Conceived and designed the experiments: NR LSC AK FW SS DB PKD. Performed the experiments: BSB RT BBR PKD. Analyzed the data: NR RT BBR PKD. Wrote the paper: NR LSC RT FW SS BBR PKD. Provided critical comments and revisions: BSB AK DB.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
HIV-infected persons suffering from tuberculosis experience high mortality. No programmatic studies from India have documented the delivery of mortality-reducing interventions, such as cotrimoxazole prophylactic treatment (CPT) and antiretroviral treatment (ART). To guide TB-HIV policy in India we studied the effectiveness of delivering CPT and ART to HIV-infected persons treated for tuberculosis in three districts in Andhra Pradesh, India, and evaluated factors associated with death.
We retrospectively abstracted data for all HIV-infected tuberculosis patients diagnosed from March 2007 through August 2007 using standard treatment outcome definitions. 734 HIV-infected tuberculosis patients were identified; 493 (67%) were males and 569 (80%) were between the ages of 24–44 years. 710 (97%) initiated CPT, and 351 (50%) collected >60% of their monthly cotrimoxazole pouches provided throughout TB treatment. Access to ART was documented in 380 (51%) patients. Overall 130 (17%) patients died during TB treatment. Patients receiving ART were less likely to die (adjusted hazard ratio [HR] 0.4, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.3–0.6), while males and those with pulmonary TB were more likely to die (HR 1.7, 95% CI 1.1–2.7, and HR 1.9, 95% CI 1.1–3.2 respectively).
Among HIV-infected TB patients in India death was common despite the availability of free cotrimoxazole locally and ART from referral centres. Death was strongly associated with the absence of ART during TB treatment. To minimize death, programmes should promote high levels of ART uptake and closely monitor progress in implementation.
India has the world's highest burden of tuberculosis (TB) with 1.9 million estimated incident cases per year. It also ranks among the world's highest HIV burden with an estimated 2.3 million persons living with HIV/AIDS
Cotrimoxazole is a broad-spectrum antimicrobial agent that is recommended as primary prevention against opportunistic infections in HIV-infected persons
Antiretroviral treatment has been convincingly associated with improved treatment outcomes and reduced mortality
To guide TB-HIV policy in India, the Government of India's Revised National TB Control Programme (RNTCP) and NACP implemented a demonstration project in three districts in the state of Andhra Pradesh. The project's goal was to deliver the WHO-recommended interventions of CPT and ART (as per national guidelines) to all known HIV-infected TB patients. We retrospectively evaluated the efficiency of decentralized CPT delivery from primary health centres, assessed the effectiveness of referral links to ART centres, and studied factors associated with mortality among HIV-infected individuals treated for tuberculosis under programmatic conditions.
Three districts in the southern Indian state of Andhra Pradesh—Ananthapur, Vizianagaram, and Vishakapatnam (combined 2001 population 9.7 million)—were intentionally selected to implement these TB-HIV activities on the basis of high HIV prevalence among antenatal clinic attendees during NACP surveillance from 2003–2006. In the three districts there are a total of 154 primary health care facilities which provide general health services including TB diagnostic and treatment services. At the time of implementation of these interventions, there were 47 HIV counseling and testing centres and 3 ART centres for free HIV diagnosis and treatment (2 ART centres in Ananthapur, 1 in Vishakapatnam and none in Vizianagaram). HIV treatment and care, including ART, was available free of cost to patients at these ART centres. Patients from Vizianagaram district were able to access ART services in the adjacent district of Vishakapatnam.
TB diagnosis under RNTCP is based on initial smear microscopy, but allows for the diagnosis of smear-negative and extrapulmonary TB as well. Pulmonary TB diagnosis is based on a standard diagnostic algorithm
Providers were instructed to immediately refer all TB patients with any HIV risk factors to the nearest HIV counseling and testing centre, as per the prevailing national guidelines at the time. HIV test results were communicated to the referring provider either directly by the patient or via direct communication from HIV counselor to the referring provider (with patient assent). An initial 1-month supply of CPT, at the dose of sulfamethoxazole 800 mg/trimethoprim 160 mg daily (one “double strength” cotrimoxazole tablet) was provided to the HIV-infected TB patients from their respective primary health centres, and 1-month refills made available for the duration of their TB treatment at no cost. While being providing CPT, patients were counseled on the benefits of CPT, possible side effects, and the importance of adherence. In an attempt to address concerns about patient privacy, CPT was available at primary health centres only from health care workers, and not through community DOT providers. At the start of the intervention, CPT became available for all HIV-infected TB patients at the same time, regardless of whether a patient was newly diagnosed with TB or already on TB treatment for several months.
Providers were asked to refer HIV-infected TB patients to the nearest ART centre as soon as possible, but at least 2 weeks after the initiation of anti-TB treatment (to address the infection control concerns). Patients were asked to continue CPT from ART centres after their TB treatment was completed, or earlier if ART were initiated during TB treatment.
The RNTCP individual patient TB treatment cards were modified to enable recording of HIV status, CPT initiation, CPT adherence, and ART information. Trainings were conducted for all district medical officers, programme staff of NACP and RNTCP, and pharmacists at peripheral health facilities. Standard forms were developed to facilitate referrals and feedback on results of HIV testing and ART evaluations. TB programme staff maintained a separate register of HIV-infected TB patients to facilitate supervision and monitoring.
Standard definitions were used to categorize patients according to TB type and treatment outcomes
We retrospectively abstracted data from programme records for all HIV-infected TB patients notified to the RNTCP between 1 March and 31 August 2007. Treatment cards were collected from all health facilities and data double entered with Microsoft Excel. At the end of 6 months RNTCP and NACP conducted field visits to 30 health service delivery sites in the three districts, and conducted unstructured interviews with 100 randomly selected HIV positive TB patients to identify gaps in the delivery of intervention services.
We compared HIV-infected TB patients who died during TB treatment with those who did not die. Risk factors for death analyzed included age, sex, district of residence, type of TB, CPT use, CPT adherence, and ART provision. To assess CPT adherence in the context of a variable duration of TB treatment, we expressed the number of monthly CPT dose pouches picked up—as recorded on TB treatment cards—as a proportion of the number of months which an HIV-infected TB patient was alive and on treatment (rounded down to the nearest month). Data on CD4 cell counts were not available in routine records.
For bivariate analysis, we compared proportions using chi-square, and for continuous variables we compared medians using the Wilcoxin Rank-Sum test. The survival distribution of the overall cohort was estimated using the Kaplan-Meier method, and subgroups were compared using the Cox-Mantel (log-rank) test. P-values throughout were 2-sided and we used a 0.05 significance level.
For multivariate analysis we calculated hazard ratios for factors associated with death using a Cox proportional-hazards model. The dependent variable was the number of days. Treatment outcomes other than death were censored after the last day of TB treatment recorded. We pre-selected variables for inclusion in the multivariable model based on prior information from studies from other settings on risk factors for mortality in HIV-infected TB patients
This retrospective analysis was conducted after review and approval by the National AIDS Control Programme and the Central TB Division, Directorate General of Health Services, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. The activity was determined to be programme evaluation of the implementation of internationally-recommended interventions. Electronic databases created for this analysis were stripped of personal health identifiers and maintained securely.
Among the 7,752 patients registered in the three districts from March 1 2007 to August 31 2007, 734 (9.5%) were identified as HIV-infected. The proportion of registered patients reported to be HIV-infected varied by district; 322 (9.9%) out of the 3,239 of TB patients registered from Ananthapur were HIV-infected, as were 317 (11.6%) out of the 2,725 from Vishakapatnam and 95 (5.3%) out of the 1,788 from Vizianagaram. Characteristics of these 734 HIV-infected TB patients are shown in
Characteristic | Subcategory | N (%) |
District of Residence | Ananthapur | 322 (43.8) |
Vishakapatnam | 317 (43.2) | |
Vizianagaram | 95 (13.0) | |
Sex | Male | 493 (67.2) |
Female | 220 (30.0) | |
Not available | 21 (2.8) | |
Previous TB treatment | Yes | 99 (13.5) |
No | 635 (86.5) | |
Type of TB | Pulmonary | 551 (75.1) |
Extrapulmonary | 183 (24.9) | |
TB Classification | New smear-positive pulmonary | 277 (37.7) |
New smear-negative pulmonary | 190 (25.9) | |
New extrapulmonary | 168 (22.9) | |
Re-treatment | 99 (13.5) | |
Age Group | <15 years | 1 (0.1) |
15–24 years | 50 (6.8) | |
25–34 years | 318 (43.3) | |
35–44 years | 251 (34.2) | |
45–54 years | 84 (11.4) | |
>55 years | 27 (3.7) | |
Not available | 3 (0.4) | |
On ART before TB treatment | No | 601 (81.9) |
Yes | 133 (18.1) | |
On ART at any time during TB treatment | No | 354 (48.2) |
Yes | 380 (51.8) |
Abbreviations: TB–Tuberculosis; ART–antiretroviral treatment.
710 (97%) of the 734 known HIV-infected TB patients were initiated on CPT during the evaluation period; 22 (3%) of patients were already taking CPT before the start of TB treatment from the ART centre, and no record of CPT initiation was found for two patients. Nearly half (323, 44%) received prophylaxis within 1 week of starting TB treatment
Characteristic | Sub-category | N (%) | Cumulative N (%) |
Delay of initiation of CPT, relative to date of TB treatment initiation | 0 days (Before or on the same day) | 203 (27.6) | 203 (27.6) |
1–7 days | 120 (16.4) | 323 (44.0) | |
8–30 days | 131 (17.9) | 454 (61.9) | |
30–60 days | 48 (6.5) | 502 (68.4) | |
61–120 days | 16 (2.2) | 518 (70.6) | |
CPT started from ART center | 22 (3.0) | 540 (73.6) | |
Data not available | 194 (26.4) | 734 (100) | |
Proportion of monthly CPT packets documented as picked up |
81–100% | 214 (29.2) | 214 (29.2) |
61–80% | 137 (18.6) | 351 (47.8) | |
41–60% | 88 (12.0) | 439 (59.8) | |
21–40% | 109 (14.9) | 548 (74.5) | |
0–20% | 111 (15.1) | 659 (89.7) | |
Not available | 75 (10.2) | 734 (100) |
Relative to total duration of TB treatment taken during the evaluation period.
Abbreviations: CPT–cotrimoxazole prophylactic treatment; TB–tuberculosis; ART–antiretroviral treatment.
Among the 734 HIV-infected TB patients, 133 (18%) were documented as already on ART at the time of TB treatment initiation. Of the 601 HIV-infected TB patients not on ART at the time of TB treatment initiation, 559 (93%) were documented to have been referred to ART centres. Of the 559 referrals to ART centre, 324 (61%) were documented to be subsequently pre-registered at ART centres. Of the 324, 247 (76%) were initiated on ART by the end of TB treatment. In total, 380 of 734 (52%) had access to ART during TB treatment.
Treatment outcomes were available for all 734 HIV-infected TB patients
Treatment outcome | NSP (%) | NSN (%) | NEP (%) | Re-treatment (%) | Total (%) |
Treatment success | 201 (72.4) | 136 (71.6) | 149 (88.7) | 50 (50.5) | 536 (73.0) |
Default | 12(4.3) | 20 (10.5) | 7 (4.2) | 16 (16.2) | 55 (7.5) |
Failure | 9(3.3) | 1 (0.5) | 0 | 3 (3.0) | 13 (1.8) |
Died | 55 (19.9) | 33 (17.4) | 12 (7.2) | 30 (30.3) | 130 (17.7) |
Total | 277 (100) | 190 (100) | 168 (100) | 99 (100) | 734 (100) |
Abbreviations: NSP–new pulmonary tuberculosis with sputum smears positive for acid-fast bacilli; NSN–new pulmonary tuberculosis with sputum smears negative for acid-fast bacilli; NEP–New extrapulmonary tuberculosis.
Overall 130 (18%) HIV-infected TB patients died during TB treatment. Bivariate risk factors for death are shown in
ART = antiretroviral treatment, TB = tuberculosis.
Characteristic | Sub-Category | Total | Died, N (%) | RR (95% CI) |
District of Residence | Ananthapur | 322 | 56 (17.4) | Referent |
Vishakapatnam | 317 | 60 (18.9) | 1.09 (0.78–1.51) | |
Vizianagaram | 95 | 14 (14.7) | 0.85 (0.49–1.45) | |
Sex | Male | 493 | 102 | Referent |
Female | 220 | 25 (11.4) | 0.55 (0.37–0.83) | |
Not available | 21 | 3 (14.9) | 0.69 (0.24–2.00) | |
Previous TB treatment | No | 635 | 100 (15.8) | Referent |
Yes | 99 | 30 (30.3) | 1.92 (1.36–2.73) | |
Type of TB | Pulmonary | 551 | 113 (20.5) | Referent |
Extrapulmonary | 183 | 17 (9.3) | 0.45 (0.28–0.73) | |
Tuberculosis Classification | New Smear-Positive | 277 | 55 (19.9) | Referent |
New Smear-Negative | 190 | 33 (17.4) | 0.87 (0.59–1.29) | |
New Extrapulmonary | 168 | 12 (7.1) | 0.36 (0.20–0.65) | |
Re-Treatment (all types) | 99 | 30 (30.3) | 1.53 (1.04–2.23) | |
Age Group | <15 years | 1 | 0 | |
15–24 years | 50 | 5 | 0.59 (0.25–1.04) | |
25–34 years | 318 | 54 | Referent | |
35–44 years | 251 | 46 | 1.08 (0.76–1.54) | |
45–54 years | 84 | 17 | 1.19 (0.73–1.94) | |
>55 years | 27 | 8 | 1.74 (0.93–3.28) | |
Data not available | 3 | 0 | ||
Delayed CPT initiation | <1 week | 323 | 58 (18.0) | Referent |
1 week–2 months | 179 | 30 (16.7) | 0.93 (0.62–1.39) | |
>2 months | 16 | 1 (6.3) | 0.35 (0.05–2.4) | |
Data not available | 194 | 36 (18.6) | 1.03 (0.71–1.51) | |
CPT adherence | >80% | 214 | 39 (18.2) | Referent |
60–80% | 137 | 30 (21.9) | 1.20 (0.79–1.84) | |
40–60% | 88 | 13 (14.8) | 0.81 (0.46–1.44) | |
<40% | 220 | 28 (12.7) | 0.70 (0.45–1.09) | |
Data not available | 75 | 20 (26.7) | 1.46 (0.91–2.34) | |
ART during TB treatment | No | 354 | 87 (24.6) | Referent |
Yes | 380 | 43 (11.3) | 0.46 (0.33–0.64) |
In multivariate analysis
Characteristic | Adjusted Hazard Ratio | 95% Confidence Interval |
Antiretroviral treatment during TB treatment | 0.41 | 0.28–0.60 |
Male sex | 1.67 | 1.07–2.62 |
Previous tuberculosis treatment | 1.44 | 0.93–2.23 |
Pulmonary tuberculosis | 1.89 | 1.11–3.21 |
Age Group | ||
15–24 years | 0.75 | 0.30–1.90 |
25–34 years | Referent | |
35–44 years | 0.89 | 0.61–1.34 |
45–54 years | 1.12 | 0.68–2.00 |
>55 years | 1.98 | 0.94–4.19 |
Limiting the multivariate analysis to those patients who started ART during TB treatment ( i.e. excluding the 133 who were already on ART at the time of TB diagnosis) did not substantially change the association between ART exposure and lower risk of death (HR 0.32, 95% CI 0.20–0.52), nor did limiting the analysis to males or females alone (HR 0.47, 95% CI 0.32–0.71 and HR 0.23, 95% CI 0.08–0.64).
This evaluation provides the first evidence from India regarding the operational challenges of delivering WHO-recommended mortality-reducing TB-HIV interventions under general field conditions. It also provides information on the daunting problem of the high mortality of HIV-infected TB patients. In this resource-limited setting, nearly 1 in 5 HIV-infected individuals diagnosed with TB died during TB treatment. While previous studies have reported high mortality among HIV-infected persons with tuberculosis
With no additional resources or efforts beyond provider trainings and monitoring by regular HIV and TB programme staff, more than 95% of all detected HIV-infected TB patients were initiated on CPT. Mixed adherence may have reduced the effectiveness of CPT in this population, as just half of patients collected >60% of their cotrimoxazole. With increased awareness of CPT, adherence may improve; additional measures the programmes should consider include use of peer-counselor networks and non-governmental organizations to support and encourage patients and providers.
We found that patients provided ART during TB treatment had less than half the risk of death as those not provided ART. This finding was independent of sex or previous TB treatment history, and is consistent with findings from several other settings
HIV-infected males experienced higher death rates than females; the reasons for this finding are unclear. Overall case-fatality rates among males with tuberculosis in India are modestly higher than in females, and postulated reasons for higher mortality among males include differences in treatment adherence, age distribution, smoking behavior, and comorbidities
Our evaluation was subject to several important limitations. This was a retrospective evaluation of a demonstration conducted under routine programme conditions; available information was limited to that recorded on standard patient records which had been modified to include additional HIV-related information. With ascertainment of HIV-infection among TB patients based on selective referral of those persons with HIV risk factors, the patients identified might not be representative of the larger population of HIV-infected TB patients. All 3 districts practiced the same selective referral policy, but in Vizianagaram district a simultaneous population-based survey of HIV infection among TB patients provides insight into the effectiveness of the ascertainment of HIV infection
Treatment outcomes were recorded by many providers, and were not independently validated. Information about other biomedical risk factors for death that may have confounded this evaluation, such as severity of TB disease, drug resistance, severity of immune suppression, or comorbidities, were not available. No ‘control’ areas without CPT were assessed because we did not seek to evaluate the efficacy of CPT as an intervention, and observational analysis of the association of CPT and mortality were not possible since almost all patients were exposed to CPT during TB treatment. The efficacy of CPT, however, has been amply demonstrated in multiple settings. The recording of ART information was dependent on feedback from the ART centre. Some patients may not have had ART consumption recorded on their TB treatment card, so we may have misclassified these patients as not provided ART, and thus underestimated the protective effect of ART in this population. We were also unable to collect adequate information about sub-type of extrapulmonary TB, patient CD4 count, or the specific timing of ART initiation. Future studies should seek to collect this information to better understand the finding of lower overall mortality in extrapulmonary TB, and the protective effect of ART against mortality during TB treatment.
On the basis of this experience, decentralized CPT delivery for HIV-infected TB patients has been included in national TB-HIV policies, and is being presently implemented in high HIV-prevalence settings throughout India
Cotrimoxazole prophylaxis can be delivered to HIV-infected TB patients under programmatic conditions in India. Despite the availability of free cotrimoxazole locally and ART from referral centres, death was common and was strongly associated with the absence of ART during TB treatment. These findings have been translated into national policy and programme implementation through the expansion of cotrimoxazole availability and training on the importance of ART. To minimize death, the TB and HIV programmes should target high levels of ART uptake and closely monitor progress in implementation.
We wish to acknowledge the Project Director of Andhra Pradesh State AIDS Control Society, District Tuberculosis Officers of Ananthapur, Vizianagaram, and Vishakapatnam, the Senior Treatment Supervisors, and the WHO-RNTCP consultants (K Santosha, J Jyoti, R Chethana, M Yogesh, and T Neelima) of Andhra Pradesh for their efforts to implement improved care for HIV-infected persons with tuberculosis and for supporting this evaluation.