Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathies (TSEs) are a group of progressive fatal neurodegenerative disorders, triggered by abnormal folding of the endogenous prion protein molecule. The encoding gene is a major biological factor influencing the length of the asymptomatic period after infection. It remains unclear the extent to which the variation between quantitative trait loci (QTLs) reported in mouse models is due to methodological differences between approaches or genuine differences between traits. With this in mind, our approach to identifying genetic factors has sought to extend the linkage mapping approach traditionally applied, to a series of additional traits, while minimising methodological variability between them. Our approach allows estimations of heritability to be derived, as well as predictions to be made about possible existence of genetic overlap between the various traits.
Our data indicate a surprising degree of heritability (up to 60%). Correlations between traits are also identified. A series of QTLs on chromosomes 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 11 and 18 accompany our heritability estimates. However, only a locus on chromosome 11 has a general effect across all 4 models explored.
We have achieved some success in detecting novel and pre-existing QTLs associated with incubation time. However, aside from the general effects described, the model-specific nature of the broader host genetic architecture has also been brought into clearer focus. This suggests that genetic overlap can only partially account for the general heritability of incubation time when factors, such as the nature of the TSE agent and the route of administration are considered. This point is highly relevant to vCJD (a potential threat to public health) where the route of primary importance is oral, while the QTLs being sought derive exclusively from studies of the ic route. Our results highlight the limitations of a single-model approach to QTL-mapping of TSEs.
Citation: Iyegbe CO, Abiola OO, Towlson C, Powell JF, Whatley SA (2010) Evidence for Varied Aetiologies Regulating the Transmission of Prion Disease: Implications for Understanding the Heritable Basis of Prion Incubation Times. PLoS ONE 5(12): e14186. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186
Editor: Ashley I. Bush, Mental Health Research Institute of Victoria, Australia
Received: February 22, 2010; Accepted: August 12, 2010; Published: December 2, 2010
Copyright: © 2010 Iyegbe et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The work was carried out with the support of grant number G9627297 of the Medical Research Council, United Kingdom. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The Prnp locus has long been established as the major genetic determinant of Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathy (TSE) incubation time, however its effects do not fully explain the variance associated with this trait, thus other critical factors must also play an important role in the aetiology of these disorders , . TSE pathogenesis has been shown to be heavily dependent on intrinsic factors specific to the strain of the agent, the route of transmission  and dose of infection . Since the identification of the prion protein gene, more recent studies have established that the risk from acquired prions is mitigated by host genes other than Prnp , . Although incubation period phenotypes in the TSEs are the product of multiple small gene effects, their overall impact may be cumulatively substantial. Exactly how substantial (ie. their collective heritability) is a question to date unexplored for acquired TSEs on account of their rarity and the challenges posed by their potentially long incubation periods. Prion research has benefitted from the success of linkage studies conducted in the mouse. These have highlighted several regions associated with the incubation period phenotype . Additionally a recent genome wide association study of human TSEs cases conducted by Mead et al  identified common variants for age of onset and death, two corollaries of the incubation period phenotype.
The contrasting genetic approaches of linkage and association are complementary and normally explore competing hypotheses regarding the underlying genetic architecture of disease progression. They provide a means by which to interrogate the genome for both common variants of small effect and rarer variants of intermediate/large effects. Current evidence suggests that the two models are not mutually exclusive and may coalesce , , .
Methodological variability precludes most meaningful comparisons between previous linkage efforts, as studies differ by either the chosen genetic background, prion source, or the host adaptation status of the agent . However the frequency with which QTLs have been successfully identified across these studies advances the case for a genetic basis independent from Prnp while, the variability between the loci reported gives some indication of the scale on which influential variants may exist. However still this leaves little objective rationale for distinguishing the more empirically relevant loci from those whose effects are confined to only certain genetic backgrounds.
In all, 5 previous linkage studies have implicated QTLs on 12 different chromosomes , , , , . The more recurrent among these loci such as chromosome 11, provide a stronger rationale for targeted fine mapping approaches. These previous studies are all based on intracranial (ic) transmission, which involves the introduction of prion material directly to the brain. This paradigm may model infection arising from exposure to larger peripheral doses of infectivity, as the relatively long period of replication in the spleen that would normally be seen in peripheral administration is bypassed in this instance, suggestive of direct neuroinvasion . Peripheral neuroinvasive routes are specifically relevant to the transmission of human acquired TSE forms such variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease (vCJD) , which poses a potentially major risk to public health. The question of whether ip transmissions have a unique genetic basis or one that may be shared across routes and between agents has to date not been addressed. A comparative approach to defining genetic commonality between traits may therefore be useful for classifying QTLs according to their empirical relevance to TSE transmissions.
The BXD set of recombinant inbred mice were the genetic cross chosen for this study. TSE incubation QTLs have not been explored in this particular background, therefore it is of interest to determine whether QTLs identified in previous studies could also be detected here. The BXDs derive from an F2 intercross of C57BL/6 and DBA/2J progenitors . By definition, recombinant inbred lines are genetically homozygous at each locus and genotypes for nearly 4000 loci are readily-available. In this case both progenitor strains are homozygous for the same short-incubating (s7) prion allele. This effectively eliminates genetic variation at this locus from the study. The recombinant inbred (RI) method exploits the fact that the individuals within each line are genetically identical, hence trait values are based on group means as opposed to individual measurements. This makes QTL detection feasible even for traits with low heritability, due to a compensatory gain in the accuracy of phenotype measurement.
Additionally, the integrative ability of the RI approach can be exploited in order to produce genetic correlations between traits which allow both estimations of genetic overlap and heritability of traits. With this in mind the goals of the work were as follows:
- To determine the total contribution made by genetic variants of small effect (QTLs) through estimations of trait heritability.
- To estimate possible overlap between the genetic architectures regulating different transmissions by genetic correlation.
- To identify new QTLs for different treatment conditions, including the transmission of natural BSE, the de facto experimental model for vCJD.
- To provide validation of any previously identified QTL candidates.
The distribution of BXD incubation periods
Raw phenotype data for the BXD lines and the progenitor strains C57BL/6 and DBA/2J are presented in table 1. An illustrative representation is shown in Figure 1. Plots of BXD strain means in Fig. 1 are continuous in nature, confirming the polygenic nature of TSE incubation times in the BXD genetic background. In all cases strain means extend outside the range of the progenitors. Relative differences between strain mean rank for each trait (table1) allude to trait-dependent genetic involvement.
Figure 1. Means and s.e.m of strain incubation periods are given for the four agent/route combinations shown in table 1.
Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE), intracranial administration (ic), intraperitoneal administration (ip).doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.g001
Table 1. BXD strain means for prion disease incubation time.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t001
The lowest overall variances are seen in Me7 ic, (fig. 1b) (129 to 170 days) reflecting the host-adapted nature of this agent. C57 appears to be the less susceptible of the two progenitors overall, as incubation periods for this strain generally exceed those of DBAs, (the only exception to this is Me7 ip). Internal reliability was assessed from BXD incubation period data using the Split-Half method . A split-half coefficient of 0.7 and above equates to an s.e.m. of over half (0.55) a standard deviation. The mean Split-Half coefficient for all traits is 0.90 (all traits). The average reliability for any single trait is over 0.86 or greater (Table S1).
Heritability in RI mice is determined as one half of the variance between strain means. Genetic effects in BXDs are predominantly additive in nature, which permits the calculation of narrow-sense heritability; ie, the proportion of phenotypic variance ascribable to additive gene effects (see methods).
The heritabilities shown in table 2 are modest, but provide evidence that a large component of TSE incubation period may be influenced by a genetic architecture independent from Prnp. Heritabilities range from 0.30 (Me7 ic) to 0.60 for Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy given ic (BSE ic). This suggests between 30 to 60% of phenotypic variance may be due to variation in genes. The upper limit of 0.6 is somewhat surprising given that direct effects from Prnp (the major genetic locus for the disease) have been excluded by experimental design. The extent to which variance between mouse strains (on which these estimates are based), may be impacted on by factors pertaining to litter or maternal rearing differences is beyond the scope of this study. Such interference may occur by way of various epigenetic processes. These may include the chemical modification of DNA (genomic imprinting) or interference of messenger RNA. The reader should refer to  for an outline of the theory and  for a direct account of the impact of maternal factors on TSE incubation time, in an experimental setting. Similar phenomena in humans may also help to explain discordances in age at onset of up to 8 years in twins carrying the inherited prion mutation P102L , . In this study such effects are assumed to have no net effect on phenotype.
Table 2. Derived estimates of TSE heritability for the BXDs.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t002
Broadly speaking, the range of heritabilities shown in table 2 suggests that for some traits the cumulative effect of QTLs on incubation time may exceed the major locus effect of Prnp. However neither the existence nor involvement of trans-acting regulators of Prnp, (which could potentially bias these heritability estimates) can be ruled out based on our data.
Genetic correlations were performed in order to investigate the possible involvement of QTLs across multiple transmission models.
The correlations in table 3 estimate the total proportion of host genetic effects that may be shared by different models. The data suggest a complex picture in which traits are underpinned by both shared and unique genetic effects.
Table 3. Inter-Trait genetic correlations.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t003
Some comparisons reach statistical significance. For example, the correlation between traits exclusively involving either the ip or the ic route reaches 0.52, p<0.05 (Me7 ic versus BSE ic) and peaks at 0.67, p<0.05 (for BSE ip versus Me7 ip).
The latter correlation in particular suggests that a partially conserved genetic infrastructure regulates transmission through the ip route and seemingly provides evidence of a dynamic effect across a range of agents, which encompass differences in host-adaptation.
A strong correlation between BSE ic and BSE ip (r = 0.702, p = 0.001) contrasts with the low level of correlation found for Me7 ic and Me7 ip (r = 0.38). The case for genuine disparity between the levels of genetic conservation across routes for natural and host-adapted isolates would benefit from further replication of these findings. Curiously, a greater degree of overlap (r = 0.6) is observed between Me7 ic, and BSE ip (p<0.05) than exists between the two traits involving Me7. This is notable as it suggests that tight conservation of the supporting architecture can potentially transcend seemingly random differences in route and agent. However it is also surprising, given that the relatively high correlation is found to be unique when the reciprocal comparison (BSE ic vs Me7 ip) is made (r = 0.29).
Unfortunately the study design employed is not well-suited for discerning what (if anything) is so special about the combination of Me7 ic and BSE ip. Moreover, due to the absence of a cloned BSE isolate (such as 301C) from this study, we have been unable to discern whether the BSE correlation effect is a pre or post species barrier phenomenon.
Despite the high level of statistical significance achieved the level of genetic overlap estimated for BSE traits is far from perfect. The large number of QTLs likely to be operating on this complex trait dictates that even smaller deviations from a perfect correlation could be significant from a biological perspective.
Mapping of BXD incubation periods
Loci meeting nominal significance criteria were interrogated for superimposed effects from other background loci (composite interval mapping). Results for the composite interval mapping (CIM) and simple interval mapping (IM) are given in table 4 for markers achieving suggestive-level linkage (Table 4).
Table 4. Interval mapping results for the BXDs.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t004
The number of QTLs found exceeds theoretical expectation as, only one false positive is anticipated per genome-wide scan at the suggestive level . Among the composite mapping results are three examples where QTLs appear to have effects across traits.
BSE ic; Me7 ic (chromosome 4)
BSE ip; Me7 ic (chromosome 6)
Me7 ip; BSE ip (chromosome 6)
Though the possibility of genetic heterogeneity within QTLs is not excluded, the data suggest correspondence between these results and the empirical scheme of genetic overlap outlined by table 3. Table 4 gives no indication of any delineation between natural and host-adapted TSE strains. Loci such as D4Mit204 and D6Mit29 are common to both.
The refining effect of CIM, when applied to simple IM data is also demonstrated in Table 4. Adjustments to LRS score, additive affect and allelic direction are all noted (all linkage statistics were improved by the CIM models applied). These refinements are non-formulaic and depend on the composition of the background construct, hence the largest LRS score of 46.2 (D6Mit29, Me7 ip) is actually derived from the lowest IM score shown in this table (ie. 8.1). All loci remained significant after Bonferroni multiple testing correction was applied to CIM scores.
Qualitative comparisons of F2 and BXD phenotype data.
The strongest QTL candidates from the initial BXD mapping data were selected for confirmatory follow-up in an F2 population. The F2 sample were derived from an identical genetic background to that of the BXDs. Transmissions of TSE material were carried out using the same combinations of agent and route described for BXDs (see methods). Incubation data was normalised where required (see methods).
Data in Table 5 and the graph in fig. 2 highlight the overall similarity between BXD and F2 incubation periods. To help qualify this statement, the calculated Pearson's r between BXD and F2 trait means is 0.813 (P = 0.049). Additionally, trait means follow identical rank order to those obtained in BXDs.
Figure 2. Boxplot comparison of BXD strain and F2 incubation period data by experiment.
Black horizontal lines within the coloured bars give the median in each experiment. Lower and upper boundaries of blue bar represent 25th and 75th percentiles, respectively. Lower and upper tails demarcate largest and smallest values within 95% confidence interval. Me7 ic and Me7 ip transmissions produce significantly different incubation times between BXDs and F2s.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.g002
Table 5. Comparison of means for BXD and F2 incubation periods.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t005
The level of correlation found suggests that for TSE incubation periods, the comparatively lower phenotyping accuracy of F2s can be overcome with a sufficiently large F2 cohort. Such a strategy may be attractive for avoiding problems associated with breeding and maintaining a large RI mouse colony.
Despite the overall similarity between BXD and F2 mouse panels, individual discrepancies are noted: The panels differ for Me7 ic and Me7 ip transmissions at the P<0.01 level. BXD traits values are derived from strain means thus, given the high reliability scores associated with these values (data not shown), it is more likely that individual discrepancies are the result of greater phenotyping error among F2s.
Results of F2 interval mapping.
QTLs reaching minimum suggestive (p = 0.63) significance (composite model) are presented. In all, nine QTLs reach our significance criteria, (table 6). As in the BXD analysis, the yield of suggestive QTLs is above the expected false positive rate (one per genomewide scan). Me7 ic is the only trait for which QTLs are not detected, this reflects the low phenotypic variance observed in F2s. In the case of F2 interval mapping the effects of composite mapping on linkage peaks is much less dramatic than is observed in the BXDs. CIM should ideally be performed after ensuring that marker coverage is sufficient to provide an unbiased estimation of background effects. However this study has only tested those markers chosen to flank BXD-mapped QTLs.
Table 6. QTL mapping data for F2s.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t006
QTLs on chromosomes 1, 2 and 10 are linked with more than one trait. These loci demonstrate a corresponding level of allelic heterogeneity. This, along with the observation of genetic correlations (table 3), supports the notion that QTLs may have multiple effects across the different TSE phenotypes explored (ie QTL pleiotropy). Effects such as those found on chromosome 2 vary between additive and recessive modes. As these characteristics depend on the surrounding genetic architecture, they are expected to vary for different transmissions.
The prevailing BXD account of genetic overlap between ic and ip indicated in tables 3 is substantiated somewhat by QTL data in Table 4. Table 6 offers further supporting evidence from F2 data. QTLs on chromosomes 1 and 2 indicate overlapping influences on both BSE traits. The chromosome 10 locus has a broad effect on ip transmissions that extends to natural (BSE) and host-adapted (Me7) isolates. This is contrasted against QTLs on chromosomes 4 and 6, which show specific influences on BSE ic.
Comparison of BXD and F2 mapping data.
Our primary criteria for confirming (ie. replication) is contingent on synchrony between BXD and F2 loci in terms of both statistical significance and allelic direction.
Table 7 indicates that confirmation was not possible for 6 out of 7 candidate regions. The exception was chromosome 2, where the effect found on BSE ic was replicated. Failures are mostly due to an inadequate significance level being attained.
Table 7. BXD and F2 mapping data.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t007
Loci such as chromosome 4 make for difficult interpretation of the data, as the locus is clearly implicated by both BXD and F2 BSE ic models, but falls short of our criteria, due to allelic discrepancies. As discussed above, this too may be a symptom of including a small and biased pool of markers in the background-effects model. In order to circumvent the effect of such constraints to QTL detection, the empirical importance of QTLs effect across BXD and F2s was also explored by meta-analysis.
Random Effects meta-analysis of BXD and F2 data.
Meta-analysis is used in the context of this study to estimate the overall influence on incubation period of candidate regions under different experimental treatments. Our methodology, an implementation of the Random Effects model  incorporates heterogeneity within and between BXD and F2 to derive empirical estimates of effect size, along with associated confidence intervals and p values. The random effects model places greater emphasis on the consistency of effect sizes between studies. Full meta-analysis results are shown in tables S2 and S3, where estimations of the mean effect size (Pearson's r) are provided, along with standard errors and significance. Data are initially combined between BXDs and F2s (table S2) before aggregating data of traits to derive empirical estimates (table S3). One-tailed significance thresholds are derived from recommended F2 thresholds (two-tailed) for 2 degrees of freedom . Thresholds are p 8.0×10−4 (suggestive) and p 2.6×10−5 (significant).
The high frequency of loci reaching suggestive (p = 8.0×10−4) significance implies relatively low genetic heterogeneity between effects found for BXDs and F2s. This further corroborates the phenotypic similarity suggested by table 5; as consistency of effects is the main basis for linkage under the random effects model. Loci reaching standard significance thresholds are summarised in table 8.
Table 8. Summary of important meta-analysis findings.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t008
The application of a random effects meta-analytical method to BXD/F2 transmission data has resulted in ten traits meeting minimum criteria for linkage. Of these, three reach genomewide significance (ie. with P<2.6×10−5). These are:
Me7 ic on chromosome 4: r 0.30±0.06, p 4.0×10−8
BSE ip on chromosome 11: r 0.23±0.05, p 1.0×10−5
BSE ip on chromosome 18: r 0.22±0.05, p 1.9×10−5
The strongest overall effect is found at chromosome 4 (r = 0.30). This locus also achieves the highest overall significance, at 10−8. The ten hits are distributed across six intervals and apply to three out of four traits analysed (table S2). Not represented among them is Me7 ip. Paradoxically, the largest number of hits (four) is found for Me7 ic, a trait from which the lowest phenotypic variations were derived. The possibility exists that statistical significances associated with the trait Me7 ic merely reflect this low variation across BXDs and F2s given the emphasis of random effects methods on effect homogeneity. However, we fail to find evidence that the group of uncombined effect sizes found for this trait differs significantly from other traits analysed, Ptwo-tailed = 0.927 (T-test).
The chromosome 11 QTL demonstrates general influence on TSE incubation periods.
The rate of linkage at any level of significance diminishes as traits are combined (table S3), thus we find evidence of just one generally-acting QTL; the linkage region on chromosome 11. Tabulated data for this region are given in table 9. The chromosome 11 locus is significant overall (P = 9×10−10). Additional significant effects are observed for ic and Me7 experiments (P = 2×10−7 and 7×10−7 respectively). Effects for BSE reach suggestive (P = 1×10−4). ip transmissions show only a trend towards significance (P = 0.002). This is due to the larger standard errors associated with these estimated effects. All are consistent in direction, with reductions in disease progression (which corresponds with lengthening incubation time) mediated by DBA alleles.
Table 9. Breakdown of meta-analysis effects found in chromosome 11 QTL region.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t009
The r2 (table 9) gives estimations about the proportional additive variances from the locus. We estimate the overall contribution to phenotypic variance to be about 3%.
A long line of previous work has already established non Prnp-linked genetic modifiers as important determinants of incubation time , , , . As it is customary that the initial scientific rationale for such work is provided by analyses of heritability, it is slightly ironic that the estimation of heritability for human prion phenotypes has only very recently been possible . One factor precluding heritability analyses of vCJD, a future potential public health risk, is its low recurrence rate among nuclear families; there has been just one case of vCJD recurring in a family (Source: European Centre for Disease Prevention).
The heritability of age at onset and death for the human inherited TSE form was recently determined to be 0.55 (95% CI 0.35–0.75) . This value is comparable to our own estimates which derive from a related phenotype and are the first to be reported for an acquired TSE (h2narrow sense range = 0.3 to 0.6). As in , our estimates exclude direct effects from Prnp and suggest a cumulatively modest contribution of non-Prnp effects. We demonstrate that they may nevertheless outweigh those of the only known major locus, in response to varying the parameters explored by this study.
Our QTL data, only partially justifies our findings in relation to heritability, thus we acknowledge and draw further attention to the many possible sources of bias on which such estimates may rely , . Additionally further biases may result due to the relatively small proportion of the currently available BXD strains sampled in the study, irrespective of any phenotypic similarity observed between BXDs and F2s across traits (Pearson's r 0.813, p = 0.049). In this instance, the use of the expanded BXD set now available was not possible, but may well have resolved such curiosities as a recurrent but unconfirmed locus on chromosome 10 for BSE ic (BXD), Me7 ip (F2), and BSE ip (F2). Such patterns may not occur randomly and may actually reflect additional complexity at these loci. Evidence that the distribution of BXD and F2 QTLs in our data is non-random derives from the fact that:
- A combination of stringently employed mapping and meta-analytical methodologies have yielded many pre-existing QTLs known to be involved in controlling prion incubation times.
- There are a high number of F2 QTLs in relation to the much smaller hypothesis region tested (9 F2 QTLs were identified within the 27 marker loci tested, whereas 12 BXD QTLs were identified across 3795 tested marker loci). The F2 number is significantly higher than a priori expectations based on extrapolated BXD data (PYates corrected χ2<<0.0001) and argues that the methodological procedures in the BXD analysis offer sufficient protection against Type 1 error in this study. This implies enrichment for genuine QTLs in BXD and F2 data as well as further complexity in the mechanism underlying these QTLs. That previously reported QTLs were detected by this study goes some way to reaffirming the validity of a novel suggestive (p<8×10−4) locus on chromosome 1 (35–62 cM) and a significant (p<2.6×10−5) locus on chromosome 18 (4–17 cM).
F2 mapping was, by itself, able to reproduce a locus on chromosome 2 specific to BSE ic that reached the genomewide threshold for suggestive significance (p = 0.63). That this locus did not survive the subsequent random effects meta-analysis procedure merely emphasises the heterogeneity between the BXD and F2 estimates and does not contradict the initial evidence suggesting linkage at this region. The chromosome 2 QTL lies approximately 50 centiMorgans (cM) upstream of Prnp (located at 75 cM). Independence of the chromosome 2 locus from Prnp is assumed. Among the loci identified for ic transmissions are a number of familiar linkage regions, (corresponding to regions of chromosomes 2, 4, and 11) previously linked to this route , .
We are the first study to attempt to quantify the genetic basis of aetiological overlap governing different routes and agents. Table 3 highlights the potential for strong overlap effects, even when traits differ simultaneously by host adaptation, route and agent. The caveat is that strong effects of route and agent on genetic influence, suggest that QTLs identified in one study cannot necessarily be extrapolated to transmission models based on different combinations of agent and route. Thus, while it may be too tempting to resist extrapolating previously reported data to the oral route (a route more relevant to the transmission vCJD) our data suggest that doing so may blur the little that we understand of the genetic processes regulating the transmission of vCJD and the potential risk to public health that they may represent. This is because even the strongest correlating traits in our study do not share more than 70% of genetic influences in common, while our lowest estimates suggest that the dissimilarity between transmissions can mean just 50% overlap or less, even between transmissions using a common administration route (table 3).
The overall implication is that any lingering uncertainty about the identity of risk variants in vCJD may be best tackled using mapping strategies that specifically target the more relevant oral route. Reassuringly, table 3 suggests some portion of genetic influence may be common to all traits. The emphatic nature of the meta-analysis result and other prior linkage evidence makes the chromosome 11 locus one prime candidate for mediating such a role. Meta-analysis also highlights a number of other significant candidate regions, which are summarised in table 8. Trait-specific QTL effects of varying significance were found on chromosomes 1, 2, 4, 6 and 18, after the merging of BXD and F2 data.
Our data represent the third independent report of a distinct TSE locus on chromosome 2 (fig. 3a). The linkage region overlaps with previous QTLs identified in  and . Other QTLs located at the distal end of chromosome 2 have been identified by Lloyd et al , . It is not clear to what extent these may be specific to the CAST/Ei x NZW/OlaHsd background in which they occurred. Interestingly one of the regions of Lloyd et al spans loci of both the prion protein (Prnp) and that of its paralogue Doppel (Prnd), although sequence symmetry between progenitor strains at this locus rules out effects from within either gene. We are the third group to independently report the existence of QTLs for prion disease on chromosome 11. Previous studies have already established this chromosome as a good linkage candidate. Crucially however, our meta-analysis data attaches empirical significance to this locus. This suggests wider involvement across a variety of other transmission types not characterised previously. Candidate-based explorations of the region have so far failed to reveal the origins of such effects .
Figure 3. Summary of QTL intervals affecting TSE transmission by study (3a) and by genetic background (3b).
Only chromosomes with multiple QTL assignments are presented. All intervals with the exception of Lloyd et al are calculated in the absence of background modifiers. Manolakou intervals are estimated using XYExtract V2.5 (2004) of Cleiton and Silva.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.g003
Lloyd et al  (Table 10 and fig. 3a) observed similar genetic factors to those found in a previous investigation of the ic route  confirming the veracity of these loci. This result is perhaps not surprising given that each study uses the same genetic cross (NZW/Hsd and Cast/Ei) and only the TSE strain used (both host-adapted) varies. Moreno et al  and Manolakou et al  employ prion agents at different stages of host-adaptation. This may account for individual discrepancies between these results (in addition to methodological and environmental/epigenetic considerations) although, common regions on chromosomes 4 and 8 indicate a broader similarity between their findings.
Table 10. Summary of TSE linkage findings to date.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t010
Previous studies show a bias towards C57-derived genetic backgrounds. Of the QTLs shown in fig. 3b we see that regions on chromosomes 2, 6 and 11 have the most general influence across varied genetic backgrounds. The chromosome 11 has already been mapped in two non C57-derived backgrounds, while loci on chromosomes 2 and 6 have been identified in the NZW/Hsd and Cast/Ei genetic cross.
A recent GWA study of human TSEs draws attention to novel common variants associated with clinical phenotypes, implicating genes such as STMN2 and RARB. In addition, previously uncharacterised variants have also been discovered within PRNP . The study identified two loci of genome-wide importance, one in strong LD with the major locus at codon 129 and another found in the intergenic region between RARB and THRB. The other genome-wide significant finding in this study highlighted a locus for orally acquired TSEs (vCJD and Kuru), using meta-analysis. Underlying genetic heterogeneity found between TSE categories in this study mirrors our own findings. We assume this to reflect that factors such as agent, dose and route also have an important role in aetiological determinism and its corresponding genetic framework.
The low recurrence rate of familial vCJD precludes studies of human linkage, in which rare disease loci may be detected by virtue of their increased occurrence among affected relatives. This and the low global incidence of vCJD, means increasingly-available next-generation sequencing methods cannot yet be fully exploited to define the possible contribution of rare variants to the TSEs. Recent progress made, across psychiatry in particular, has helped to demonstrate the pathogenic potential of this variant class . Meanwhile, the continued application of linkage studies to murine proxies must continue in order to provide further cues for fine-mapping and positional cloning work. Gene targets identified by such approaches can advance human prion research by exploiting synteny between murine and human biological systems. QTL mapping in Heterogeneous Stock mice offers superior resolution to the RI approach and use of this genetic resource has the potential to expedite the search for QTLs by reducing the size of candidate regions to relatively few genes. Such approaches have been applied to great effect and have heralded the first wave of gene candidates and confirmed trait loci ,  to derive from murine QTL mapping of the TSEs.
Our findings concur with previous reports linking QTLs on chromosomes 2, 4, 6 with TSE incubation time. We also report a novel QTL on chromosome 18. Additionally our results enable us to extrapolate from a previous linkage region on chromosome 11 linked with ic transmissions, to a general effect spanning across ic/ip routes and natural/host adapted prion agents. The generality of this locus may make it a prime candidate for involvement in the general pathogenesis of TSEs, including vCJD. Our demonstration of the substantial selectively with which host genetics may act across different transmission models suggests that not all QTLs identified using the historically favoured ic model will feature as strongly for orally acquired TSEs. The enduring aetiological relevance of this route to vCJD contrasts with the apparent decline in the number of cases resulting from blood transfusions , . Thus a paradigm shift may be warranted to aid the detection of biological effects specific to vCJD. Such reasoning dictates that oral TSE transmissions should be the next priority for mapping studies of this type.
Materials and Methods
Animals were maintained with a 12 hour day/night cycle in a specific pathogen-free (SPF) facility by trained, qualified animal technicians. General husbandry was carried out on a daily basis. Animals had free access to food and water throughout the experiment. The experimental design was vetted and approved by the Home Office (project licence number: PPL 70/4351).
Transmissions were conducted in a category 3 biohazard containment unit using either halothane/oxygen or isoflourane/oxygen for anaesthesia purposes.
Animals were checked daily for neurological symptoms by a research staff member trained and approved in animal handling by the Animal Procedures department of the Home Office. Onset of disease was taken as the onset of three or more concurrent neurological signs. Mice were sacrificed at a defined endpoint of two weeks post diagnosis.
Mice used in the study
The BXD mouse set is derived from an F2 intercross between C57BL/6 and DBA/2J progenitors. 26 successive generations of brother-sister mating result in the generation of inbred mouselines that are homozygous at virtually every locus . BXD recombinant inbred mouse strains and their progenitors C57BL/6J and DBA2/J were imported from Jackson Laboratories (Bar Harbour, Maine, USA) and maintained by brother-sister mating. All mice were housed under specific pathogen-free conditions for the duration of the experiment. BXDs were routinely tested for homozygosity during the course the study to maintain the integrity of each line. One strain (33ty) was excluded on this basis. F2 mice were generated in-house from an F1 cross. Mice used were uniquely identifiable using subcutaneous transponder tags (AVID, UK).
Group sizes for the study are given in table 11. Commercial availability of BXD lines determined the number and pattern of strain usage in each experiment. This was mitigated by the survival and proliferation characteristics of each line after importation to UK. BSE ic transmissions were heavily prioritised in the F2 study. This was to ensure sufficient numbers to allow meaningful comparisons with previous studies.
Table 11. Breakdown of group sizes used.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014186.t011
Adult female mice aged 10–12 weeks old were used. Female mice were used in preference to males as, although group-housing by sex is the only feasible way to maintain a cohort of this size, severe injury and death in males caused by fighting was very frequently observed in a smaller pilot study. The small standard deviations associated with incubation time in BXD mice (see results) suggested a negligible effect of hormonal status.
Age-matched controls were given uninfected brain homogenate at the same dosage and volume as those administered infectious material. Group sizes for controls ranged between 5 and 10. There was no effect of inoculation batch on incubation time for any experiment.
TSE agents used
BSE affected bovine brain was provided by Central Veterinary Laboratories, Weybridge, UK. Cloned ME7 mouse-adapted scrapie was obtained from BBSRC, UK. Me7 was propagated by passage in C57 animals inoculated ic. Brains were harvested at terminal stages of disease.
Transmissions were conducted in a category 3 biohazard containment unit. Anaesthesia was carried out using halothane/oxygen. 30 µl of 1% w/v infective brain homogenate was injected into the right parietal lobe for all intra-cerebral (ic) inoculations. Intra-peritoneal (ip) inoculations used either 100 µl of 10% w/v BSE or 30 µl of 0.1% w/v Me7. Injections were given in the intraperitoneal cavity of the abdominal region. Experimental controls for ic and ip transmissions were inoculated under the same experimental conditions using identical quantities of uninfected mouse brain material.
The dosage scheme adopted by this study follows the observation that use of low dose inoculum is associated with increased variability of incubation time . This suggests that it is not feasible to apply the same standard dose to different routes, as this could create bias in the distribution of BXD incubation times. The extent of the bias would be determined by the variable transmission efficiency associated with individual routes. The incubation period data derived from such an approach would actually make traits less suited for evaluations of potential overlap (ie. genetic correlations).
In the worst case scenario, the variability arising from ‘under-dosing’ of routes could mean only a proportion of mice ultimately go on to develop clinical disease within average lifetime. To circumvent this possibility, titration studies were performed during the pilot phase of the study. These were used to establish the minimum dose required to ensure 100% transition from the pre-clinical to clinical disease status within a normal lifespan. These dosages were subsequently adopted for the main study. The advantages of this solution are two-fold:
- constraining of the total phenotypic variance in this way reduces measurement error. This is because data are derived from measurable endpoints, whereas if incubation periods were to exceed natural lifespan of the host it would only be possible to define the clinical endpoint by extrapolation of the observed data.
- the comparability of the resulting incubation period data is increased for genetic correlation purposes, as dosages for each trait are calibrated against a single ‘hit-rate’ target of 100%.
Animals were checked daily for neurological signs. Onset of disease was taken as the appearance of three or more concurrent neurological signs. Symptoms included dysmetria (as assessed by cage-top tests), tremor, wobbly gait and foot clasping . Head tilting, vacant staring and abnormal hyperactivity were other frequent indicators of early end-stage. Mice were sacrificed at a defined endpoint of two weeks post diagnosis. The experiment was terminated sooner for animals whose rate of physical decline warranted this. Incubation time was determined as the number of days between inoculation and establishment of three disease symptoms. Apart from intercurrent illnesss (accountable for death in 7% of cases), all inoculated animals became ill with prion disease.
All neuropathology was performed by the department of Neuropathology at the Institute of Psychiatry, London, UK. Brains of terminally ill animals were removed, fixed in formaldehyde/saline and processed for either haematoxylin and eosin staining or immuno-histochemical staining of PrP deposits using SP40 anti-PrP polyclonal antibody. Confirmation of disease in each of the experimental groups has been achieved by either establishing the existence of PrP-positive amyloid deposits  and/or the appearance of neuronal vacuolation in the medulla as in . PrPsc positivity in the medulla was limited to 40% of brain tissues examined. However these animals were recorded as being infected, on the basis of the following:
- Neuronal vacuolation was observed in the medulla of all affected brains.
- No evidence was found of any inflammatory response or other superimposed disease effects.
- Neither injected nor non-injected age-matched controls displayed TSE symptoms (Controls were allowed to go beyond two standard deviations from the tabulated BXD incubation means).
- Scoring was performed blind with respect to affective status (ie. case or control). TSE-related vacuoles were found only in the brains of prion-inoculated mice
- There is no evidence in our data to suggest that the plaque-negative animals form a distinct subgroup in terms of incubation periods (Mann-Whitney U test).
General statistical analyses.
Basic statistical analyses were carried out using SPSS v13 (LEAD technologies) and MiniTab (MiniTab Inc.).
Reliability of BXD data.
Internal consistency (or reliability) of the data was estimated in SPSS using the Split-Half method . Estimates were obtained by randomly dividing data for individual strains into two (odds and evens). A split-half coefficient was obtained from the correlation between the two halves. The result (typically over-conservative) is corrected to give a full test score using the Spearman-Brown prophecy formula (SPSS).
Genetic correlation was investigated in the BXD study by Pearson's correlation of BXD means across traits. This has allowed exploration of genetic overlap between the traits. Calculation of heritability estimated the contribution of genetics overall to each transmission phenotype. Being that members of each BXD line are genetically identical, any variation within each line is ascribed to environmental variance, whereas variance between strains is genetic. One half of the variance of means between the BXD lines estimates additive genetic variance (VA) while, the mean within-strain variance estimates mean environmental variance (VE). Thus, an estimate of narrow-sense heritability (h2n) may be obtained using the formula :(1)
Regression analysis and Interval mapping.
QTL analysis was performed by initial linear regression of BXD phenotype data across genotypes at each marker. Simple interval mapping was subsequently implemented using Mapmanager QTX v20b  using trait variances to weight BXD strain means.
For F2s interval mapping was performed using consensus map distances from the Mouse Genome database (www.informatics.jax.org). An unconstrained regression model was used with the strength of linkage in each region expressed as a likelihood ratio statistic.
Significance thresholds for the genome scan.
Genomewide significance thresholds are based on 10,000 permutations of the data (Mapmanager QTX). In order to remove any bias from the computed statistics C57BL/6 and DBA2/J data were excluded from permutation and from simple and composite mapping. Two levels of significance are used to assess the strength of linkage or association in genomewide studies:
The suggestive threshold represents the approximate value of the Likelihood Ratio Statistic (LRS) that would be expected to yield on average one false positive per genome scan . In the QTL analysis of BXD mice this corresponds to a genomewide p-value of 0.63 . Though this threshold is very permissive, it is extremely useful for highlighting loci worthy of follow-up. In this case loci reaching suggestive significance will be followed-up in a confirmatory screen that utilises F2 mice. Meanwhile, the significant threshold represents the approximate LRS value that would be expected to yield on average one false positive every twenty genome scans . Here this corresponds to a genomewide p-value of 0.05 .
Composite interval mapping.
The WebQTL interface, located at www.genenetwork.org, was used to perform initial interval mapping. This was followed up with a comprehensive analysis of genome-wide linkage using Mapmanager QTXvb20 . Loci meeting nominal significance criteria were interrogated for superimposed effects of other background loci (composite mapping). This was done using multiple regression to establish a panel of background markers under the assumption that constitutively these markers do not act epistatically. A forward step-wise strategy was employed in which the strongest linked markers were added to the background locus model if they improved the fit at the P<0.05 level. QTL Cartographer v2.5 (North Carolina State University) confirmed the location of all F2 QTLs identified in Mapmanager and found a high level of agreement between the observed effects (Spearman's rho = 0.71, P = 0.0001).
.An advantage of the RI method is that the BXDs are already genetically characterised at over 4000 markers, thus BXD mice require no additional genotyping. For each BXD region nominated for F2 follow-up, markers were chosen on the basis of location and heterozygosity between C57 and DBA progenitors from the Mouse Genome Database (http://www.informatics.jax.org) and the Roche database (http://mousesnp.roche.com). Markers 10 cM either side of each candidate peak were chosen . The phenotypic distribution across the genotypes generally followed the expected 1:2:1 ratio with the exception of D6Mit384 this marker was therefore excluded from the BSE ip analysis.
Polymerase Chain Reaction.
DNA was extracted from 1 cm F2 tail samples prior to transmissions using a commercially available kit (Qiagen, cat. No. 69506). 10 ng of DNA (in 5 µl of double-distilled water) was used as the template in 20 µl polymerase chain reactions (PCR). Reactions were carried out in 96-well plates using a PTC-200 thermocycler (GRI, UK). The reaction mix consisted of dNTPs (200 µM), AmpliTaq-Gold and provided buffer (Applied Biosystems), MgCl2 (3 mM) and forward/reverse primers (1 picoMolar of each). The 5′ end of each forward primer was fluorescently labelled with either Hex, Fam (MWG Biotech, Germany) or Ned (Applied Biosystems, UK). All reverse primers were obtained from MWG Biotech.
The reaction sequence was as follows: 94°C for 5 minutes; 94°C for 30 seconds, 15 seconds at annealing temperature, 72°C for 30 seconds for 35–40 cycles; 72°C for 5 minutes.
PCR products were run in multiplex on a 3100 genetic analyser (Applied Biosystems). Pooled sample were heat denatured in formamide (HiDi, Applied Biosystems) for 2 minutes at 94°C and subsequently snap frozen before being run using a 5 second injection time using a Rox GS-500 size standard (Applied Biosystems). Resolution of individual products within the multiplex required a minimum fluorescence signal of not less than 1000 units per PCR product. The software ‘Genotyper’ (Applied Biosystems) was used to analyse and genotype the output data.
Pre-processing of data.
Implementation of Random-Effects meta-analysis formulae was performed in Microsoft Excel spreadsheets. The effect size r was derived from the estimated variances calculated in Mapmanager, (valid since this equates to r2). Conversion of r to Fisher's Z (Zr) is recommended , . The conversion is based on the following formula:(2)
In practise this is done using a standard conversion table. Differences in the sign associated with a given effect (ie, allelic direction) are accounted for by assigning positive and negative Zr signs for C57BL/6 and DBA/2J alleles respectively.
Calculation of heterogeneity.
Calculation of heterogeneity was performed using equations appropriate to the number of studies being combined . Equation (3).(3)
was used for 3 or more studies , . Q, the weighted sum of squared errors, has a distribution with K-1 degrees of freedom when k equals the number of studies being compared. Equation (4) was used for comparisons of 2 studies (adapted from ).(4)
Equation 4 returns a standard normal deviation (Z) score for which the corresponding p value was obtained using a standard conversion table. This statistic was converted to a statistic with 1 degree of freedom, equivalent to in equation (3).
The between-study variance is an expression of the overall variance between two or more studies, taking into account all of its possible sources.  provides equations for estimating the between-study variance () that incorporate the heterogeneity calculated using equations (3) or (4), and a constant (c):(5)
This was applied in stages so that heterogeneity was first calculated between BXD and F2s for the same trait, and then between traits making up each measure. For example, the measure ‘BSE’ comprises BSE ic and BSE ip). When BXD and F2 data are initially combined, the constant c is calculated using fixed-effect weights as this step occurs before random effects weights are calculated. (6)
is accumulated over each combination step.
The weighted mean effect and its standard error.
Both between-study variance () and the within-study variance (n-3) are combined to produce a weighting coefficient (equation 7) for each. Implementation of the weighting gives the weighted mean effect size, (equation 8) in terms of. This equation is used to combine this metric across BXD and F2 experiments and between measures:(8)
Actual weighted means are derived after transformation back to r from. The sampling variance of the average effect size is the reciprocal of the sum of weights  therefore the standard error of the average effect size is the square root of the sampling variance, hence:(9)
It is recommended that the Z-score of the weighted mean effect is obtained by dividing the mean effect size by its standard error . This enables the probability associated with r to be calculated via a standard Z to P conversion table.
Reliability of BXD incubation data per trait. Summary of ‘Split-Half’ reliability estimates. BXD averages are calculated by strain across experiments. Experimental averages are calculated by condition across strains. *These reliability estimates are constrained by low phenotypic variance within the group.
(0.07 MB DOC)
Summary of effect sizes derived from Random-Effects meta-analysis procedure. Weighted mean r's for combined BXD and F2s data, r± s.e.m (see methods). Conversion of Zr to r is performed using a standard conversion table. Standard error is calculated as √(1/∑w). *Suggestive (P<8×10−4), **Significant (P<2.6×10-5).
(0.03 MB DOC)
Derived meta-analysis effect sizes summarised by agent/route. Weighted mean r (± s.e.m) for combined BXD and F2s data which is subsequently combined by route and by agent (see methods). *Suggestive (P<8×10−4), **Significant (P<2.6×10−5).
(0.04 MB DOC)
Conceived and designed the experiments: CI OOA SW. Performed the experiments: CI OOA CT. Analyzed the data: CI CT. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: CI OOA SW. Wrote the paper: CI. Co-supervised the work: JP SW.
- 1. Bruce M, Chree A, McConnell I, Foster J, Pearson G, et al. (1994) Transmission of bovine spongiform encephalopathy and scrapie to mice: strain variation and the species barrier. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B BiolSci 343: 405–411.
- 2. Kingsbury DT, Kasper KC, Stites DP, Watson JD, Hogan RN, et al. (1983) Genetic control of scrapie and Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in mice. J Immunol 131: 491–496.
- 3. Outram GW, Fraser H, Wilson DT (1973) Scrapie in mice. Some effects on the brain lesion profile of ME7 agent due to genotype of donor, route of injection and genotype of recipient. J Comp Pathol 83: 19–28.
- 4. Mould DL, Dawson AM, Smith W (1967) Determination of the dosage-response curve of mice inoculated with scrapie. J Comp Pathol 77: 387–391.
- 5. Stephenson DA, Chiotti K, Ebeling C, Groth D, DeArmond SJ, et al. (2000) Quantitative trait loci affecting prion incubation time in mice. Genomics 69: 47–53.
- 6. Mead S, Poulter M, Uphill J, Beck J, Whitfield J, et al. (2009) Genetic risk factors for variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease: a genome-wide association study. Lancet Neurol 8: 57–66.
- 7. Lloyd SE, Onwuazor ON, Beck JA, Mallinson G, Farrall M, et al. (2001) Identification of multiple quantitative trait loci linked to prion disease incubation period in mice. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98: 6279–6283.
- 8. Manolakou K, Beaton J, McConnell I, Farquar C, Manson J, et al. (2001) Genetic and environmental factors modify bovine spongiform encephalopathy incubation period in mice. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98: 7402–7407.
- 9. Lloyd SE, Uphill JB, Targonski PV, Fisher EM, Collinge J (2002) Identification of genetic loci affecting mouse-adapted bovine spongiform encephalopathy incubation time in mice. Neurogenetics 4: 77–81.
- 10. Moreno CR, Lantier F, Lantier I, Sarradin P, Elsen JM (2003) Detection of new quantitative trait Loci for susceptibility to transmissible spongiform encephalopathies in mice. Genetics 165: 2085–2091.
- 11. Race R, Oldstone M, Chesebro B (2000) Entry versus blockade of brain infection following oral or intraperitoneal scrapie administration: role of prion protein expression in peripheral nerves and spleen. J Virol 74: 828–833.
- 12. Ano Y, Sakudo A, Nakayama H, Onodera T (2009) Uptake and dynamics of infectious prion protein in the intestine. Protein Pept Lett 16: 247–255.
- 13. Plomin R, McClearn GE (1993) Quantitative trait loci (QTL) analyses and alcohol-related behaviors. Behav Genet 23: 197–211.
- 14. Falconer DS, Mackay T (1996) Quantitative Genetics: Longman Group
- 15. Webb T, Mead S, Beck J et al (2009) Seven-year discordance in age at onset in monozygotic twins with inherited prion disease (P102L). Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol 35: 427–432.
- 16. Hamasaki S, Shirabe S, Tsuda R, Yoshimura T, Nakamura T, Eguchi K (1998) Discordant Gerstmann-Straussler-Scheinker disease in monozygotic twins. Lancet 352: 1358–1359.
- 17. Lander E, Kruglyak L (1995) Genetic dissection of complex traits: guidelines for interpreting and reporting linkage results. Nat Genet 11: 241–247.
- 18. Hedges LV, Vevea JL (1998) Fixed and Random Effects Models in meta-analysis. Psychological Methods 3: 486–504.
- 19. Webb TE, Whittaker J, Collinge J, Mead S (2009) Age of onset and death in inherited prion disease are heritable. Am J Med Genet B Neuropsychiatr Genet 150B: 496–501.
- 20. O'Shea M, Maytham EG, Linehan JM, Brandner S, Collinge J, et al. (2008) Investigation of mcp1 as a quantitative trait gene for prion disease incubation time in mouse. Genetics 180: 559–566.
- 21. Owen MJ, Craddock N, O'Donovan MC (2010) Suggestion of roles for both common and rare risk variants in genome-wide studies of schizophrenia. Arch Gen Psychiatry 67: 667–673.
- 22. Lloyd SE, Maytham EG, Grizenkova J, Hummerich H, Collinge J (2009) A Copine family member, Cpne8, is a candidate quantitative trait gene for prion disease incubation time in mouse. Neurogenetics 2009 Oct 1. [Epub ahead of print].
- 23. Lloyd SE, Maytham EG, Pota H, Grizenkova J, Molou E, et al. (2009) HECTD2 is associated with susceptibility to mouse and human prion disease. PLoS Genet 5: e1000383.
- 24. EuroSurveill (2007) Fourth case of transfusion-associated vCJD infection in the United Kingdom. Euro Surveill 12: E070118.
- 25. Gillies M, Chohan G, Llewelyn CA, MacKenzie J, Ward HJ, et al. (2009) A retrospective case note review of deceased recipients of vCJD-implicated blood transfusions. Vox Sang 97: 211–218.
- 26. McLean AR , Bostock CJ (2000) Scrapie infections initiated at varying doses: an analysis of 117 titration experiments. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 355: 1043–1050.
- 27. Lantos PL, McGill IS, Janota I, et al. (1992) Prion protein immunocytochemistry helps to establish the true incidence of prion diseases. Neurosci Lett 147: 67–71.
- 28. Fraser H, Bruce ME, Chree A, McConnell I, Wells GA (1992) Transmission of bovine spongiform encephalopathy and scrapie to mice. J Gen Virol 73(Pt 8): 1891–1897.
- 29. Field AP (2005) Discovering statistics using SPSS (second edition). London: Sage publications.
- 30. Rodriguez LA, Plomin R, Blizard DA, Jones BC, McClearn GE (1994) Alcohol acceptance, preference, and sensitivity in mice. I. Quantitative genetic analysis using BXD recombinant inbred strains. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 18: 1416–1422.
- 31. Manly KF, Olson JM (1999) Overview of QTL mapping software and introduction to Map Manager QT. Mammalian Genome 10: 327–334.
- 32. Darvasi A (1998) Experimental strategies for the genetic dissection of complex traits in animal models. Nat Genet 18: 19–24.
- 33. Rosenthal R, DiMatteo MR (2001) Meta-analysis: recent developments in quantitative methods for literature reviews. Annu Rev Psychol 52: 59–82.
- 34. Rosenthal R (1991) Meta-analysis: a review. Psychosom Med 53: 247–271.