Citation: Maulucci G, Papi M, Arcovito G, De Spirito M (2011) The Thermal Structural Transition of α-Crystallin Inhibits the Heat Induced Self-Aggregation. PLoS ONE 6(5):
e18906.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0018906
Editor: Laurent Kreplak, Dalhousie University, Canada
Received: October 7, 2010; Accepted: March 23, 2011; Published: May 9, 2011
Copyright: © 2011 Maulucci et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The authors have no support or funding to report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Cataract, the opacity of the eye lens, is an age-onset pathology that affects nearly 50
of the world's population over the age of 65, and is the leading cause of blindness worldwide [1]. Pathological studies of cataractous lenses have revealed that cataracts are composed of protein aggregates that precipitate in eye lens cells. The prevalent proteins within the eye lens are the crystallins. Lens transparency is thought to be maintained by a liquid-like, short range order present in highly concentrated solutions of these proteins [2], [3]. In mammals, there are three classes of crystallins denoted 
, 
, and 
of which 
-crystallin is the most abundant. 
-crystallin is an oligomeric protein, having a molecular mass of about 
, composed of two types of subunits, 
A and 
B crystallins, each having a molecular mass of about 
and 
A crystallins in a ratio of 3 to 1 with respect to 
B [4]. The increase in light scattering in old and cataractous lenses can be ascribed to alterations in lens crystallins interactions due to age related post-translational modification of 
-crystallin [5]–[8]. The alterations are triggered by lens cells exposition to elevated temperatures or other stress factors like 
ions, that disrupt the liquid-like molecular order and promote the formation of large scattering particles [9], [10], following pathways that include both changes in the secondary structure and in the state of assembly [11], [12].
To monitor the heat and 
induced changes that occur in the structural domain of lens-crystallin different techniques like circular dichroism, fluorescence, Small Angle X-Ray scattering (SAXS) were used [13], [14]. Differential scanning calorimetric studies on 
-crystallin [14] show two endothermic transitions, a first ranging from 
to 
, peaked at 
and a second major transition peaked at 
. The transition at 
has been found to be biologically relevant [15]. At this temperature, 
-crystallin undergoes a minor change in its tertiary structure accompanying the exposure of its hydrophobic surfaces [16], [17], whereas its secondary structure is relatively unchanged.
Here we focused on the effects of this structural transition on the 
-crystallin self-aggregation. Several aggregations have been induced by changing temperature, and therefore, by generating different heat-modified 
-crystallin forms [18]. At temperature larger than 
the kinetic pattern of the 
-crystallin aggregation and the structural features of the clusters can be described according to the reaction limited cluster-cluster aggregation theory (RLCA) [19]. Aggregation occurs by initially forming the basic aggregation units, the high molecular weight forms of 
-crystallin (HMW) [20], that successively continue to diffuse, collide and form rather compact fractal aggregates (
). Although the final morphology of the aggregates is similar, the aggregation kinetics are completely different below and above 
, together with the size of the HMW, and their repulsive energy barrier (
). An abrupt increase in (
) reveals a mechanism that markedly protects from aggregation preserving the transparency of the lens.
Materials and Methods
Dynamic light scattering
Dynamic light scattering (DLS) (24) provides information on the aggregation kinetics and on the clusters dimension and evolution as the aggregation proceeds. DLS measurements were performed during aggregation by using a commercial computer-interfaced scattering instruments ALV/SLS-5000 system from ALV, Langen, Germany, equipped with a 
HeNe laser operating at 632.8 nm. The beam was focused to a spot (at 
) of 
and the detection of the scattered light was carried out with a mono-mode fiber coupled to a photomultiplier, both mounted on a stepping motor-controlled rotating arm. The sample was contained in a cylindrical cell (
inner diameter) immersed in a toluene-filled index-matching vat whose temperature was controlled with a resolution of 
. In this instrument, the usable wavevector range varies from 
to 
. The autocorrelation function of the photopulses were performed by a 256-channel digital correlator (ALV-5000). Counts per second were used to measure the scattered intensity during the aggregation. DLS technique measures the intensity autocorrelation function 
where 
is the lag time and brackets represent the ensemble average [22]. The 
can be related to the field autocorrelation function 
through the Siegert relation 
where 
is an instrumental constant (in our set-up 
). The mathematical form of 
depends on the physical properties of the investigated system. For monodisperse particles, the electric field autocorrelation function decays exponentially following 
,where the decay rate 
depends on the particle translational diffusion coefficient according to 
. For a polydisperse sample, 
is more complex than a single exponential. In this condition, the derivative of 
measures the intensity weighted average decay rate of the clusters:
(1)
To determine 
experimentally, we fitted the logarithm of the measured autocorrelation function 
, to a second-order polynomial, according to the cumulant expansion [23]:
(2)
Where we assumed 
. In aggregating systems, because of cluster-mass polydispersity, what we actually measure is an average effective diffusion coefficient that can be expressed as:
(3)where 
is the normalized intensity-weighted radius distribution function describing the distribution of the fraction of the intensity scattered by a particle of hydrodynamic radius 
and decay rate 
, given by:
(4)where 
is the water viscosity and 
the Boltzmann constant. The intensity weighted average effective hydrodynamic radius 
can be obtained using Stokes-Einstein Relation
(5)
The complete distribution of decay rates can also be recovered by introducing from the relation [22], [24]:
(6)
The recovery of the 
distribution, a classical ill posed problem, can be obtained by performing a regularized Laplace inversion of the intensity autocorrelation function using the software CONTIN [25]. In the presence of highly polydisperse fractal clusters, we also have to account for the volume and for the inner structure of clusters, therefore we need a complete recovery of the normalized number-weighted radius distribution function 
[24]:
(7)where 
is the mass of a cluster of hydrodynamic radius 
and 
is the scattering form factor of the particle. Finally once 
is known, the mean hydrodynamic radius can be easily determined by:
(8)
Reaction limited cluster aggregation
A key to the understanding of proteins aggregation is the behavior of the energy of interaction between two approaching particles. It has been demonstrated that for a wide variety of proteins, this can be understood within the Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) model [26]. The key parameter is the repulsive energy barrier between two approaching particles. If the height of this energy barrier 
is sufficiently large compared to 
, the particles will be unable to stick to one another when their diffusive motion causes them to collide, and the particle will be stable against aggregation. If 
is reduced to much less than 
, every collision will result in the particles sticking together, leading to very rapid aggregation, limited only by the rate of diffusion induced collisions between the clusters. This regime is therefore called diffusion-limited colloid aggregation (DLCA) [27]–[29]. For DLCA, computer simulation and several different experimental techniques show that clusters, characterized by a typical fractal dimension 
, are essentially monodisperse in that their mass distribution is bell shaped and peaked around an average mass value, which grows linearly with time. By contrast, if 
remains comparable to, or larger than, 
, many collisions must occur before two particles can stick to one another. In this case, the aggregation rate is limited by the probability of overcoming the repulsive barrier 
(sticking probability), leading to much slower aggregation. In this regime, called reaction limited aggregation (RLCA) [30]–[32], clusters have a structure more dense than in the DLCA, and with the typical 
. In each case, however, as particles stick together to become clusters, the clusters themselves continue to diffuse, collide, and aggregate. Each of these two regimes is characterized by a different time evolution of the average cluster mass, 
, of the shape of cluster-mass distribution function, and of the fractal dimension of the resulting clusters. In RLCA regime the average cluster radius is an exponential function of time [19], [30], [33]:
(9)where 
is the basic aggregation units and the aggregation rate 
is a constant that depends on the sticking probability and therefore on the repulsive energy barrier [30], [34]:
(10)
Clusters formed in the RLCA regime show an extremely high mass polydispersity, described by a power law, up to a cutoff mass 
, after which it decreases exponentially following:
(11)where 
is a characteristic exponent (i.e 
in RLCA) [30]–[32]. The DLCA and RLCA regimes must be considered universal in that their features do not depend on the nature of interacting forces between particles. Spectroscopic and microscopy techniques usually detect the normalized number-weighted radius distribution function, 
, instead of the cluster-mass distribution function, 
. For a direct comparison of the theoretical predictions with experimental results, we here developed the relation between these two distributions. To this end let us to recall that by definition, 
, where 
is the number of clusters of radius 
and 
is the total number of clusters (
). Since 
, for fractal clusters we obtain 
. In the case of RLCA aggregation we obtain:
(12)where 
is the cut-off radius of clusters with a mass 
.
Results
To characterize the extent of the aggregation process, we performed dynamic light scattering experiments by measuring the time evolution of the intensity weighted average hydrodynamic radius of the clusters, 
, determined according to Eq.2, Eq.3, and Eq.5. The results for samples at different temperatures above 
are reported in Fig. 1.
After an initial, fast, increase of 
a second, slower, exponential growth, is observed.
The first increase of 
is ascribed to the initial conversion of the protein from the native to the heat- and calcium-induced conformers that rapidly bind to form high molecular weight species (HMW) [19]. The second exponential growth, already investigated in detail [19], is consistent with an RLCA process where HMWs, of radius 
, after a large number of collisions can stick together. The time at which appears the crossing between these two steps it is called 
.
Fits of Eq.9 to experimental data allow to recover 
, 
for each aggregation process (Table 1). The value of 
is determined as the 
value where 
.
All the aggregations, carried out at different temperatures, show the same behavior. The initially formed basic aggregation units aggregate forming fractal clusters, accordingly to an RLCA process characterized by a temperature dependent rate constant (i.e. higher is the temperature faster is the aggregation rate). The size of basic aggregation units,instead, is independent on temperature with an average value of 
.
By decreasing temperature below 
the time evolution of the aggregation process undergoes to a dramatic modification (Fig. 2) and the fitting equation used is slightly modified according to the expression 
. Basic aggregation units are formed over a longer time and their average size is smaller (
) (Tab.1). At times larger than 
an exponential increase of the hydrodynamic radius, 
, is still observed. In order to verify if aggregations below 
, although different with respect to those observed at 
, are still consistent with an RLCA process, we investigate the shape of the cluster-number distribution (
) that can be recovered directly from the intensity autocorrelation function [24], [33]. In Fig. 3 we report representative distributions of 
taken at different times during the aggregation occurred at 
. Number weighted radius distributions shift toward higher values with time, and, more relevant, all distributions appear broad and highly asymmetric. Fits of Eq.12 to experimental data evidence that, in agreement with the RLCA aggregation theory, the 
is well described by a power law up to the cut-off radius, 
, after which it becomes an exponential distribution. Contextually, the fractal dimension does not vary as aggregation proceeds, keeping an average value of 
. This peculiar behavior imply an universal scaling of the number distribution, i.e. 
depends only on the cut-off radius 
that increases exponentially with time as 
(see inset of Fig. 3) [30], while is independent on the detailed nature of the aggregating particle. In Fig. 4 we report the whole aggregate's size distribution, recovered from aggregations occurred at two different temperatures, below (full dots) and above 
(open diamonds), when the average radius reach a specific value (
). The overlap of the aggregates' size distribution curves before and after the structural transition is a further evidence that the shape of aggregates' size distribution is independent on the size of the aggregating particle (which has different dimension above and below 
) as expected for RLCA aggregations [30].
Therefore above and below 
the aggregations are well characterized in the framework of RLCA theory: the final morphology of the aggregates is similar, but the aggregation kinetics are completely different.
A closer look of Tab.1, indeed, evidences that the aggregation rate 
depends on 
both above and below 
, with an abrupt change across 
. This jump of the 
value is a consequence of the phase transition [35] and it can be easily visualized in Fig. 5 where the logarithm of 
against the inverse temperature is reported. In this plot two different behaviors of 
can be identified above and below 
(the 1/
value is indicated by a dashed line). Fit of eq.10 to experimental data allows to recover two distinct energy barriers for the aggregation process: 
Kcal/mol and 
Kcal/mol (below and above 
respectively). The rate of formation of HMWs (
), estimated as 
[36], reveals, instead, a single Arrhenius behavior along all the temperature range investigated (inset Fig. 5) showing that the rate of formation of intermediate aggregation units is independent on the alpha-crystallin phase transition.
Discussion
-crystallin is the most abundant lens protein of the mammalian eye, and its aggregates are the main scattering elements strongly involved in the process of cataractogenesis. The increase in light scattering in old and cataractous lenses can be ascribed to alterations in lens crystallins interactions due to age related post-translational modification of 
-crystallin [5]–[8]. The alterations are triggered by lens cells exposition to elevated temperatures or other stress factors like 
ions, that disrupts the liquid-like molecular order and promote the formation of large scattering particles [9], [10].
Supramolecular structure of crystallins substantially varies both in lenses of different vertebrate species and in various parts of the same lens [37], therefore the understanding of the aggregation mechanism and the fractal clustering could be an important tool to characterize lens ageing and crystallin function.
Here we monitor changes in the 
-crystallin's aggregation process induced by the thermal structural transition (
).
At all the temperatures investigated supramolecular aggregation of 
-crystallin could be described according to the reaction limited cluster-cluster aggregation theory. Aggregation of the 
and heat-modified proteins occurs initially by rapidly forming the first clusters or basic aggregating units, corresponding to HMW [20], [38]. After that clusters themselves continue to diffuse, collide, and aggregate. As the aggregation proceeds, clusters with different masses are formed and stick each other. The average cluster size of aggregating HMWs increases exponentially in time and their fractal dimension 
indicates that aggregates sample all the possible mutual configurations before they stick together.
The radius of the HMW is 
, and 
, below and above 
, respectively. This difference highlights a substantial alteration in the packing of 
-crystallin subunits. Accordingly, HMW molecular weight increases 
times and HMW concentration decreases by the same factor. A lower HMW concentration reduces the probability of collision decreasing the rate of formation of aggregates. Nevertheless, modifications in subunit's packaging do not affects the kinetic of formation of the HMWs (see inset of Fig. 5).
The aggregation rate, instead, undergoes to an overall abrupt change when crossing 
. Above 
, the energy barrier that must be crossed to create larger particles is 
higher than below 
. Accordingly, the probability that an activated state occurs along the aggregation process results 
times lower than above 
. Therefore, the formation of large scattering particles in old and cataractous lenses is inhibited at high temperature by the structural transition that occurs at 
. As already pointed out, there is an effective inhibition only of the aggregation step: the rate of aggregation of HMW changes steeply at 
, whereas the rate of formation of HMW is unmodified at 
.
Therefore, the change in tertiary structure occurring at the endothermic phase transition at 
[16], [17], triggers a major reorganization of 
-crystallin subunits in the HMWs. A smaller number of more stable HMW particlesis formed, and accordingly the aggregation is inhibited.
Lens crystallin is particularly recessive to deleterious effects from elecromagnetic radiations that are known to be a potential risk factor for cataract and other eyes diseases. Indeed, its aqueous content favors radiation absorption and the very weak vascularization makes difficult to stand fast temperature increases [39].
In this context, the natural self-protective mechanism that we report preserves the lens from premature opacification throughout the lifespan of the organism [40], abruptly reducing the formation of aggregates in the lens fiber cells under hyperthermic conditions, such as those determined by extended exposure to microwaves or other electromagnetic radiation emitted by cell and cordless phones, wireless communications, monitors and even high voltage lines [41]–[45].
Acknowledgments
Experimental data reported in this paper were obtained at the LABCEMI (Laboratorio Centralizzato di Microscopia, Ottica ed Elettronica) of the Universitá Cattolica del S.Cuore di Roma (Italy) (http://www.rm.unicatt.it/).
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: GM MDS. Performed the experiments: GM MP. Analyzed the data: GM MP GA MDS. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: GM MP GA MDS. Wrote the paper: GM MDS.
References
- 1.
Clark J, Muchowski P (2000) Small heat-shock proteins and their potential role in human disease. CurrOpinStructBiol 10: 52–59.
- 2.
Delaye M, Tardieu A (1983) Short-range order of crystallin proteins accounts for eye lens transparency. Nature 302: 415–417.
- 3.
Xia J, Aerts T, Donceel K, Clauwaert J (1994) Light scattering by bovine alpha-crystalline proteins in solution: hydrodynamic structure and interparticle interaction. Biophys Journ 66: 861–872.
- 4.
Horwitz J (2003) Alpha-crystallin. Exp eye res 76: 145–153.
- 5.
Garland D, Duglas-Tabor Y, Jimenez-Asensio J, Datiles M, Magno B (1996) The nucleus of the human lens: demonstration of a highly characteristic protein pattern by two-dimensional electrophoresis and introduction of a new method of lens dissection. ExpEye Res 62: 285–291.
- 6.
Santini S, Mordente A, Meucci E, Miggiano G, Martorana G (1992) Conformational stability of bovine alpha-crystallin. evidence for destabilizing effect of ascorbate. BiochemJ 287: 107–112.
- 7.
Luthra M, Balasubramanian D (1993) Nonenzymatic glycation alters protein structure and stability. a study of two eye lens crystallins. JBiolChem 268: 18119–18127.
- 8.
Miesbauer LR, Zhou X, Yang Z, Yang Z, Sun Y, et al. (1994) Post-translational modifications of water-soluble human lens crystallins from young adults. JBiolChem 269: 12494–12502.
- 9.
Jedziniak JA, Kinoshita JH, Yates E, Hocker L, Benedek GB (1972) Calcium-induced aggregation of bovine lens alpha crystallins. Invest Ophthalmol 11: 905–915.
- 10.
Guptasarma P, Balasubramanian D, Matsugo S, Saito I (1992) Hydroxyl radical damage to proteins, with special reference to the crystallins. Biochemistry 31: 4296–4303.
- 11.
Doss-Pepe E, Carew E, Koretz J (1998) Studies of the denaturation pattern of bovine alpha-crystallin using an ionic denaturant, guanidine hydrocloride and a non-ionic denaturant, urea. Exp Eye Res 67: 657–679.
- 12.
Putilina T, Skouri-Panet F, Prat K, Lubsen N, Tardieu A (2003) Subunit exchange demonstrates a differential chaperone activity of calf-alpha crystallin towards beta-low- and individual gamma crystallins. JBC 278: 13747–13756.
- 13.
Tardieu A, Laporte D, Licinio P, Krop B, Delaye M (1986) Calf lens alpha-crystalline quaternary structure. Journ Molec Biol 192: 711–724.
- 14.
Walsh M, Sen A, Chakrabarti B (1991) Micellar subunit assembly in a three-layer model of oligomeric alpha-crystallin. Journ Biol Chem 266: 20079–20084.
- 15.
Raman B, Rao C (1997) Chaperone-like activity and temperature-induced structural changes of alpha-crystallin. JBC 272: 23559–23564.
- 16.
Raman B, Ramakrishna T, Rao C (1995) Temperature dependent chaperone-like activity of alpha-crystallin. FEBS lett. pp. 133–136.
- 17.
Raman B, Rao C (1994) Chaperone-like activity and quaternary structure of alpha-crystalline. JBC 269: 27264–27268.
- 18.
Horwitz J, Huang Q, Ding L (2004) The native oligomeric organization of alpha-crystallin, is it necessary for its chaperone function? Exp Eye Res. pp. 817–821.
- 19.
Andreasi Bassi F, Arcovito G, De Spirito M, Mordente A, Martorana G (1995) Self-similarity properties of alpha-crystalline supramolecular aggregates. Biophys Journ 69: 2720–2727.
- 20.
Kramps HA, Stols ALH, Hoenders HJ, De Groot K (1975) On the quatemary structure of high-molecular-weight proteins from the bovine eye lens. Eur J Biochem 50: 503–509.
- 21.
Delaye M, Clark J, Benedek G (1982) Identification of the scattering elements responsible for lens opacification in cold cataracts. Biophys J 37: 647–656.
- 22.
Berne B, Pecora R (1976) Dynamic light scattering. Robert E. Krieger.
- 23.
Koppel DE (1972) Analysis of macromolecular polydispersity in intensity correlation spectroscopy: the method of cumulants. J Chem Phys. pp. 4814–4820.
- 24.
Maulucci G, De Spirito M, Arcovito G, Boffi F, Congiu Castellano A, et al. (2005) Particle size distribution in dmpc vesicles solutions undergoing different sonication times. BiophysJ 88: 3545–3550.
- 25.
Provencher S (1982) Contin: a general purpose constrained regularization program for inverting noisy linear algebric and integral equations. Comp Phys Comm 27: 229–242.
- 26.
Verwey E, Overbeek J (1948) Theory of the stability of lyophobic colloid. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
- 27.
Witten T, Sander L (1983) Diffusion-limited aggregation. PhysRevB 27: 5686–5697.
- 28.
Witten T, Sander L (1981) Diffusion-limited aggregation, a kinetic critical phenomenon. PRL 47: 1400–1403.
- 29.
Meakin P, Majid I, Havlin S, Stanley H (1984) Topological properties of diffusion limited aggregation and cluster-cluster aggregation. JPhysA. pp. L975–L981.
- 30.
Lin M, Lindsay H, Weitz D, Ball R, Klein R, et al. (1990) Universal reaction-limited colloid aggregation. PhysRev A 41: 2005–2020.
- 31.
Weitz D, Huang J, Lin M, Sung J (1985) Limits of the fractal dimension for irreversible kinetic aggregation of gold colloids. PRL 54: 1416–1419.
- 32.
Shih W, Aksay I, Kikuchi R (1987) Reversible-growth model: cluster-cluster aggregation with finite binding energies. PhysRevA 36: 5015–5019.
- 33.
Parasassi T, De Spirito M, Mei G, Brunelli R, Greco G, et al. (2008) Low density lipoprotein misfolding and amyloidogenesis. FASEB J 22: 2350–2356.
- 34.
Ball R, Weitz D, Witten T, Leyvraz F (1987) Universal kinetics in reaction-limited aggregation. PRL 58: 274–277.
- 35.
Biosca J, Travers F, Barman T (1983) A jump in an arrhenius plot can be the consequence of a phase transition. FEBS lett 153: 217–220.
- 36.
Schmelzer J, Fokin , Yuritsyn , Zanotto (2005) Nucleation Theory and Applications. Nucleation and Crystallization Kinetics in Silicate Glasses: Theory and Experiment. GmbH: Wiley-VCH Verlag.
- 37.
Krivandin A, Muranov K (1999) Comparative study of the crystallin supramolecular structure in the carp, frog, and rat lenses by small-angle roentgen ray scattering. Phys Med Biol 44: 1088–1093.
- 38.
Siezen RJ, Bindels JG, Hoenders HJ (1979) The interrelationship between monomeric, oligomeric and polymeric a-crystallin in the calf lens nucleus. Exp Eye Res 28: 551–567.
- 39.
Wainwright PR (2007) Computational modelling of temperature rises in the eye in the near field of radiofrequency sources at 380, 900 and 1800 mhz. Phys Med Biol 52: 3335–3350.
- 40.
Harding J (2002) Viewing molecular mechanisms of ageing through a lens. Ageing ResRev 1: 465–479.
- 41.
Guy AW, Lin JC, Kramar PO, Emery AF (1975) Effect of 2450-mhz radiation on the rabbit eye. IEEE transactions on microwave theory and techniques 23: 492–498.
- 42.
Cleary S (1980) Microwave cataractogenesis. Proceedings of the IEEE 68: 49–55.
- 43.
Kramar P, Harris C, Guy AW (1987) Thermal cataract formation in rabbits. Bioelectromagnetics 8: 397–406.
- 44.
Hirata A, Watanabe H, Shiozawa T (1994) Sar and temperature increase in the human eye induced by obliquely incident plane waves. IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility 269: 592–594.
- 45.
Lin J (2003) Cataracts and cell-phone radiation. IEEE Antennas and propagation magazine 45: 171–174.
-crystallin