Advertisement
Research Article

Characteristics of Opioid-Users Whose Death Was Related to Opioid-Toxicity: A Population-Based Study in Ontario, Canada

  • Parvaz Madadi mail,

    parvaz.madadi@gmail.com

    Affiliation: Division of Clinical Pharmacology and Toxicology, Department of Pediatrics, Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

    X
  • Doris Hildebrandt,

    Affiliation: The Office of the Chief Coroner of Ontario, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

    X
  • Albert E. Lauwers,

    Affiliation: The Office of the Chief Coroner of Ontario, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

    X
  • Gideon Koren

    Affiliation: Division of Clinical Pharmacology and Toxicology, Department of Pediatrics, Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

    X
  • Published: April 05, 2013
  • DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0060600

Abstract

Background

The impact of the prescription opioid public health crisis has been illustrated by the dramatic increase in opioid-related deaths in North America. We aimed to identify patterns and characteristics amongst opioid-users whose cause of death was related to opioid toxicity.

Methods

This was a population-based study of Ontarians between the years 2006 and 2008. All drug-related deaths which occurred during this time frame were reviewed at the Office of the Chief Coroner of Ontario, and opioid-related deaths were identified. Medical, toxicology, pathology, and police reports were comprehensively reviewed. Narratives, semi-quantitative, and quantitative variables were extracted, tabulated, and analyzed.

Results

Out of 2330 drug-related deaths in Ontario, 58% were attributed either in whole or in part, to opioids (n = 1359). Oxycodone was involved in approximately one-third of all opioid-related deaths. At least 7% of the entire cohort used opioids that were prescribed for friends and/or family, 19% inappropriately self-administered opioids (injection, inhalation, chewed patch), 3% were recently released from jail, and 5% had been switched from one opioid to another near the time of death. Accidental deaths were significantly associated with personal history of substance abuse, enrollment in methadone maintenance programs, cirrhosis, hepatitis, and cocaine use. Suicides were significantly associated with mental illness, previous suicide attempts, chronic pain, and a history of cancer.

Significance/Conclusion

These results identify novel, susceptible groups of opioid-users whose cause of death was related to opioids in Ontario and provide the first evidence to assist in quantifying the contribution of opioid misuse and diversion amongst opioid-related mortality in Canada. Multifaceted prevention strategies need to be developed based on subpopulations of opioid users.

Introduction

Non-medical use of prescription opioids has culminated in a public health crisis in many North American jurisdictions. The impact of this crisis has been powerfully illustrated by the dramatic increase in opioid-related deaths [1][6]: in 2008, prescription opioids were involved in 14,800 accidental deaths in the United States [4]. That there has been a parallel increase in the consumption of prescription opioids and deaths related to opioid drugs is not in dispute. Previous studies of Ontarians whose cause of death was related to opioids have deduced several relationships between opioid prescription practices and opioid-related deaths. Firstly, the introduction of long-acting oxycodone to the provincial formulary has been singled out as an important contributor to the increase in opioid-related morality in this province [2]. Secondly, regions/municipalities within the province with a high incidence of opioid-related deaths per capita have high opioid prescription utilization [7]. Thirdly, opioid-related deaths appear to be concentrated amongst patients treated by physicians who prescribed opioids more frequently [8], and high doses are significantly associated with an increase risk of mortality [9]. Such discoveries have subsequently shaped new provincial strategies to help curb and prevent this epidemic [10][12].

However, we need more individualized evidence and insight on how and why opioid-related deaths occur in order to develop holistic, inclusive, and multifaceted preventative strategies towards this issue. For example, indicators of opioid diversion and misuse amongst those whose cause of death was opioid-related in Canada has not been evaluated, despite data illustrating the enormity of these considerations in the United States [13], [14]. We aimed to identify patterns and characteristics amongst opioid-users whose cause of death was related to opioid toxicity in the province of Ontario between the years 2006 and 2008.

Methods

This study was approved by the Office of the Chief Coroner of Ontario and the Research Ethics Board of the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto, Canada. The Office of the Chief Coroner of Ontario conducts research in the public interest for the purpose of preventing future deaths and disseminates the findings of this research to the public on a regular basis. The authority to collect and analyze information about deaths in order to prevent future deaths in the public interest is provided in section 15(1) of the Ontario Coroners Act. The ability to conduct examinations and analysis appropriate in the circumstances is provided by section 28(2) of the Ontario Coroners Act. The Research Ethics Board of the Hospital for Sick Children granted a waiver of consent for next of kin in this research study based on the following three necessary conditions: 1) The objectives of the research cannot be reasonably accomplished without using personal health information, 2) There is a public interest in this research while protecting the privacy of individuals and 3) There are adequate safeguards to protect the privacy of individuals. It was also considered that given the subject group was deceased individuals, contacting the families would cause distress. The data collected in this study was coded and analyzed anonymously. No personal identifiers were collected.

Ontario is the most populous province in Canada with an estimated population of 12.69 million in 2006, rising to 12.93 million in 2008. Under the Ontario Coroners Act, all sudden and unexpected deaths, and/or deaths thought to be from any cause other than disease must be reported to the Coroner's Office from anywhere in the province of Ontario. The coroners' death investigations involve classification of the cause of death as well as the manner of death according to five categories: homicide, accident, suicide, natural, and undetermined. Particularly relevant to this study were the classification of accidental death (due to an occurrence, incident, or event that happens without foresight or expectation), suicide (an intentional act of omission or commission in a person knowing the probable consequence of what he/she is about to do), and undetermined [(a) there is no evidence for any specific classification; (b) there is equal evidence, or a significant contest, among two or more classifications, or (c) a death is a suicide that does not meet a high degree of probability].

The records of the Office of the Chief Coroner of Ontario were examined and all deaths coded as drug and alcohol-related between 2006 and 2008 were reviewed. From these files, all deaths in which opioids had been identified by the coroner were isolated. Medical, toxicological, pathological, and police reports compiled as part of the coroner's report were comprehensively reviewed. Narratives, semi-quantitative, and quantitative variables were extracted, tabulated, and analyzed. Indicators of opioid misuse and diversion were assessed amongst all opioid-related fatalities. A nonmedical route of drug administration was determined from coroner, police, and/or autopsy findings (i.e. death scene investigations, puncture sites on body, patch debris). Indicators of diversion were based solely on narratives found in coroner and police reports. These reports were informed by coroner and police analysis of prescription records, prescription bottles, interviews with family and friends, consultations with healthcare providers, and other circumstantial data gathered as part of the death investigation.

In addition, factors which have been validated for predicting risk of opioid misuse or addiction in patients were assessed in this cohort. In particular, data on gender, age, psychological disease, and personal history of substance abuse as reported in the Opioid Risk Tool (ORT) [15] were evaluated. Descriptive statistics (mean, standard deviation, median, minimum, and maximum) were calculated. Pearson's Chi-square, Fischer Exact, Student T-test, and Mann-Whitney U test were used as appropriate.

Results

In Ontario, there were 2330 individuals whose cause of death was deemed to be drug-related between 2006 and 2008. Opioids were implicated in 58% (n = 1359) of these cases. Individuals whose cause of death was opioid-related were significantly younger, were disproportionately male, and their manner of death was significantly more likely to be deemed accidental (Table 1). Conversely, when the deaths were due to drug toxicity but were non-opioid related, a significantly higher proportion of suicidal overdoses were observed (Table 1). Oxycodone (35%) was involved in approximately one-third of all opioid-related deaths, followed by morphine (28%) and methadone (15%) (Table 2). Oxycodone was also associated with the highest proportion of both accidental deaths and suicides. However, when analyzing the proportion of the types of deaths (accident, undetermined or suicide) within each opioid type, methadone had the highest relative percentage of deaths which were accidental (84%), while codeine had the lowest proportion of accidental deaths (32%) (Figure 1).

thumbnail

Figure 1. Manner of death per opioid type.

This graph illustrates the relative proportion of accidental, suicide, or undetermined manners of death per opioid type. The graph represents all single opioid-related deaths in Ontario, Canada between the years 2006 and 2008 (n = 1040 decedents).

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0060600.g001
thumbnail

Table 1. Comparison of demographic characteristics between opioid-related mortalities and non-opioid drug related mortalities in Ontario for the years 2006, 2007, and 2008.

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0060600.t001
thumbnail

Table 2. Opioid-related deaths in Ontario between the years 2006 and 2008, by type of opioid.

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0060600.t002

Opioid self-administration by inappropriate route of injection, inhalation, or patch ingestion was identified in 19% of all individuals (Table 3). Prior to death, 101 individuals (7.4%) had used opioid medications which were diverted and had belonged to their partners, family members or friends (Table 3). Signals of double-doctoring, purchasing opioids from a street source, and of health workers diverting opioids for personal use were detected in 2.1%, 2%, and 0.6% of all cases, respectively (Table 3).

thumbnail

Table 3. Indicators of diversion and opioid misuse amongst opioid-related deaths in Ontario (n = 1353).

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0060600.t003

Prior to death, 50 individuals (3.7%) had been switched to a more potent opioid medication (Table 4); an additional 9 individuals had received opioids for acute pain while in methadone programs and another 7 had their methadone dose adjusted prior to the fatality. Further analysis was performed to identify factors specifically associated with accidental versus suicidal overdose with opioids. Individuals whose manner of death was accidental were younger and were more likely to have a history of substance abuse as compared to those committing suicide (Table 4). These individuals were significantly more likely to be enrolled in methadone programs and had a higher incidence of cirrhosis, hepatitis, and cocaine use prior to death (Table 4). In 242 accidental deaths, the deceased had contact with a healthcare worker (physician or pharmacist) less than 5 days before death (Table 4). Individuals who committed suicide were significantly more likely to have received a larger number of medications, to have had previous suicide attempts, depression and/or other psychiatric morbidities, and to have had a history of cancer and chronic pain (Table 4).

thumbnail

Table 4. Health characteristics amongst Ontarians whose cause of death was related to opioids; compared by manner of death.

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0060600.t004

There were 46 individuals (~3% of opioid-related deaths between 2006 and 2008) whose death was temporally related to custody or release from a correctional facility (Table 5). Over 90% of these deaths were accidental, 20% occurred while the individual was in custody, and a further 43% occurred within 7 days of release from jail (Table 5). Forty percent of these individuals were found to have injected opioids, and cocaine was detected in 65% of these cases (Table 5).

thumbnail

Table 5. Opioid-related deaths in Ontario which were temporally associated with release from a correctional institution or under custody (n = 46).

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0060600.t005

Discussion

Amongst all deaths in Ontario that were due to drug intoxication/overdose, a far greater proportion of accidental deaths were identified when opioids were involved. Conversely, in non-opioid related deaths, a significantly higher proportion of suicide was observed. This demonstrates the potential role that opioids play in the genesis of accidental deaths, where unforgiving margins of prescribing or ingesting errors can be lethal and necessitate great caution on the part of prescribers and users.

Oxycodone was involved in approximately one third of opioid-related deaths. This drug has been associated with the rising number of opioid deaths in the province of Ontario [2], [11]. In parallel however, there have also been dramatic increases in the use of fentanyl, hydromorphone, and methadone in Canada over the same time frame [16][18]. When we evaluated the manner of death based on opioid type, a high proportion of accidental deaths occurred amongst methadone, hydromorphone, and fentanyl users. This and other data [19][21] suggests that a range of prescription-opioids constitute this public health crisis, particularly as more individuals are enrolled in treatment programs for prescription-opioid addiction [22][24], or are switched from oxycodone to other potent opioids.

One in five individuals whose cause of death was related to opioids utilized an inappropriate route of drug administration such as injection, inhalation, or chewing pills or patches. Diversion occurred in 7.4% of the deaths, including 8 cases in which healthcare workers diverted opioids for their personal use. Opioids were known to be purchased from the street in approximately 2% of opioid-related deaths, however identifying the root source of diverted opioids beyond what can be gleaned from interviews, witnesses, and the immediate death scene investigations is limited in coroner-led investigations. Notwithstanding, these figures assist with quantifying the contribution of opioid abuse and illicit opioid diversion to mortality in Ontario, and buttresses arguments that support greater utilization of drug monitoring and other surveillance systems [25] directed at promoting appropriate use while discouraging abuse and diversion.

Switching to a more potent opioid, adding an opioid to someone taking methadone, or adjusting a methadone dosage, was associated with accidental opioid-related deaths. These are practices which present healthcare providers with unique and potentially lethal outcomes if not done with great caution. Enlisting the aid of collaborative expertise such as pharmacists, pharmacologists or addiction medicine consultants might assist practitioners faced with these situations. Recent data suggests that approximately 18% of individuals in the methadone program in Ontario received at least one prescription for non-methadone opioids [26].

The Opioid Risk Tool (ORT) was applied posthumously for a limited number of parameters including personal history of substance abuse, age, and mental illness. A personal history of substance abuse, particularly illicit or prescription drugs, and a younger age were more likely to be associated with accidental overdose. For suicidal deaths, depression and mental illness were strongly correlated with deliberate overdose. In addition, a history of previous suicide attempts was known in one-third of those who committed suicide with opioids (versus just 4% of those whose manner of death was accidental). Yet the ORT is specifically designed to assess the risk for opioid abuse or addiction. While there may be an overlap between predictors for opioid abuse or addiction and predictors for opioid-related death, the sheer magnitude of individuals who succumb to opioid-related toxicity necessitates the need to identify individuals at risk specifically for opioid overdose. Such an assessment should consider a specific question directed at whether the potential recipient of an opioid prescription has ever attempted suicide in the past.

Opioid-related deaths occurred while individuals were incarcerated and/or shortly after release. Almost all of these deaths were accidental, and 43% occurred within one week of release. In addition, 39% utilized injection as the preferred administration route, and 65% had evidence of cocaine or its metabolites present. A high rate of acute drug-related mortality amongst prison populations in the immediate post-release period has been described in other settings [27][29]. A contributing factor is decreased tolerance during incarceration. Upon release, individuals may utilize previous doses based on their beliefs regarding their own tolerance. Almost 90% of post-release substance abuse deaths in Australia, England and Wales, and Switzerland involved opioids [27]. Our findings point to the need for opioid substitution treatment interventions during incarceration and a coordinated effort between prison and public health systems to provide education to inmates on these issues.

Our current analysis is limited by several factors. All data in this study were obtained from coroners' reports, but there is variability among coroners in how death investigations are conducted across the province. Furthermore, toxicology testing in Ontario for coroners' cases is not standardized and depends on the individual scientists in charge of the case, the history of drug use as collected by the coroner, and the volume and type of samples available. The drug fentanyl, for example, was not part of the regular toxicology screen at the time of these fatalities and needed to be specifically requested [30]. Thus, certain drugs may be underrepresented in our study cohort based on these differences. Finally, we did not include an in-depth assessment of drug-interactions associated with this study cohort. Drug interactions and an examination of genetic mechanisms which may predispose certain individuals to these fatalities will be the subject of a subsequent investigation by our team.

It is evident that opioid-related mortality is associated not only with high risk prescribing, but also with personal characteristics of individuals who receive or use this class of drugs. Previous studies which illustrate the short-term safety and efficacy of prescription opioids excluded patients with substance abuse disorders [31]; but in this present population-based study, there was an overrepresentation of individuals with a history of drug abuse. In particular, one in five decedents had self-administered opioids inappropriately. We also identified other vulnerable Ontarians including those involved in the correctional system, those with previous history of suicide, those whose doctors had recently switched their opioid medication, and those involved in a methadone program. Our multifaceted findings point to the need for diverse prevention strategies to be developed based on subpopulations of opioid users.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to thank Dr. Karen Woodall and Ms. Patricia Solbeck from the Ontario Centre of Forensic Sciences for toxicology consultation, and Dr. David Chiasson from the Hospital for Sick Children for pathology consultation.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: PM GK. Performed the experiments: PM. Analyzed the data: PM. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: DH AL. Wrote the paper: PM. Data interpretation: PM GK DH AL. Critically revised the manuscript for intellectual content: AL DH GK.

References

  1. 1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2012) CDC grand rounds: prescription drug overdoses - a U.S. epidemic. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 61: 10–3.
  2. 2. Dhalla IA, Mamdani MM, Sivilotti ML, Kopp A, Qureshi O, et al. (2009) Prescribing of opioid analgesics and related mortality before and after the introduction of long-acting oxycodone. CMAJ 181: 891–6. doi: 10.1503/cmaj.090784
  3. 3. Warner M, Chen LH, Makuc DM (2009) Increase in fatal poisonings involving opioid analgesics in the United States, 1999–2006. NCHS Data Brief 22: 1–8.
  4. 4. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2011) Vital signs:overdoses of prescription opioid pain relievers---United States, 1999--2008. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 60: 1487–92.
  5. 5. Kuehn BM (2010) Safety plan for opioids meets resistance: opioid-linked deaths continue to soar. JAMA 303: 495–7. doi: 10.1001/jama.2010.71
  6. 6. Fischer B, Rehm J (2009) Deaths related to the use of prescription opioids. CMAJ 181: 881–2. doi: 10.1503/cmaj.091791
  7. 7. Gomes T, Juurlink D, Moineddin R, Gozdyra P, Dhalla I, et al. (2011) Geographical variation in opioid prescribing and opioid-related mortality in Ontario. Healthc Q 14: 22–4. doi: 10.12927/hcq.2011.22153
  8. 8. Dhalla IA, Mamdani MM, Gomes T, Juurlink DN (2011) Clustering of opioid prescribing and opioid-related mortality among family physicians in Ontario. Can Fam Physician 57: e92–6. doi: 10.12927/hcq.2011.22153
  9. 9. Gomes T, Mamdani MM, Dhalla IA, Paterson JM, Juurlink DN (2011) Opioid dose and drug-related mortality in patients with nonmalignant pain. Arch Intern Med 171: 686–91. doi: 10.1001/archinternmed.2011.117
  10. 10. College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario. Avoiding abuse, achieving a balance: Tackling the opioid public health crisis. http://www.cpso.on.ca/uploadedFiles/poli​cies/positions/Opioid%20report%20final.p​df Accessed October 9, 2012.
  11. 11. Fischer B, Keates A (2012) ‘Opioid Drought', Canadian-style? Potential implications of the ‘natural experiment' of delisting Oxycontin in Canada. Int J Drug Policy 23: 495–7. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2012.07.008
  12. 12. Dhalla IA, Persaud N, Juurlink DN (2011) Facing up to the prescription opioid crisis. BMJ 343: d5142. doi: 10.1136/bmj.d5142
  13. 13. Hall AJ, Logan JE, Toblin RL, Kaplan JA, Kraner JC, et al. (2008) Patterns of abuse among unintentional pharmaceutical overdose fatalities. JAMA 300: 2613–20. doi: 10.1001/jama.2008.802
  14. 14. Volkow ND, McLellan TA (2011) Curtailing diversion and abuse of opioid analgesics without jeopardizing pain treatment. JAMA 305: 1346–7. doi: 10.1001/jama.2011.369
  15. 15. Webster LR, Webster RM (2005) Predicting aberrant behaviors in opioid-treated patients: preliminary validation of the Opioid Risk Tool. Pain Med 6: 432–42. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4637.2005.00072.x
  16. 16. Pain & Policy Studies Group, University of Wisconsin/WHO Collaborating Center (2012) Mg/capita consumption of fentanyl, Canada. 1980–2010. http://www.painpolicy.wisc.edu/sites/www​.painpolicy.wisc.edu/files/country_files​/fentanyl/canadafentanyl.pdf Accessed October 9, 2012.
  17. 17. Pain & Policy Studies Group, University of Wisconsin/WHO Collaborating Center (2012) Mg/capita consumption of hydromorphone, Canada. 1980–2010. http://www.painpolicy.wisc.edu/sites/www​.painpolicy.wisc.edu/files/country_files​/hydromorphone/canadahydromorphone.pdf Accessed October 9, 2012.
  18. 18. Pain & Policy Studies Group, University of Wisconsin/WHO Collaborating Center (2012) Mg/capita consumption of methadone, Canada. 1980–2010. http://www.painpolicy.wisc.edu/sites/www​.painpolicy.wisc.edu/files/country_files​/methadone/canadamethadone.pdf Accessed October 9, 2012.
  19. 19. Martin TL, Woodall KL, McLellan BA (2006) Fentanyl-related deaths in Ontario, Canada: toxicological findings and circumstances of death in 112 cases (2002–2004). J Anal Toxicol 30: 603–10. doi: 10.1093/jat/30.8.603
  20. 20. Paulozzi LJ, Kilbourne EM, Shah NG, Nolte KB, Desai HA, et al. (2012) A history of being prescribed controlled substances and risk of drug overdose death. Pain Med 13: 87–95. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4637.2011.01260.x
  21. 21. Gomes T, Juurlink DN, Dhalla IA, Mailis-Gagnon A, Paterson JM, et al. (2011) Trends in opioid use and dosing among socio-economically disadvantaged patients. Open Med 5: e13–22.
  22. 22. Fischer B, Nakamura N, Ialomiteanu A, Boak A, Rehm J (2010) Assessing the prevalence of nonmedical prescription opioid use in the general Canadian population: methodological issues and questions. Can J Psychiatry 55: 606–9.
  23. 23. Webster PC (2012) Medically induced opioid addiction reaching alarming levels. CMAJ 184: 285–6. doi: 10.1503/cmaj.109-4088
  24. 24. Sproule B, Brands B, Li S, Catz-Biro L (2009) Changing patterns in opioid addiction: characterizing users of oxycodone and other opioids. Can Fam Physician55: :68–9, 69.e1-5.
  25. 25. Minister of Health and Long-Term Care (2010). Bill 101, Narcotics Safety and Awareness Act http://www.ontla.on.ca/web/bills/bills_d​etail.do?locale=en&Intranet=&BillID=2395 Accessed October 9, 2012.
  26. 26. Kurdyak P, Gomes T, Yao Z, Mamdani MM, Hellings C, et al. (2012) Use of other opioids during methadone therapy: a population-based study. Addiction 107: 776–80. doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2011.03707.x
  27. 27. World Health Organization (2010). WHO Regional office for Europe. Prevention of acute drug-related mortality in prison populations during the immediate post-release period. http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pd​f_file/0020/114914/E93993.pdf Accessed October 5, 2012.
  28. 28. Binswanger IA, Stern MF, Deyo RA, Heagerty PJ, Cheadle A, et al. (2007) Release from prison--a high risk of death for former inmates. N Engl J Med 356: 157–65. doi: 10.1056/nejmsa064115
  29. 29. Rich JD, Wakeman SE, Dickman SL (2011) Medicine and the epidemic of incarceration in the United States. N Engl J Med 364: 2081–3. doi: 10.1056/nejmp1102385
  30. 30. Woodall KL, Martin TL, McLellan BA (2008) Oral abuse of fentanyl patches (Duragesic): seven case reports. J Forensic Sci 53: 222–5. doi: 10.1111/j.1556-4029.2007.00597.x
  31. 31. Noble M, Treadwell JR, Tregear SJ, Coates VH, Wiffen PJ, et al. (2010) Long-term opioid management for chronic noncancer pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 20: CD006605. doi: 10.1002/14651858.cd006605.pub2