Reader Comments

Post a new comment on this article

Absence of structures

Posted by cdsouthan on 23 Dec 2012 at 12:13 GMT

Considering the profile of this journal with respect to transparency, the omission of the explicit inhibitor chemical structures is unexpected. Without them the key experiments in the paper cannot be reproduced

No competing interests declared.

RE: Absence of structures

eportan replied to cdsouthan on 04 Feb 2013 at 11:46 GMT

Novartis is willing to provide the inhibitor they supplied for this study under a Material Transfer Agreement for academic research and non-commercial purposes. Please contact Ulf Neumann (ulf.neumann@novartis.com).

Compound S is identical to compound J in the published BACE2/diabetes Cell metabolism paper:
Cell Metabolism, Volume 14, issue 3, 7 september 2011, Pages 365-377. This reference describes the synthesis in more detail:

2-Aminodihydro[1,3]thiazines as BACE 2 inhibitors and their preparation and use in the treatment of diabetes.
Beauchamp, Jeremy; Benardeau, Agnes; Hilpert, Hans; Migliorini, Cristiano; Riboulet, William; Wang, Haiyan
PCT Int. Appl. (2011), WO 2011029803 A1’

No competing interests declared.