Reader Comments

Post a new comment on this article

Disease?

Posted by Dixie on 02 Jul 2009 at 16:00 GMT

This article refers to Schizophrenia as a 'disease'. How can that be so, bearing in mind the following:

If mental illness is a disease, a biochemical event, there must be:


1. Reliable evidence of a consistent cause-effect relationship between Schizophrenia, BAD, Depression, PTSD, ADHD etc and a brain disorder such as lesion, tumour, microbes or other markers

2. Evidence of a reliable diagnostic scan or test of brain, blood, urine, genes, etc that can distinguish untreated individuals with diagnoses from individuals without them

3. Evidence of a base-line standard, chemically balanced "normal" personality against which imbalance can be measured and shown corrected by pharmaceutical means

4. Evidence psychotropic drugs can reliably correct, heal, or cure such imbalance

No competing interests declared.