Reader Comments

Post a new comment on this article

Some problems with the The Single Item Narcissism Scale (SINS)

Posted by Tenpel on 06 Aug 2014 at 08:59 GMT

The SINS won’t work in all environments. There are environments where narcissism is seen as extreme egoism and as something bad, condemnable, something to overcome. For instance, within Mahayana Buddhism, e.g. Tibetan Buddhism, there is a strong emphasis on empathy or compassion which is seen as an ideal one should strive for. A narcissist living in such an environment will adopt this ideal and emulate to live in it while he or she still has not overcome his or her narcism. Instead the person uses the ideal of empathy/compassion to increase his narcissism (or to feed it), thinking he or she would be a great compassionate person, demanding admiration and recognition for his or her great compassion and "self-lessness".

If you do the SINS with such a person, I doubt that such a person will agree to a question »"I am a narcissist." (Note: The word “narcissist” means egotistical, self-focused, and vain.)« though he or she is a narcissist because this question does not conform to the sense of being a grandiose, compassionate, non-egoistic person. I assume in such a context this SINS will rather totally fail.

The SINS doesn’t take into account that there are other social environments where this test might fail to a high percentage.

As a reminder: »Even altruism and love itself can be nothing more than elaborate façades built to protect and disguise the ego.« – François de La Rochefoucauld (17th century)

No competing interests declared.

RE: Some problems with the The Single Item Narcissism Scale (SINS)

Tenpel replied to Tenpel on 06 Aug 2014 at 11:12 GMT

Just as an additional criticism …

Since the study seems not to take into account narcissists in different sozial environments where there are different value systems, the SINS might be valid only in a certain country and environment (and tells more about that country or its environment than about its validity).

I deeply doubt that in Asian countries or Buddhist communities the SINS will work, though for sure there are narcissists that can be recognised with the commonly established tests. Therefore I suggest to do further studies in different cultures and in different social environments to prove the general validity of the SINS and to not generalise the result too much. (I got aware of the research via German media.)

No competing interests declared.