Breath tests based on the administration of a 13C-labeled drug and subsequent monitoring of 13CO2 in the breath (quantified as DOB – delta over baseline) liberated from the drug during hepatic CPY-dependent detoxification are important tools in liver function diagnostics. The capability of such breath tests to reliably indicate hepatic CYP performance is limited by the fact that 13CO2 is not exclusively exhaled but also exchanged with other compartments of the body. In order to assess this bias caused by variations of individual systemic CO2 kinetics we administered intravenously the test drug 13C-methacetin to 25 clinically liver-healthy individuals and monitored progress curves of DOB and the plasma concentration of 13C-methacetin. Applying compartment modelling we estimated for each individual a set of kinetic parameters characterizing the time-dependent exchange of the drug and of CO2 with the liver and non-hepatic body compartments. This analysis revealed that individual variations in the kinetics of CO2 may account for up to 30% deviation of DOB curve parameters from their mean at otherwise identical 13C-methacetin metabolization rates. In order to correct for this bias we introduced a novel detoxification score which ideally should be assessed from the DOB curve of a 2-step test (“2DOB”) which is initialized with the injection of a standard dose of 13C-labeled bicarbonate (in order to provide information on the actual CO2 status of the individual) followed by injection of the 13C-labeled test drug (the common procedure). Computer simulations suggest that the predictive power of the proposed 2DOB breath test to reliably quantity the CYP-specific hepatic detoxification activity should be significantly higher compared to the conventional breath test.
Citation: Holzhütter H-G, Lock JF, Taheri P, Bulik S, Goede A, et al. (2013) Assessment of Hepatic Detoxification Activity: Proposal of an Improved Variant of the 13C-Methacetin Breath Test. PLoS ONE 8(8): e70780. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780
Editor: Matias A. Avila, University of Navarra School of Medicine and Center for Applied Medical Research (CIMA), Spain
Received: April 5, 2013; Accepted: June 22, 2013; Published: August 15, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 Holzhütter et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was in part supported by the BMBF-systems biology program “Virtual Liver” (FKZ 0315742). No further funding was received. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Non-invasive breath tests based on the stable isotope 13C have become a valuable diagnostic tool for several diseases. The core idea of such tests is the administration of a substrate with a labeled functional group. The substrate undergoes specific metabolization in the tissue under investigation, thus 13CO2 is released and can be quantitatively assessed in the expired breath. Breath tests are attractive for being less invasive, relatively simple and having a high patient acceptance , . Popular examples of breath tests are the detection of Helicobacter pylori infection by 13C-urea breath test  or testing of exocrine pancreatic function by 13C-labeled triacylglycerides . In liver surgery, breath tests are of particular relevance for the pre- and postoperative assessment of the organ function. To this end, various substrates as, for example, 13C-aminopyrine , , 13C-galactose ,  or 13C-phenylalanine  can be used. Several groups , , , , , , ,  prefer 13C-methacetin because of its non-toxicity in low doses and exclusive metabolization by the liver.
In this work we focus on the 13C-methacetin breath test (MBT). Hepatic (microsomal) deacylation of this drug yields as reaction products 13CO2 and the analgetic and antipyretic drug paracetamol. The diagnostic value of the conventional MBT has remained somehow limited, since oral administration of methacetin leads to a delay in kinetics by gastric emptying and absorption. Thus, the MBT is weak in discriminating between different stages of progressing fibrosis and liver cirrhosis due to larger individual differences between distinctive patients , . However, a new intravenous test protocol with online measurement (LiMAx test) seems to enable a more precise assessment. This has been clinically validated for the prediction of postoperative outcome after liver surgery ,  and transplantation , .
A general issue with all 13C-labeled breath tests is, however, that emerging 13CO2 is not directly and exclusively eliminated by respiration but partially distributed throughout the whole body. In a preliminary report  we found that the time curve of exhaled 13CO2 was significantly delayed compared with the kinetics of methacetin plasma washout. This finding can be reasoned by the fact that in virtually all tissues 13CO2 can be incorporated into organic molecules (13CO2-fixation) by various biochemical reactions of the intermediary metabolism. In addition, it is known that 13CO2 can be integrated in the large bicarbonate pool in blood and blood cells. Those fractions of transiently trapped 13CO2 can be liberated with some delay (e.g. 13CO2-decarboxylation) into the plasma and exhaled. Another issue is that a certain fraction of 13CO2 is not recovered in the breath because of renal clearance as H13CO3− or hepatic clearance as 13C-labeled urea. The relative contribution of these non-respiratory clearance processes to the kinetics of 13CO2 in the blood and thus in the breath shows larger intra- and inter-individual differences , ,  and is strongly affected by the metabolic state of the investigated patients .
The aim of this work was to assess the impact of individual variations in the exchange kinetics of CO2/bicarbonate with other body compartments on the DOB profile and to suggest a combined experimental-computational approach that enables to correct the kinetics of exhaled 13CO2 measured in the MBT for the contribution of systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics and by this to provide a more precise assessment of the actual functional capacity of the liver.
Methods and Mathematical Modeling
A group of 25 healthy volunteers were enrolled into the study after exclusion of any disease by medical history, standard laboratory and clinical examination. Descriptive characteristics see Table 1. In addition 30 patients with chronic liver diseases prior liver transplantation were included into analysis. Those patients had participated in another clinical study that has already been published elsewhere , . Out of this group, 10 patients suffered from malignant tumors in non-cirrhotic livers, another 10 patients had biopsy proven cirrhosis but compensated function (serum bilirubin 2.7±1.7 mg/dl), finally ten patients with end-stage cirrhosis and decompensated function (serum bilirubin 4.4±3.0 mg/dl).
Table 1. Model parameters for individual test subjects.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.t001
All healthy volunteers and patients received an intravenous injection of 13C-labeled methacetin (injection dose = 2 mg/kg). The amount of 13CO2 in the breath exceeding that of continuously formed endogenous 13CO2 ( = delta over baseline – DOB) was measured over 30 minutes by a modified non-dispersive isotope-selective infrared spectroscopy based device (FANci2-db16, Fischer Analyseninstrumente, Leipzig, Germany). Mean baseline 13CO2/12CO2 ratio was recorded ten minutes before injection. Six time points (1, 2, 5, 10, 20, 30 min) were selected for analysis. The two different study protocols were prior approved by the faculty's' (University Medicine Berlin - Charité; Germany) ethical review board and written informed consent was obtained from each individual.
In addition to the breath test, the healthy volunteers received analysis of blood pharmacokinetics. The concentration of 13C-methacetin and paracetamol in the blood was measured at six time points (2, 5, 10, 20, 30, 60 min). Blood probes were drawn in a standardized manner: Five ml were discarded and a sample of 5 ml was drawn in a serum tube. Probes were centrifuged with 1,500 g for 4 minutes and the serum aliquot was separated. Blinded probes were analyzed for 13C-methacetin and paracetamol by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). HPLC analysis was performed using a Ultrashere ODS column (250 mm×4,6 mm×5 µm; Beckman Coulter, Krefeld, Germany) with a LC-6B system (Shimadzu, Duisburg, Germany) at a flow rate of 1.5 mL/min, with UV-detection at 260 nm. Samples of 50 µl serum were mixed with 100 µl of acetonitrile/methanol solution (1:1) and centrifuged 10,000 g for 8 minutes before HPLC. Samples of each 10 µl were applied to the analyzer. A commercial HPLC-Test-Kit for measurement of levetiracetam (Chromsystems GmbH, Munich, Germany) was used for the analysis. The Kit-conditions were modified for estimation of methacetin and paracetamol. Chromatography was performed with a LC-6B system (Shimadzu, Duisburg, Germany) at a flow rate of 1.5 mL/min, with UV-detection at 260 nm. The sensitivity was 0.5 µg/mL with proven test linearity up to a concentration of 100 µg/ml. The mean inter-assay variability was 6.8% for methacetin and 6.9% for paracetamol.
Estimation of characteristic parameters of 13C-methacetin and DOB time courses
The measured time courses of plasma 13C-methacetin, plasma paracetamol and DOB were approximated by an exponential regression function,(1)
with coefficients obeying the side constraints A1+A2+A3 = 0 for the time course of DOB and paracetamol, and A1+A2+A3 = M0 ( = initial plasma concentration of 13C-methacetin) for the time course of 13C-methacetin. From the regression function we estimated the following empirical parameters: half-life of 13C-methacetin plasma concentration (M0.5), DOB peak height (DOBmax), DOB time to peak (DOBmaxT) and DOB at t = 20 min (DOB20).
Compartment modeling of 13C-methacetin, 13CO2 and paracetamol kinetics
We used a 3-compartment model (Fig. 1) to describe the kinetics of 13C-methacetin (M), 13CO2 (C) and paracetamol (P). Note that the variable C represents the total concentration of 13CO2 and H13CO3, which are in quasi-equilibrium due to the fast carboanhydrase reaction. 13C-methacetin in the plasma compartment (B) is reversibly exchanged with the liver compartment (L). Exchange of methacetin with other body compartments was not considered, as its kinetic discrimination from exchange with the liver was not feasible from the measurements of plasma 13C-methacetin.
Figure 1. Schematic of the 3-compartment model used to describe the observed kinetics of 13C-methacetin (M), paracetamol (P) and 13CO2 (C) (quantified in the breath as DOB).
(1) Injection of M into the blood, (2) reversible exchange of M between blood and liver, (3) hepatic metabolization of M to P and C, (4) reversible exchange of P between blood and other body compartments, (5) reversible exchange of CO2 between blood and other body compartments, (6) respiratory removal of M, (7) injection of H13CO3 (in the proposed novel 2DOB-method). ΩB, ΩL and ΩX denote the volume of the three compartments.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.g001
Hepatic formation of 13CO2 and paracetamol from 13C- and release into the plasma is described by a single overall reaction step. Paracetamol and 13CO2 may reversibly exchange between plasma and body compartments (X). Excretion of paracetamol was not explicitly considered in the model because the plasma half-life is 1.5–2.5 hours  but the potential influence of paracetamol excretion on its plasma profile can be partially captured by the parameter k+P. Release of plasma 13CO2 into the breath is quantified by the DOB value. Additionally, application of the proposed novel 2DOB method envisages the direct administration of H13CO3 injection into the plasma. Non-respiratory elimination of 13C-bicarbonate by the kidney or liver was not modeled but the potential influence of such elimination on the plasma profile and thus DOB curve can be partially covered by the parameter k+C.
Time-dependent changes in the compartment concentrations of 13C-methacetin, 13CO2 and paracetamol are governed by a system of 6 first-order differential equations:(2)
The variables are related to the original variables of Fig. 1 ML, CX and PX through(3)
where denote the volume of the respective compartment.
The function g(t) was introduced to take into account that quantifiable amounts of paracetamol occurred in the plasma with some delay compared to the rapid decline of 13C-methacetin:(4)
Numerical estimates for the model parameters k+M, k−M, k+C, k−C, k+P, k−P and γ obtained for the 25 subjects are given in Table 1. The estimation of parameter values was performed by combining the numerical integration of the equation system (2) by means of a 5th-order Runge-Kutta procedure with a non-linear regression method (Frontline Solver, Version 6.0). In these computations, the numerical value of the rate constant for respiratory CO2 elimination was put to 0.038 which corresponds to a total amount of 8.5 mmol CO2 exhaled per minute by a person having a body surface of 1.7 m2.
Comparing DOB curves with plasma profiles of 13C-methacetin and paracetamol
First, we compared the kinetics of 13CO2 release into the breath (DOB) with the plasma profiles of 13C-methacetin and paracetamol. To this end, the time courses of these variables were approximated by exponential regression functions (see Methods).
A typical example is shown in Fig. 2 (dotted curves). As already noted in , there was a significant difference between the kinetics of DOB and plasma 13C-methacetin. Whereas plasma 13C-methacetin was rapidly cleared from the plasma with a half-life of about 0.5 minutes directly after administration, elevated DOB values persisted more than 30 minutes. Moreover, for the set of 25 subjects studied the half-life of 13C-methacetin in the plasma, showed only a very weak correlation with DOB curve parameters (Fig. 3). These findings indicate that the early clearance rate of plasma 13C-methacetin merely reflects the rapid distribution of the test compound, but does not mirror its metabolization rate and thus cannot be used as reliable indicator of liver function.
Figure 2. Typical time-course of plasma 13C-methacetin (triangles), paracetamol (circles) and DOB (squares) after intravenous injection of 13C-methacetin (2 mg/kg).
The thin dotted lines represent best-fit curves constructed by means of an exponential regression function (1) to estimate numerical values of the characteristic parameters Mo.5, DOBmax, DOBmaxT and DOB20 (see Table 1). The solid lines represent best-fit curves obtained by fitting equation system (2) to the measured data (numerical parameter values for the shown data are for patient PX, see Table 1). The bold grey curve represents the computed time-course of the variable (ΩL/ΩB) [13C-methacetin] (see transformation (3)) in the liver compartment.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.g002
Figure 3. Relation between clearance of plasma 13C-methacetin (represented by the parameter M0.5 indicating the time required for a 50% drop) and the DOB curve parameter DOBmax (triangles), DOBmaxT (circles) and DOB20 (squares).
Numerical values of these parameters for the 25 subjects are given in Table 1. DOBmax and DOB20 are given in ‰.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.g003
Estimation of the actual capacity for the metabolism of 13C-methacetin
Next, we applied the compartment model described in the methods section to estimate the actual capacity for the metabolism of 13C-methacetin. To this end, numerical values for all model parameters were estimated by fitting the equation system (2) to measured time-course data of plasma 13C-methacetin, plasma paracetamol and exhaled 13CO2 (DOB). A typical data fit is shown in Fig. 2 (solid lines). Numerical values of the model parameters for the 25 subjects are depicted in Table 1.
The bold grey curve in Fig. 2 shows (up to the linear scaling factor , see (3)) the computed time-course of 13C-methacetin in the liver compartment. The peak of this concentration curve appears at a significantly earlier time point than that of the DOB curve. Such a time shift was already reported in an earlier study with 14C-methacetin in rats .
As the capacity of the liver to metabolize 13C-methacetin depends from both the exchange rates k−M and k+M and the chemical conversion rate kL we decided to use as liver function parameter the fraction of administrated 13C-methacetin (M0) that within 3 minutes after its application is taken up by the liver and metabolized to paracetamol. We call this liver function parameter Fractional Hepatic Metabolization Capacity (FHMC):(3)
With an average blood volume of 60 ml per kg body weight  and a 13C-methacetin dose of 2 mg/kg the initial plasma concentration of appearing as pre-factor in (3) was put to in all calculations.
Note that the parameter FHMC defined in equation (3) overestimates the true detoxification rate of 13C-methacetin as our model assumes that the plasma clearance of 13C-methacetin is exclusively due to exchange with the liver, thereby neglecting the rapid distribution of the test drug into other compartments and tissues and its delayed release back to the plasma and subsequent metabolization in the liver.
Numerical estimates of FHMC for the 25 subjects are depicted in Table 1. On the average, about 23% of 13C-methacetin entering the liver within the first 3 minutes was metabolized.
Considering that FHMC reflects the capacity of the liver to metabolize 13C-methacetin we asked how well this liver function parameter can be inferred from the DOB curve (see Fig. 4). The correlation of FHMC with the characteristic parameters DOBmax and DOB20 is indeed better than the correlation with the half-life of plasma 13C-methacetin (see Fig. 4). Nevertheless, relevant individual deviations from the linear regression line remain. For example, largely deviating DOB peak values of 24 and 40 may be associated with a similar FHMC value of about 22%. Hence, DOB curves as routinely monitored in the methacetin breath test may frequently provide imprecise results of the actual hepatic 13C-methacetin metabolization. We reasoned that the remaining discrepancies between hepatic metabolization capacity for 13C-methacetin (FHMC) and DOB curve parameters are due to individual variations of the exchange kinetics of 13CO2/H13CO3 between plasma and other body compartments.
Figure 4. Relation between the hepatic metabolization capacity (represented by the parameter FHMC being the % share 13C-methacetin metabolized within 3 minutes) and the DOB curve parameter DOBmax (triangles), DOBmaxT (circles) and DOB20 (squares).
Numerical values of these parameters for the 25 subjects are given in Table 1. DOBmax and DOB20 are given in ‰.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.g004
Impact of individual systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics on DOB curves
Individual variations of the exchange kinetics of 13CO2/H13CO3 between plasma and other body compartments are illustrated in Fig. 5 where we used the numerical values of the kinetic parameters k−C and k+C estimated for the 25 subjects to calculate DOB curves which would result from direct injection of 2.4 mg/kg bodyweight H13CO3 into the blood plasma. In the following we designate DOB curves generated by direct administration of labeled bicarbonate with DOBB to distinguish them from DOB curves generated by administration of the test compound methacetin. As shown in Fig. 5, the DOBB curves exhibit larger differences in the initial part between t = 0 and t = 5 minutes. At larger time points (t>15 minutes) this differences between the curves becomes smaller. All curves posses a large tail characterized by a marginal further decline. The average half-life of 13CO2 in the blood was 2.2±0.6 minutes and the average residual amount after 30 minutes was 9.2±0.9%. These values are in good agreement with values obtained from a set of 6 experimentally determined DOBB curves, i.e. 2.9±0.6 minutes half-live and 11.8±3.6% residual amount, which we took from a publication on the quantification systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics in humans , . This suggests that the numerical estimates of our model parameters k−C and k+C reliably reflect the 13CO2/H13CO3 exchange between plasma and other body compartments. Our simpler model for the bicarbonate washout slightly overestimates the velocity of CO2 exhalation compared to the more detailed models ,  but yields a sufficient approximate for the short times considered in this study.
Figure 5. DOBB curves initiated by the direct injection of 1 mmol/l 13C-bicarbonate into the plasma at time t = 0.
Thin lines represent simulated DOB curves based on the kinetic model parameters k+C and k−C determined for the 25 subjects (see Table 1). Bold lines indicate DOB curves fitted to experimental data measured in 6 patients . The DOB values are normalized to the DOB value at t = 0 (100%).doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.g005
Estimation of FHMC from conventional DOB curves of patients with different severity of liver function impairment
Conventional 60 minutes DOB curves of 30 patients prior liver transplantation were used for the validation of the developed model. As these curves do not allow the identification of neither the model parameters k+C and k−C (rate constants for CO2/bicarbonbate exchange) nor the model parameters k+M and k−M (rate constants for methacetine exchange) independent of kL (CYP-dependent methacetin conversion rate) there was no other choice than neglecting individual differences in these parameters and approximating their values by the mean values obtained in the 25 liver-healthy individuals (see Table 1). Fixing the values of the parameters k+M and k−M to their mean is indeed not very problematic as the impact of these parameters on FHMC is largely redundant with the impact of the parameter kL. For example, an increase of the value of k+M alone would lead to a more rapid clearance of plasma methacetine, an increase of the hepatic methacetine concentration and thus a higher value of FHMC. This effect can be almost completely nullified by a proper decrease of the value of kL.
With this setting, the only adjustable parameters of the model are the rate constants kL for the CYP-dependent methacetin conversion and the respiration rate kR. The resulting FHMC value is similar in all these settings. Notwithstanding the necessary simplifications used here, the compartment model provided a satisfactory description of the measured DOB curves (see inset in Fig. 6 for representative examples of such curve fits). As shown in Fig. 6, the FHMC was able to discriminate between three different classes of liver function impairment presented by the patients. This analysis demonstrates that our model can be applied to liver healthy and liver impaired individuals.
Figure 6. Relationship between FMHC and the severity of liver function impairment assessed by the LIMAX score FHMC values were estimated for 30 patients with different severity of liver function failure by fitting the model equation system (2) to conventional DOB curve data while fixing the values of the kinetic parameters k+C, k−C for systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics at the mean value obtained in the 25 investigated subjects.
Based on the LIMAX score the patients were arranged into three different groups of liver function failure (indicated by the colors green, blue and red) and within each group ranked with their FMHC value. The inset shows experimental and fitted DOB curves for three patients belonging to different classes of liver function impairment (indicated by a circle in the FHMC versus patient no. plot).doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.g006
The influence of individual variations in the hepatic detoxification kinetics on the characteristics of the DOB curve
We assessed the consequences of the observed individual variations in the systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics on the shape of the DOB curve by computer simulations. To this end we defined a ‘generic’ liver-healthy patient by using for the parameters of the compartment model the mean values obtained across the 25 subjects (see second last column in Table 1). We simulated a gradual loss of liver function of this generic patient by reducing the numerical value of the rate constant for the conversion of methacetin to paracetamol kL in 10 steps from 100% to 10% of the initial value. This resulted in the 10 different FHMC values. The associated DOB curves are shown in Fig. 7. They exhibit a successive decrease of DOBmax, which for residual metabolization rates of less than 40% is even not defined within the observation time interval of 30 minutes, an increase of DOBmax and a decrease of DOB20 with decreasing metabolization rate kL.
Figure 7. Simulated DOB (values in ‰) curves of a ‘generic’ patient at different degrees of liver impairment.
The value of the metabolization rate was successively reduced in steps of 10% from the initial 100%-value (kL = 0.09 min−1).doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.g007
On top, we included individual variations in systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics by using for the parameters k−C and k+C one after the other the numerical values obtained in the 25 subjects. This computer experiment yielded 10×25 = 250 different DOB curves for which we determined the characteristic DOB curve parameters peak height, time to peak and DOB20 from the exponential regression function (for details see legend of Fig. 8).
A Conventional breath test: Relation between the true value of the liver function parameter FHMC and the characteristic parameter DOBmax of DOB curves. DOB curves were simulated at various degrees of liver impairment by reducing the value of the model parameter kL in steps of 10%. For each degree of liver function impairment, we used the 25 different parameters pairs k+C, k−C for systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics obtained in the 25 investigated subjects. Note that for the liver-healthy ‘generic’ patient ( = 100% metabolization capacity) the variance of DOBmax is 8.1 thus being 25% of the mean (36.7). B 2DOB breath test: Relation between true and estimated values of the liver function parameter FHMC. Estimation of FHMC values was performed by fitting the compartment model to the 2-phasic DOB curve resulting from injection of 13C- bicarbonate followed by injection of 13C-methacetin (see Fig. 6).doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.g008
For each individual, a well-defined monotone relationship exists between DOBmax and FHCM, i.e. changes in the liver capacity should be clearly reflected by changes of DOBmax or related DOB curve parameters. For example, reducing the liver capacity of the patient represented by the bold curve in Fig. 8A by 50%, e.g. due to a partial hepatectomy, is predicted to lower the value of DOBmax by about 25% from 31 to 24. This well-defined intra-individual relation between DOB curve parameters and liver function is the prerequisite for the precise determination of individual liver function by MBT , , , .
On the other hand, inter-individual variations are large due to individual variations in the systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics largely varying values of the DOB curve parameter DOBmax may be associated with the same value of the liver function parameter FHMC. For example, in the worst case a numerical value of about 30 of the parameter DOBmax characteristic for a normal liver function can still be observed if the value of FHMC has already dropped to about 50% of the normal. Of note, the variability of DOB curve parameter values at fixed value of the liver function parameter FHMC becomes smaller with decreasing metabolization capacity of the liver. Thus, poor values of DOB parameters indeed validly reflect a poor metabolization capacity of the liver as long as the CO2/bicarbonate kinetics of the patient is in the range defined by the DOBB curves in Fig. 5.
2DOB: Accounting for the Impact of individual systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics on DOB curves
In order to correct the measured kinetics of exhaled 13CO2 for the impact of individual variations in the systemic CO2/bicarbonate metabolism allowing a more accurate assessment of the hepatic metabolization capacity we propose a novel variant of the breath test that we call 2DOB method. It envisages the administration of a defined amount of 13C-bicarbonate prior to the administration of the labeled test chemical. Subsequent injection of 13C-bicarbonate and 13C-methacetin results in a 2-phasic DOB curve (see bold circles in Fig. 9). The first part of this DOB curve represents the washout of 13C-bicarbonate from the plasma and contains information on the kinetic parameters k+C and k−C for the exchange of carbon dioxide between plasma and various body compartments. The second (non-monotone) part of the DOB curve starts at the time of 13C-methacetin administration. It represents the plasma level of 13CO2 produced by 13C-methacetin metabolization and on top the residual part left from the preceding 13C-bicarbonate administration. Therefore, the peak of the second part of the combined DOB curve is higher than the peak of the conventional DOB curve (open circles in Fig. 9). This second part of the biphasic DOB-curve contains information on the kinetic parameters k+M, k−M and kL for the exchange of 13C-methacetin between blood and liver and hepatic metabolization of 13C-methacetin. Fitting the model equations (2) to the 2-phasic DOB curves thus provides unequivocal numerical estimates for all relevant model parameters and allows the differentiation of the 13C-methacetin kinetics from that of systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics of the observed DOB kinetics.
Figure 9. Simulated DOB (values in ‰) curves for the conventional breath test and the proposed novel 2DOB method.
The conventional breath tests was simulated by generating DOB curves with the mean values of the kinetic model parameters determined in the 25 subjects (see Table 1). We imposed a random error of 15% to the simulated DOB data (open circles) and approximated these data by the exponential regression function (thin line) from which the characteristic parameters of the DOB were derived. Simulation of 2DOB breath test was done in a similar way but with the exception that first at time t = 0 a bolus of 0.1 mmol/l 13C-bicarbonate followed by the injection of 2 mg 13C-methacetin/kg bodyweight at time t = 15 min. A random error of 15% was imposed to the simulated 2-phasic DOB data (closed circles). Fitting of equation system (2) to these data yielded the model parameters k+C, k−C, k+M, k−M and kL and theoretical time-courses of DOB (bold line) and of 13C-methacetin (curve not shown) in the liver. Based on this information the numerical value of FHMC was estimated.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0070780.g009
To illustrate the usefulness of the proposed 2DOB approach we performed again computer simulations similar to those described in the previous section. We again generated 250 virtual patients with 13C-methacetin metabolization rates between 10% and 100% of the normal and 25 different parameter sets for the CO2/bicarbonate exchange between plasma and body compartments. However, we now initialized each computer experiment by administration of 0.1 mmol H13CO3 and monitored the resulting DOBB curve over 15 minutes. Injection of 13C-methacetin was simulated at time t = 15 minutes and the time-course of DOB monitored again over 15 minutes (for further details of the simulation see legend of Fig. 9). Fitting of equation system (2) to the resulting 2-phasic DOB curve yielded an estimate of the liver function parameter FHMC which we compared with the actual value of FHMC used in the simulation. As shown in Fig. 8B, the 2DOB procedure yielded an almost perfect prediction of FHMC. From the in silico validation we conclude that the proposed 2DOB method should enable a significantly more precise estimation of the metabolization capacity of the liver and hence improve the diagnostic accuracy of breath tests.
13CO2-based breath tests have become an wide-spread application in the clinical diagnosis of various types of organ dysfunctions. However, one reason that up to now has prevented breath tests to enter the mainstream of clinical practice is the perception that they lack the specificity and adequate precision needed to give accurate results in real time , . In an attempt to refine the methodology of 13CO2-based breath tests we have identified systemic distribution and elimination of CO2 as one crucial factor that may potentially compromise the predictive capacity of such tests. The 13CO2 released from the tissue under investigation into the blood plasma, is exchanged with numerous body compartments whereby the exchange kinetics depends on the type of the body compartment (e.g. bones exchange CO2 much slower than kidneys) and exhibits larger individual variations , , . Therefore, we carried out a critical evaluation of the accuracy of the intravenous 13C-methacetin breath test to determine the functional capacity of the liver. The test results obtained during breath analysis can be influenced by variations in the individual kinetics of plasma CO2. As the extraction rate of the test drug from the plasma provides a more direct measure of its hepatic elimination we measured simultaneously the exhalation of 13CO2 liberated from the test drug 13C-methacetin and the plasma kinetics of 13C-methacetin and its reaction product paracetamol in 25 healthy subjects and analyzed the kinetic data by means of a pharmacokinetic compartment model.
As already reported in , the two time courses occur at different time scales with a rapid extraction of 13C-methacetin within a few minutes and a DOB profile persisting more than 60 minutes. As shown in Fig. 2, the characteristic parameters of the DOB curve commonly used as the test readouts of liver performance are not accurately correlated with the disappearance rate of 13C-methacetin in the plasma. According to our model-based calculations, the rapid hepatic extraction of 13C-methacetin from the plasma leads to an initial accumulation in the liver followed by a slower metabolization whereby that uptake rate of the test chemical into the liver does not allow to infer its metabolization rate. It has to be mentioned that our model does not take into account the net loss of 13HCO3− from the body due to excretion by the kidney or conversion into urea in the liver. However, for the proposed short duration of the test of about 30 minutes these non-respiratory changes in the total amount of systemic 13HCO3− should remain negligibly small.
We quantified the functional performance of the liver by the parameter FHMC being the percentage of the administrated dose of the test drug metabolized within the first 3 minutes. It has to be noted, that owing to the simplicity of the model the parameter FHCM represents an integral liver function parameter the value of which depends on the rate of exchange of the test compound between plasma and the hepatocyte compartment, blood perfusion of the organ, the total amount of viable and the enzymatic capacity of individual hepatocytes to detoxify the given test compound. The relative contribution of these various sources to an altered value of FHMC cannot be further quantified. Experiments with isolated hepatocytes would allow to eliminate the effect of impaired blood perfusion. Exposing cultured hepatocytes to defined perturbations such as hypoxia, oxidative stress or excessive lipid accumulation (hepatic steatosis) and measuring their capacity to detoxify 13C-metacetin would provide an excellent means to assess the sensitivity of FHMC against ‘mild’ alterations in the ultra-structure and biochemical functions of hepatocytes that usually precede severe liver dysfunction.
We found that DOB curve parameters, such as DOBmax, usually used in clinical applications of the breath test to evaluate liver function showed a relatively small correlation with the liver function parameter FHMC when studied across a group of different individuals. Our analysis provided evidence that this fairly poor correlation is due to considerable individual variations in the exchange kinetics of CO2/bicarbonate between plasma and other body compartments.
It has to be emphasized that this finding doesn't compromise the clinical validity of the MBT as a valuable tool to identify hepatic impairment in general. As suggested by the simulation results shown in Fig. 8A, even at extreme variations in the individual short-term kinetics of systemic CO2/bicarbonate a reduction of the DOBmax to less than 50% should clearly indicate a severe impairment of the detoxifying capacity of liver. Moreover, as can be inferred from the clear monotone and quasi-linear relation between FHMC and DOBmax of an individual patient (see Fig. 8A) the conventional MBT is well suited for monitoring the development of liver function of individual patients , , , .
To better account for the influence of individual variations in systemic CO2/bicarbonate kinetics we propose a novel variant of the MBT that aims at improving the test's capability to assess the detoxifying capacity of the liver. Our approach enables to include the impact of systemic CO2/bicarbonate on the readout of the test, the time-course of exhaled 13CO2 (DOB). It has to be emphasized that the liver function parameter FHMC cannot be directed taken from the 2-biphasic DOB monitored in the proposed 2DOB test curve but requires the evaluation of this curve by means of the mathematical compartment model.
From the technical point of view, the proposed 2-step test requires higher effort caused by the additional injection of 13C-bicarbonate. On the other hand, the duration of the test could be shortened to 30 minutes (to be tested in a clinical trial). Our simulations suggest that monitoring the DOB curve over 15 minutes after injection of 13C-bicarbonate and another 15 minutes after injection of 13C-methacetin should be sufficient to gain all kinetic parameters needed for the estimation of the hepatic detoxification rate (FHMC).
As the 2DOB test required for a precise estimation of the new score FHMC has yet to be established and validated, we estimated values of FHMC from conventional DOB curves monitored in patients with different severity of liver function impairment. As these curves result from both hepatic 13CO2 formation and systemic 13CO2 distribution we had to approximate the kinetic parameters for the latter process by their mean values. Despite this necessary simplification, the FHMC enabled discrimination between different degrees of severity of liver impairment (Fig. 6) similar to existing methods. Therefore, the tailored determination of the individual FHMC based on the proposed 2DOB test variant and its normalization to basic whole-body measures like height or bodyweight (similar as in the definition of the LiMAX score) should give rise to a further significant improvement of the predictive power of the breath test.
The mathematical compartment model was chosen to balance physiological feasibility with the identification of valid model parameters. This compromise required some simplifications which, however, should be acceptable and without a significant influence on the obtained results. First, we assumed that the outflow of 13CO2 from the liver to the blood is fast enough to lump together this process and the formation inside the liver to one overall process. This assumption is supported by the finding that in isolated male rat livers perfused with erythrocyte-free solutions an equilibrium between extracellular CO2/bicarbonate and the liver was reached in about one minute . Second, we considered only a single compartment with which plasma CO2/bicarbonate may exchange. Accordingly, the plasma profile of 13CO2/13C-bicaronate is described by a sum of two exponential functions. Earlier studies of Barstow et al. ,  and Irving et al.  on the 13C-bicarbonate kinetics in humans have provided evidence that at least three different compartments with different characteristic time constants for the exchange kinetics have to be taken into account. However, over shorter time ranges of about 15–30 minutes considered in this study the error made by approximating the decline of plasma 13CO2/13C-bicabonate by only two exponentials remains sufficiently small. For time points larger than 30 minutes, the measured values of DOB and plasma 13C-methacetin showed larger deviations from the model simulations. In particular, at 60 minutes the residual level of plasma 13C-methacetin (being still of the order of 5% of the initial concentration) is higher than predicted by the model. We concluded that methacetin not only exchanges with the liver, but also with other body compartments. In an extended version of our compartment model including such a non-hepatic exchange of plasma methacetin we were able to describe the plasma 13C-methacetin profile by a sum of 3 exponentials with high accuracy. In this case, we obtained slightly lower values of the FHMC. Hence, the estimated FHMC values shown in Table 1 possibly overestimate the initial metabolization rate of the drug. Unfortunately, the extended compartment model accounting in a more detailed manner for the 13C-methacetin kinetics is not suited for the use in breath tests as the estimation of parameter values is not possible from the DOB curve alone but requires additionally measurements of the 13C-methacetin plasma profile. Third, we assumed in our simulations of the 2DOB method that 13C-bicarbonate and 13C-methaxcetione injected in a sequential manner contribute additively to the DOB value. This assumption is well justified since the endogenously produced 13CO2 is more than 10 times higher than the additionally formed 13CO2 from 13C-labeled bicarbonate or 13C-methacetin.
The validity of the proposed 2DOB approach was tested by computer simulations. The parameter values used in these simulations have been varied around physiologically meaningful values determined in 25 healthy patients. Thus, the simulation results possess a high degree of credibility. Considering the crucial role of the liver in the regulation of the acid/base-status of humans it cannot be excluded, however, that in patients with impaired liver function the individual deviations from normal CO2/bicarbonate exchange kinetics are larger than revealed by our analysis of liver-healthy subjects. Indeed, a clinical study with 200 cirrhotic patients showed a clear trend towards metabolic acidosis manifested by a negative base excess .
Finally, it has to be emphasized that the proposed method could potentially improve the diagnostic accuracy of all 13CO2-based breath tests.
Conceived and designed the experiments: JFL PT MS. Performed the experiments: JFL PT MS. Analyzed the data: HH SB AG. Wrote the paper: HH SB AG JFL PT MS. Model development: HH SB AG.
- 1. Braden B, Lembcke B, Kuker W, Caspary WF (2007) 13C-breath tests: current state of the art and future directions. Dig Liver Dis 39: 795–805. doi: 10.1016/j.dld.2007.06.012
- 2. Modak AS (2007) Stable isotope breath tests in clinical medicine: a review. J Breath Res 1: 014003. doi: 10.1088/1752-7155/1/1/014003
- 3. Graham DY, Klein PD, Evans DJ Jr, Evans DG, Alpert LC, et al. (1987) Campylobacter pylori detected noninvasively by the 13C-urea breath test. Lancet 1: 1174–1177. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(87)92145-3
- 4. Chowdhury RS, Forsmark CE (2003) Review article: Pancreatic function testing. Aliment Pharmacol Ther 17: 733–750. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2036.2003.01495.x
- 5. Irving CS, Schoeller DA, Nakamura KI, Baker AL, Klein PD (1982) The aminopyrine breath test as a measure of liver function. A quantitative description of its metabolic basis in normal subjects. J Lab Clin Med 100: 356–373.
- 6. Mion F, Queneau PE, Rousseau M, Brazier JL, Paliard P, et al. (1995) Aminopyrine breath test: development of a 13C-breath test for quantitative assessment of liver function in humans. Hepatogastroenterology 42: 931–938.
- 7. Giannini EG, Fasoli A, Borro P, Botta F, Malfatti F, et al. (2005) 13C-galactose breath test and 13C-aminopyrine breath test for the study of liver function in chronic liver disease. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol 3: 279–285. doi: 10.1016/s1542-3565(04)00720-7
- 8. Mion F, Rousseau M, Scoazec JY, Berger F, Minaire Y (1999) [13C]-Galactose breath test: correlation with liver fibrosis in chronic hepatitis C. Eur J Clin Invest 29: 624–629. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2362.1999.00512.x
- 9. Festi D, Capodicasa S, Sandri L, Colaiocco-Ferrante L, Staniscia T, et al. (2005) Measurement of hepatic functional mass by means of 13C-methacetin and 13C-phenylalanine breath tests in chronic liver disease: comparison with Child-Pugh score and serum bile acid levels. World J Gastroenterol 11: 142–148.
- 10. Braden B, Faust D, Sarrazin U, Zeuzem S, Dietrich CF, et al. (2005) 13C-methacetin breath test as liver function test in patients with chronic hepatitis C virus infection. Aliment Pharmacol Ther 21: 179–185. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2036.2005.02317.x
- 11. Ilan Y (2007) Review article: the assessment of liver function using breath tests. Aliment Pharmacol Ther 26: 1293–1302. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2036.2007.03519.x
- 12. Razlan H, Marzuki NM, Tai ML, Shamsul AS, Ong TZ, et al. (2011) Diagnostic value of the C methacetin breath test in various stages of chronic liver disease. Gastroenterol Res Pract 2011: 235796. doi: 10.1155/2011/235796
- 13. Schneider A, Caspary WF, Saich R, Dietrich CF, Sarrazin C, et al. (2007) 13C-methacetin breath test shortened: 2-point-measurements after 15 minutes reliably indicate the presence of liver cirrhosis. J Clin Gastroenterol 41: 33–37. doi: 10.1097/mcg.0b013e31802dd4b9
- 14. Stibbe KJ, Verveer C, Francke J, Hansen BE, Zondervan PE, et al. (2011) Comparison of non-invasive assessment to diagnose liver fibrosis in chronic hepatitis B and C patients. Scand J Gastroenterol 46: 962–972. doi: 10.3109/00365521.2011.574725
- 15. Stockmann M, Lock JF, Malinowski M, Niehues SM, Seehofer D, et al. (2010) The LiMAx test: a new liver function test for predicting postoperative outcome in liver surgery. HPB (Oxford) 12: 139–146. doi: 10.1111/j.1477-2574.2009.00151.x
- 16. Stockmann M, Lock JF, Riecke B, Heyne K, Martus P, et al. (2009) Prediction of postoperative outcome after hepatectomy with a new bedside test for maximal liver function capacity. Ann Surg 250: 119–125. doi: 10.1097/sla.0b013e3181ad85b5
- 17. Lock JF, Schwabauer E, Martus P, Videv N, Pratschke J, et al. (2010) Early diagnosis of primary nonfunction and indication for reoperation after liver transplantation. Liver Transpl 16: 172–180. doi: 10.1002/lt.21973
- 18. Stockmann M, Lock JF, Malinowski M, Seehofer D, Puhl G, et al. (2010) How to define initial poor graft function after liver transplantation? - a new functional definition by the LiMAx test. Transpl Int 23: 1023–1032. doi: 10.1111/j.1432-2277.2010.01089.x
- 19. Lock JF, Taheri P, Bauer S, Holzhutter HG, Malinowski M, et al. (2009) Interpretation of Non-Invasive Breath Tests Using 13C-labeled Substrates - A Preliminary Report With superset13 C-Methacetin. Eur J Med Res 14: 547–550. doi: 10.1186/2047-783x-14-12-547
- 20. Barstow TJ, Cooper DM, Epstein S, Wasserman K (1989) Changes in breath 13CO2/12CO2 consequent to exercise and hypoxia. J Appl Physiol 66: 936–942.
- 21. Barstow TJ, Cooper DM, Sobel EM, Landaw EM, Epstein S (1990) Influence of increased metabolic rate on [13C]bicarbonate washout kinetics. Am J Physiol 259: R163–171.
- 22. Irving CS, Wong WW, Shulman RJ, Smith EO, Klein PD (1983) [13C]bicarbonate kinetics in humans: intra- vs. interindividual variations. Am J Physiol 245: R190–202.
- 23. Yunoki T, Horiuchi M, Yano T (1999) Kinetics of excess CO2 output during and after intensive exercise. Jpn J Physiol 49: 139–144. doi: 10.2170/jjphysiol.49.139
- 24. Prescott LF (1980) Kinetics and metabolism of paracetamol and phenacetin. Br J Clin Pharmacol 10 Suppl 2: 291S–298S. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2125.1980.tb01812.x
- 25. Thornhill DP, Steffen C, Netter KJ (1984) A kinetic evaluation of 14CO2 in expired air after 14C-methacetin administration in rats, used for the in vivo study of the metabolism of drugs. Eur J Drug Metab Pharmacokinet 9: 161–168. doi: 10.1007/bf03189620
- 26. Feldschuh J, Enson Y (1977) Prediction of the normal blood volume. Relation of blood volume to body habitus. Circulation 56: 605–612. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.56.4.605
- 27. Afolabi P, Wright M, Wootton SA, Jackson AA (2013) Clinical utility of 13C-liver-function breath tests for assessment of hepatic function. Dig Dis Sci 58: 33–41. doi: 10.1007/s10620-012-2340-z
- 28. Kasicka-Jonderko A, Jonderko K (2013) Phase-1 evaluation of 13C-liver function breath tests. Dig Dis Sci 58: 579–581. doi: 10.1007/s10620-012-2529-1
- 29. Lipsen B, Effros RM (1988) CO2 and bicarbonate exchange in the rat liver. J Appl Physiol 65: 2736–2743.
- 30. Cucchetti A, Siniscalchi A, Ercolani G, Vivarelli M, Cescon M, et al. (2007) Modification of acid-base balance in cirrhotic patients undergoing liver resection for hepatocellular carcinoma. Ann Surg 245: 902–908. doi: 10.1097/01.sla.0000256356.23026.9f