We thank A. Martinez, J. Villacide, D. Fischbein, and A. Fernandez-Ajo for helping with field data collection and for valuable discussions and contributions throughout this work.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: MVL JCC. Performed the experiments: MVL. Analyzed the data: MVL. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MVL. Wrote the paper: MVL JCC.
References
- 1. Hatala JA, Crabtree RL, Halligan KQ, Moorcroft PR (2010) Landscape-scale patterns of forest pest and pathogen damage in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. Remote Sensing of Environment 114: 375–384.
- 2.
Kessler A, Poveda K, Poelman EH (2012) Plant-Induced Responses and Herbivore Population Dynamics. In: Barbosa P.;, Letourneau D.and Agrawal A., editors. Insect Outbreaks Revisited. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. pp. 89–112.
- 3.
Liebhold AM, Haynes KJ, Bjørnstad ON (2012) Spatial Synchrony of Insect Outbreaks. In: Barbosa P.;, Letourneau D. and Agrawal A., editors. Insect Outbreaks Revisited. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. pp. 113–125.
- 4. Peltonen M, Liebhold AM, Bjørnstad ON, Williams DW (2002) Spatial Synchrony in Forest Insect Outbreaks: Roles of Regional Stochasticity and Dispersal. Ecology 83: 3120–3129.
- 5. Aukema BH, Carroll AL, Zheng Y, Zhu J, Raffa KF, Dan Moore R, et al. (2008) Movement of outbreak populations of mountain pine beetle: influences of spatiotemporal patterns and climate. Ecography 31: 348–358.
- 6. Chapman TB, Veblen TT, Schoennagel T (2012) Spatiotemporal patterns of mountain pine beetle activity in the southern Rocky Mountains. Ecology 93: 2175–2185. pmid:23185879
- 7. Corley JC, Villacide JM, Bruzzone OA (2007) Spatial dynamics of a Sirex noctilio F., Hymenoptera:Siricidae) woodwasp population within a pine plantation in Patagonia, Argentina. Entomología Experimentalis et Applicata 125: 231–236.
- 8. Turchin P, Kareiva P (1989) Aggregation in Aphis Varians: An Effective Strategy for Reducing Predation Risk. Ecology 70: 1008–1016.
- 9. Parrish JK, Edelstein-Keshet L (1999) Complexity, Pattern, and Evolutionary Trade-Offs in Animal Aggregation. Science 284: 99–101. pmid:10102827
- 10. Aukema BH, Raffa KF (2004) Does aggregation benefit bark beetles by diluting predation? Links between a group-colonisation strategy and the absence of emergent multiple predator effects. Ecological Entomology 29: 129–138.
- 11. Johnson DM, Bjørnstad ON, Liebhold AM (2004) Landscape geometry and travelling waves in the larch budmoth. Ecology Letters 7: 967–974.
- 12. Bouchard M, Auger I (2014) Influence of environmental factors and spatio-temporal covariates during the initial development of a spruce budworm outbreak. Landscape Ecology 29: 111–126.
- 13.
Madden J (1988) Sirex in Australasia. In: Berryman A. A., editor editors. Dynamics of forest insect populations. New York: Plenum Press. pp. 407–429.
- 14. Tribe GD (1995) The woodwasp Sirex noctilio Fabricius (Hymenoptera: Siricidae), a pest of Pinus species, now established in South Africa. African Entomology 3: 215–217.
- 15.
Iede E, Penteado SRC, Schaitza EG (1998) Sirex noctilio problem in Brazil: detection, evaluation, and control. In: Iede E., Schaitza E. G., Penteado S., Reardon R. and Murphy S. T., editors. Proceedings of a Conference: Training in the Control of Sirex noctilio by Use of Natural Enemies. Colombo, Brazil. pp. 45–52.
- 16. Hoebeke ER, Haugen DA, Haack RA (2005) Sirex noctilio: discovery of a palearctic siricid woodwasp in New York. Newsletter of the Michigan Entomological Society 50: 24–25.
- 17. Lantschner MV, Villacide JM, Garnas JR, Croft P, Carnegie AJ, Liebhold AM, et al. (2014) Temperature explains variable spread rates of the invasive woodwasp Sirex noctilio in the Southern Hemisphere. Biological Invasions 16: 329–339.
- 18. Tribe GD, Cillie JJ (2004) The spread of Sirex noctilio Fabricius (Hymenoptera: Siricidae) in South African pine plantations and the introduction and establishment of its biological control agents. Entomological Society of Southern Africa 12: 9–17.
- 19. Carnegie AJ, Eldridge RH, Waterson DG (2005) History and management of Sirex wood wasp in pine plantations in New South Wales, Australia. New Zealand Journal of Forestry Science 35: 3–24.
- 20. Hurley B, Slippers B, Wingfield M (2007) A comparison of control results for the alien invasive woodwasp, Sirex noctilio, in the southern hemisphere. Agricultural and Forest Entomology 9: 159–171.
- 21. Yemshanov D, McKenney DW, de Groot P, Haugen D, Pedlar J, Sidders D, et al. (2011) A harvest failure approach to assess the threat from an invasive species. Journal of Environmental Management 92: 205–213. pmid:20870339
- 22. Villacide JM, Corley JC (2012) Ecology of the woodwasp Sirex noctilio: Tackling the challenge of successful pest management. International Journal of Pest Management 58: 249–256.
- 23. Corley JC, Villacide JM, Liebhold A (2014) Can entomophagous nematodes slow the spread of invasive pest populations? The case study of Beddingia siricidicola released for the management of Sirex noctilio. J Pest Sci 87: 551–557.
- 24. Talbot PHB (1977) The Sirex-Amylostereum-Pinus Association. Annual Review of Phytopathology 15: 41–54.
- 25. Spradbery JP, Kirk AA (1978) Aspects of the ecology of siricid woodwasps (Hymenoptera: Siricidae) in Europe, North Africa and Turkey with special reference to the biological control of Sirex noctilio F. in Australia. Bulletin of Entomological Research 68: 341–359.
- 26.
Corley JC, Villacide JM (2012) Population Dynamics of Sirex noctilio: Influence of Diapause, Spatial Aggregation and Flight Potential on Outbreaks and Spread. In: Slippers B., de Groot P. and Wingfield M. J., editors. The Sirex Woodwasp and its Fungal Symbiont: Research and Management of a Worldwide Invasive Pest. Netherlands: Springer. pp. 51–64.
- 27.
Berryman AA (1987) The theory and classification of outbreaks. In: Barbosa P. and Schults J., editors. Inset outbreaks. Academic Press. pp. 3–30.
- 28. Aparicio JP, Corley JC, Rabinovich JE (2013) Life history traits of Sirex noctilio F. (Hymenoptera: Siricidae) can explain outbreaks independently of environmental factors. Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering 10: 1265–1279. pmid:24245616
- 29. Eldridge RH, Simpson JA (1987) Development of contigency plans for use against exotic pests and diseases of trees and timber. 3. Histories of control measures against some introduced pests and diseases of forests and forest products in Australia. Australian Forestry 50: 24–36.
- 30. Haugen DA, Bedding RA, Underdown MG, Neumann FG (1990) National strategy for control of Sirex noctilio in Australia. Australian Forest Grower 13: 1–8.
- 31.
Slippers B, de Groot P, Wingfield MJ (2012) The Sirex Woodwasp and its Fungal Symbiont: Research and Management of a Worldwide Invasive Pest. Netherlands: Springer.
- 32.
Barros VR, Cordon VH, C.L. M, R.J. M, Forquera JC, Pizzo O (1983) Cartas de Precipitación de la zona oeste de las Provincias de Río Negro y Neuquén. Informe de la Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias. Cinco Saltos, Neuquén, Argentina: Universidad Nacional del Comahue.
- 33.
SAGPyA (2001) Inventario Nacional de Plantaciones Forestales. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Dirección de Forestación, Secretaría de Agricultura, Ganadería, Pesca y Alimentos.
- 34.
CFI-FUNDFAEP (2009) Inventario del bosque implantado de la provincia del Neuquén. Buenos Aires: Consejo Federal de Inversiones. pp. 63.
- 35.
ASTER-GDEM-Validation-Team (2009) ASTER Global DEM Validation Summary Report. Available online: https://lpdaac.usgs.gov/sites/default/files/public/aster/docs/ASTER_GDEM_Validation_Summary_Report.pdf (accessed on 29 December 2013).
- 36. Beers TW, Dress PE, Wensel LC (1966) Aspect transformation in site productivity research. Journal of Forestry 64: 691–692.
- 37.
Krebs CJ (1989) Ecological methodology. Harper & Row Publishers, New York.
- 38. Feinsinger P, Spears EE, Poole RW (1981) A Simple Measure of Niche Breadth. Ecology 62: 27–32.
- 39. Powers J, Sollins P, Harmon M, Jones J (1999) Plant-pest interactions in time and space: a Douglas-fir bark beetle outbreak as a case study. Landscape Ecology 14: 105–120.
- 40. Orwig DA, Foster DR, Mausel DL (2002) Landscape patterns of hemlock decline in New England due to the introduced hemlock woolly adelgid. Journal of Biogeography 29: 1475–1487.
- 41. Dodds KJ, Garman SL, Ross DW (2006) Landscape analyses of Douglas-fir beetle populations in northern Idaho. Forest Ecology and Management 231: 119–130.
- 42.
Iede E, Penteado SC, Filho W (2012) The Woodwasp Sirex noctilio in Brazil: Monitoring and Control. In: Slippers B., de Groot P. and Wingfield M. J., editors. The Sirex Woodwasp and its Fungal Symbiont: Research and Management of a Worldwide Invasive Pest. Springer Netherlands. pp. 217–228.
- 43.
Ryan K, Hurley B (2012) Life History and Biology of Sirex noctilio. In: Slippers B., de Groot P. and Wingfield M. J., editors. The Sirex Woodwasp and its Fungal Symbiont: Research and Management of a Worldwide Invasive Pest. Netherlands: Springer. pp. 15–30.
- 44.
Bordeaux J, Dean JD (2012) Susceptibility and Response of Pines to Sirex noctilio. In: Slippers B., de Groot P. and Wingfield M. J., editors. The Sirex Woodwasp and its Fungal Symbiont: Research and Management of a Worldwide Invasive Pest. Springer Netherlands. pp. 31–50.
- 45. Stephenson N (1998) Actual evapotranspiration and deficit: biologically meaningful correlates of vegetation distribution across spatial scales. Journal of Biogeography 25: 855–870.
- 46. Mermoz M, Kitzberger T, Veblen TT (2005) Landscape influences on occurrence and spread of wildfires in patagonian forests and shrublands. Ecology 86: 2705–2715.
- 47. Madden J (1968) Physiological aspects of host tree favourability for the woodwasp, Sirex noctilio F. Proceedings of the Ecological Society of Australia 3: 147–149.
- 48. Bonneau L, Shields K, Civco D (1999) Using Satellite Images to Classify and Analyze the Health of Hemlock Forests Infested by the Hemlock Woolly Adelgid. Biological Invasions 1: 255–267.
- 49. Safranyik L, Linton DA, Silversides R, McMullen LH (1992) Dispersal of released mountain pine beetles under the canopy of a mature lodgepole pine stand. Journal of Applied Entomology 113: 441–450.
- 50. Bruzzone OA, Villacide JM, Bernstein C, Corley JC (2009) Flight polymorphism in the woodwasp Sirex noctilio (Hymenoptera: Siricidae): an analysis of tethered flight data using wavelets. Journal of Experimental Biology 212: 731–737. pmid:19218525
- 51. Tscharntke T, Klein AM, Kruess A, Steffan-Dewenter I, Thies C (2005) Landscape perspectives on agricultural intensification and biodiversity—ecosystem service management. Ecology Letters 8: 857–874.
- 52. Wichmann L, Ravn HP (2001) The spread of Ips typographus (L.) (Coleoptera, Scolytidae) attacks following heavy windthrow in Denmark, analysed using GIS. Forest Ecology and Management 148: 31–39.
- 53. Fernandez Ajo AA, Martínez AS, Villacide JM, Corley JC (in press) Behavioral responses of the woodwasp Sirex noctilio to volatile emissions of its fungal symbiont. Journal of Applied Entomology.
- 54. Mitchell RG, Preisler HK (1991) Analysis of Spatial Patterns of Lodgepole Pine Attacked by Outbreak Populations of the Mountain Pine Beetle. Forest Science 37: 1390–1408.
- 55. Powell J, Tams J, Bentz B, Logan J (1998) Theoretical Analysis of “Switching” in a Localized Model for Mountain Pine Beetle Mass Attack. Journal of Theoretical Biology 194: 49–63. pmid:9778424
- 56. Fettig CJ, Klepzig KD, Billings RF, Munson AS, Nebeker TE, Negrón JF, et al. (2007) The effectiveness of vegetation management practices for prevention and control of bark beetle infestations in coniferous forests of the western and southern United States. Forest Ecology and Management 238: 24–53.
- 57. Logan JA, White P, Bentz BJ, Powell JA (1998) Model Analysis of Spatial Patterns in Mountain Pine Beetle Outbreaks. Theoretical Population Biology 53: 236–255. pmid:9682026
- 58.
Eldridge RH, Taylor EE (1989) Sirex woodwasp—a pest of pine in N.S.W. Forestry. Forest Protection Series No. 1. Australia: Commision of New South Wales.
- 59. Fitzgerald JW, Coulson RN, Pulley PE, Flamm RO, Oliveria FL, Swain KM, et al. (1994) Suppression Tactics for Dendroctonus frontalis Zimmerman (Coleoptera: Scolytidae): An Examination of the Occurrence of Infestations Adjacent to Treatment Sites. Journal of Economic Entomology 87: 417–425.
- 60. Ford TE, Colwell RR, Rose JB, Morse SS, Rogers DJ, Yates TL (2009) Using Satellite Images of Environmental Changes to Predict Infectious Disease Outbreaks. Emerging Infectious Diseases 15: 1341–1346. pmid:19788799
- 61. Carnegie AJ, Matsuki M, Haugen DA, Hurley B, Ahumada R, Klasmer P, et al. (2006) Predicting the potential distribution of Sirex noctilio (Hymenoptera: Siricidae), a significant exotic pest of Pinus plantations. Annals of Forest Science 63: 119–128.